WW 34--The Slugfest!

[sunrise089]

Because of something I saw in the lurker thread, any votes I make on Goreripper won't count for to-day. I wasn't about to vote him, but just to get it out of the way.

Maybe it's too meta to bring up, but I don't get this. If MJW dinged you for looking at the wrong thread that's weird but whatever, but were you required to post about it here? If so why add the "not that I was going to vote for him anyways" part?

Sunrise's post also seemed a little like he was just doing his duty. Possibly what Goreripper was getting at, too?

Doing my duty to look for bad logic and apparent contradictions...how crazy!

If the top two vote recipients I prefer lynching Jowy over Rowain, but I also prefer siding with the Rowain voters on the margin. I'll ponder that, and will be on through the deadline.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Maybe it's too meta to bring up, but I don't get this. If MJW dinged you for looking at the wrong thread that's weird but whatever, but were you required to post about it here? If so why add the "not that I was going to vote for him anyways" part?

He didn't have to talk about it but he did it anyway.

~30 minutes left

[Jowy]

Well that pretty much confirms Q as town.

[BRickAstley]

Jowy how does that confirm him? Why couldn't a scum do the exact same thing?

[Jowy]

Jowy how does that confirm him? Why couldn't a scum do the exact same thing?

Townie accidentally checks the lurker thread, sees post that argues Gore is scum. As punishment he can't vote to lynch Gore today. Makes sense.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Jowy how does that confirm him? Why couldn't a scum do the exact same thing?

Townie accidentally checks the lurker thread, sees post that argues Gore is scum. As punishment he can't vote to lynch Gore today. Makes sense.

He could be lying about his punishment though...

[Jowy]

Jowy how does that confirm him? Why couldn't a scum do the exact same thing?

Townie accidentally checks the lurker thread, sees post that argues Gore is scum. As punishment he can't vote to lynch Gore today. Makes sense.

He could be lying about his punishment though...

Yeah before you confirmed it a few posts ago Sorry for the cheap confirm, but it's there so we gotta take it.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Jowy how does that confirm him? Why couldn't a scum do the exact same thing?

Townie accidentally checks the lurker thread, sees post that argues Gore is scum. As punishment he can't vote to lynch Gore today. Makes sense.

He could be lying about his punishment though...

Yeah before you confirmed it a few posts ago Sorry for the cheap confirm, but it's there so we gotta take it.

How is me confirming that it happened is the same as confirming the punishment?

[BaII]

So BaII, these are your posts so far.

I would call out for Baii but if past experience is an indication he would panic and look super scummy and be our first proud newbie mislynch.

That said Baii you awake yet?

Ha obvious trying to get the ez innocent newbie lynch on day 1. Goregripper

On a more serious note Rowain is giving off the same edgy feel I get whenever I read his posts. He sounds the same to me from the first game I was played with him.

@Jowy I still don't get how you consider Gore lynch a win win scenario can you atleast elaborate on that before the deadline. I'm going to hold off on voting for Jabbaz until we get another response from him don't want to condem him just yet.

1. Rowain is being himself.
2. Vote Jowy for saying a Gore lynch is win/win, holding off on voting Jabbz because you don't want to condemn him just yet.

Sounds like you're considering a Jabbz vote then - why is that?
Any other reads?

I was considering the Jabbz vote because he seemed the one most likely to just go off the bandwagon. I know he's played with Rowain before so I was kinda of confused what he thought was scummy about Rowain and wanted to see how he would respond to the wagon. After his response I would lean more towards town. Even though Brick was a little trigger happy with his Rowain accusation that's not enough for me to vote on him.

[BRickAstley]

Or:

- Scum looked at the lurker thread accidentally, saw something about Goreripper (not necessarily alignment)
- Messaged/ posted in the QT towards MJW to inform him
- Realized he could post about it in the thread to gain face.
- Did so.

Just cause MJW confirms an altercation took place doesnt tell us for sure what he is.