WW11 - Civilization

[Tasunke]

[first ? is supposed to be a !] meh

[Lewwyn]

Right. And so that is why it took you half an hour to come up with that.

Calculations my arse, you are the clear calculator around here?

TI-84 or TI-83? :D

Hi my name is Lewwyn and I work 3 jobs. I have an hour and a half for lunch and I like to eat while I read news/posts from other games. I'm going out the door to my other job now which is 45 minutes away. Who knows if I'll have time to be online when I'm there.

Don't try to call people out based on time. Don't you have a baby to take care of?

[MJW (ya that one)]

Hi my name is Lewwyn and I work 3 jobs. I have an hour and a half for lunch and I like to eat while I read news/posts from other games. I'm going out the door to my other job now which is 45 minutes away. Who knows if I'll have time to be online when I'm there.

Don't try to call people out based on time. Don't you have a baby to take care of?

I call you out! :neenernee The fact that you work 3 jobs causes you to suffer a lot these games. I think you are not guilty due to you anger though.

I think Tusanke was waiting for you to post something so he could react to it and post a counter response. He does not understand that having the "green dot" on means that you could be AFK. (Gustarin logined-in-and-out so it was obvious he was not AFK.)

Tusanke calling you out for taking 30 minutes for such a short post (he thought!) slightly points to him being a villger. However, is tone was mocking so he could have been mocking you for taking so long to make a short post in a "legit" fashion.

[Gaspar]

Hi my name is Lewwyn

Liar, Lewwyn's totally not your name.

Ichabod's response is well-reasoned enough but I don't think it necessarily changes the underlying reasoning behind voting him in the first place. The downside of course to being good at this game is it is very believable that you can come up with a reasonable excuse for why you're acting a certain way. So I still think you're on the radar.

I don't really love that night devolved into this weird Tasunke-Mardoc fest as I think Tasunke is weird enough that this could just be his style and Mardoc is unsure of himself enough that it is next to impossible to really tell what's up. I do think (and no offense, friend) that if Mardoc did roll wolf he'd have had a very hard time ginning up the mental strength to lie a lot and probably would be exceedingly quiet. So I think this is just two novice villagers making typical newbie villager mistakes. Unfortunately it just ends up being noise.

I didn't like scooter tonight. Reminds me a bit of the part in WW7 where he was flailing away at stuff without real conviction. I don't really want to point a finger at him just yet simply because the next 8 hours or so are Euro only time so we can always come back to him, even if we actually have to make a decision today.

So let's look at the Europeans. Rowain has been very quiet for himself but I attribute that mostly to the fact that he gets himself killed on day 1 like literally half the time and is probably trying to just stay beneath the radar a bit. For some reason I buy zak's excuse at the moment, but as always, he bears watching. I still have absolutely no read on novice but that will have to wait. Meiz seems Meiz-like. Catwalk is a little off but I buy his explanation. Slowcheetah has been exceedingly inactive. Jkaen's a dangerous werewolf because he's always inactive so he has solid cover.

Let's try Jkaen on for size.

[Tasunke]

Don't you have a baby to take care of?

The baby went to sleep several hours ago

(and I may follow suit soon enough, perhaps in the next hour or two)

[novice]

Tasunke seems to think this is an alliance building game. If he were a wolf one would think his scumbuddies would have corrected him.

I have some other stuff to comment on too, I need a real keyboard for that though. So later.

[Jkaen]

I was going to vote Tasunke but novice's point above is a pretty good one.

As I stated the vote on Ichabod was to try and put him under pressure, hasn't really worked.

So far from what I see the votes on me range from 'why not' to 'if he is a WW he is a good one' not really sure how to defend against that.

Scooters reasoning seemed a bit odd recently, but as has been pointed out 'normal' scooter is a WW

I got called away fromt he computer in the middle of typing this, so going to hit enter and follow up on comments I missed (this is response to Novice's Tasunke alliance building post)

[Jkaen]

well didn't I miss alot.

Ok, need another proper review before the end of the day, but far from convinced on Ichabod, and don't want to lynch a potentially valuable villager right now, so will park on MJW who is being as confusing to me as always

[Catwalk]

I just went through all posts by novice. While he does contribute, there is a very large ratio of no-content posts. And the contributing posts tend to be really short. Does this match his usual playing style?

POST COUNT (top 8)
34 scooter
33 Tasunke
30 Lewwyn
24 Catwalk
23 novice
23 MJW (ya that one)
17 Cyneheard
14 zakalwe

Breakdown of his posts (IMO)
14 fluff posts: 5 - 49 - 52 - 59 - 89 - 121 - 127 - 128 - 132 - 176 - 177 - 198 (debatable) - 210 (debatable) - 226
7 very brief posts with some content: 15 - 22 - 27 - 123 - 125 - 130 - 276
2 posts with a bit more content: 174 - 209

Maybe it's just his playing style, but this looks a lot to me like a wolf feigning activity and contribution.

[Jkaen]

Unfortunately yes it does match his standard playing style.

Generally low content posts, but a few real gems and late voting near deadline is what I associate with Novice