Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
scooter Wrote:I've become convinced of this. scooter, Rowain, novice: one of us three are wolves. I know it's not me, and I tend to doubt that it is novice, so logically, I believe it is probably Rowain. Add onto that thet quotes Meiz dug up from Bruinane defending him (in a somewhat odd manner too), and Rowain looks like a good target to me honestly. Zakalwe is still way up near/at the top of my list as well, so I will be happy if either one of those two are lynched. I wish I could put 1/2 vote down on each of them, but for now I will wait on my vote. Just know that unless something drastic changes, one of those two will likely get my vote.
Well...
Guess we can end the discussions 
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Ichabod Wrote:You suspect scooter, Meiz??
Hm... Interesting...
Why haven't you said so when we were debating between him and Rowain?? You were online at the time, I know it. You sticked to Rowain without saying a word about any other suspects.
If you read my posts, you can find a lot of them regarding scooter  . I talked earlier with Roland regarding him, and I mentioned that I would be willing to leave scooter as last of my wolf suspects. Rowain was another one, and I was 95% sure of his guilt.
Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
At the end of last night, this is how it broke down for me:
Lewwyn - 100%, Meiz - 80%, scooter - 60%.
I only wish novice had gotten back to me on his thoughts. I sent him my thoughts last night, but he was asleep. Guess I won't be hearing them until I die or the game ends.
Frankly Meiz, I don't trust one word out of your mouth, nor Jkaen's. No offense, but I just can't let you walk way as a "Villager" - especially not a trusted one.
I do believe zakalwe to be innocent. This is reinforced by the fact that, if he's a 'Wolf, he would be the only 'Wolf Bruindane voted to lynch - ever. I can't clear Mardoc in any way, and his voting record is as abysmal as Jkaen's (I think), but I don't think he's a 'Wolf. Call me blind, but it's how I feel. I'd put Serdoa in the Villager camp, as well, but again - no way to prove it. Beyond that, I won't speculate, but I wanted to get some of my thoughts out now.
Don't just look at the personal voting records. Look at the big picture, AND the little one. Look through the records, and follow the swings. Then, color the name of someone in orange or blue in your mind - see if it fits. It's the best I can offer at this point, but I don't see much else for us to go on.
Posts: 15,358
Threads: 112
Joined: Apr 2007
Ichabod Wrote:You suspect scooter, Meiz??
Where have you been?? He wouldn't leave me alone for the longest time.
Meiz Wrote:If you read my posts, you can find a lot of them regarding scooter . I talked earlier with Roland regarding him, and I mentioned that I would be willing to leave scooter as last of my wolf suspects. Rowain was another one, and I was 95% sure of his guilt.
Considering you were "95% sure" of Rowain's guilt and all the other innocent people you lynched, maybe it would ding the lightbulb in your head that maybe you should trust someone else's judgment rather than your own? Better yet:
Meiz Wrote:I thought novice was the baner, and that's why I "protected" him with my accusations after day 2...  .
Perhaps that's why novice is dead? You and your fellow werewolves figured he was the baner? Meiz
Posts: 15,358
Threads: 112
Joined: Apr 2007
Thanks for your thoughts Roland. They really are helping honestly. One question:
Roland Wrote:I do believe zakalwe to be innocent. This is reinforced by the fact that, if he's a 'Wolf, he would be the only 'Wolf Bruindane voted to lynch - ever.
Am I misreading this? Didn't Bruindane vote to lynch Selrahc?
Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
scooter Wrote:Thanks for your thoughts Roland. They really are helping honestly. One question:
Am I misreading this? Didn't Bruindane vote to lynch Selrahc?
Ah, yes, I believe he did. I was mostly thinking Day 1, to be honest. Poor word choice. Typing while rushed at work, as usual, gets me in trouble.
Appreciate the vote of confidence. You're the lowest on my list of suspects, so I'm not comfortable lynching you today. Nothing personal - just the way the chips fell when I was doing the records.
We have 1 wrong move to make before we're out of mistakes, although I certainly hope we don't make any more. That said, I'm not looking to take chances today, so I'm going to be going with the most likely target - even if someone convinces me Lewwyn can wait for a day. :neenernee
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
Roland Wrote:I do believe zakalwe to be innocent. This is reinforced by the fact that, if he's a 'Wolf, he would be the only 'Wolf Bruindane voted to lynch - ever. I can't clear Mardoc in any way, and his voting record is as abysmal as Jkaen's (I think), but I don't think he's a 'Wolf. Call me blind, but it's how I feel. I'd put Serdoa in the Villager camp, as well, but again - no way to prove it. Beyond that, I won't speculate, but I wanted to get some of my thoughts out now.
Bruindane voted to lynch Selrahc, Roland.
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
Duh... 
I'll try to finish reading all the post the next time, I promise...
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
I don't know about scooter, Roland. I think he tried to hard to make theories against villagers to be a wolf.
I still think Zakalwe might be the last wolf. He has been near the gallows some times now and it never seems to get support. I'll take a better look at the voting charts later to see if I can confirm this...
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
scooter Wrote:Perhaps that's why novice is dead? You and your fellow werewolves figured he was the baner?
I started to suspect novice as our baner after Selrahc lynch (added to his comments regarding baner earlier). I remembered someone saying that the best place for a villager is to be little suspected to stay alive on night, but not enough to get lynched on day. So I decided to post my real suspects first and then end my post by continuing the paranoia against novice, http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showthrea...post123627. I ended the "threatening accusations" with: "I honestly don't know... I don't expect to get any bandwagon against novice, and I'm not sure at all on this. But am I really the only one who finds his behavior a bit odd? It would definitely help the village if he would open up a bit."
I never voted against novice, or continued to suspect him. I decided to trust him as best as I can and try to work with him.
|
