WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[Lewwyn]

Wha... yours is missing?

Yes.

[Lewwyn]

BTW I think the cases on VM and Bigger were bad.

I suspect Injera and Zak.

[Rowain]

BTW I think the cases on VM and Bigger were bad.

I suspect Injera and Zak.

I think we would profit more from your wisdom if you share it before the lynch.

[Lewwyn]

Yeah I meant to get back online last night, but I went out with friends around 7 drank more than I intended too, passed out in my wife's arms and woke up hungover today. Day ends are at 6 am for me.

I'm going out right now, but I intend to drink less so hopefully I'll share a few insights before a possible death tonight.

[zakalwe]

BTW I think the cases on VM and Bigger were bad.

I suspect Injera and Zak.

Is there any connection between the first and the second paragraph here?

[pindicator]

Actually, no he can't.

It's normal that there SHOULD be a rule against this and I will add one to the first post.

Yeah, I double checked the rules because it seemed like that was a normal thing to have. My thinking in asking was that if he was lying to us about the role reveal then it was a (admittedly slight) chance we'd catch it in what he put down for a post quote since he'd have to make that up too.

[pindicator]

So we had a 2 villager race there (if we believe Bigger).



I think we will find (at least) 1 wolf in the late VM-switchers. pindicator, slowcheetah and waterbat. All 3 were voting for Bigger before and switched to VM after zak voted for VM
And I think we have at least 2 wolves in those with a useless vote:
Lewwyn, TT, Jkaen, Sareln, Mattimeo
From those Mattimeo,Lewwyn have been very silent. But I don't like TT's 'Oh I misread the deadline and missed the post about VM getting lynched'-post too.
(And of course Jkaen beeps as wolf to me with anything he says and does).

For day 2 I would like to concentrate on the first group (pind,slow,water) and see if the second group starts to contribute or not.

I take it you don't believe Bigger's role claim then? And if you do believe his reveal, what reason would a wolf have to jump villager to villager so late in the voting?

[Lewwyn]

Is there any connection between the first and the second paragraph here?

Worried Much?

I think you locked on to a target and didn't do very much to look around during Day 1. Not seriously at least. Very atypical of villager Zak who makes a point of getting in a number of different faces. VM was extremely convenient with his post restriction. So yeah my read is wolf. Easy.

I think Rowain seems pretty normal and villagery. He's getting on peoples nerves in a very Rowain type of way. Straight play.

Injera is suspicious because of the post dearth. But its not simply that. It is that Injera was not posting for a long while, then someone mentioned it and Injera posted shortly after. Was the timing coincidental? Maybe. But I was in Injera's head as GM last game and I can see it now too. "Lay low, STFU, and let someone lynch themselves."

Meiz. Well I dunno right now. I'm half and half.

I believe Bigger is a vegetarian werewolf because A) that is something that Uber would put into this game. B) I got a villager read through Day 1. Thing is after last game no one can really trust full on confessions from Bigger because they don't want to get fooled again. So. I think Bigger knew that and he knew that if he was scanned as a "werewolf" he'd be lynched no matter what he said. AT the same time claiming Vegie WW could be a mistake as people might just want to lynch him now anyway so that they AREN"T fooled again...

Jkaen null read.

Mnnn. Pin is possibly a WW again. I would be pissed if he were so lucky.\

TT,waterbat,sareln,mattimeo? null

Novice. We should lynch him too since we have lynched one post restriction and got a villager. Lynch the other get a wolf?

Molach, my Man, Molach. Innocent. Very. Don't get dead now ya'hear. I think Molach was the one who noticed Injera hadn't posted in a while.

[Rowain]

I take it you don't believe Bigger's role claim then? And if you do believe his reveal, what reason would a wolf have to jump villager to villager so late in the voting?

I do believe his claim.

Perhaps to get browny points with say zak? Besides it easier to defend your vote when you are on the same target as he is.

And I fail to see any other place for a wolf to be. You 3 all wanted to lynch Bigger and suddenly you 3 have seen the light and are now voting with Bigger vs VM. Yes I absolutly do believe that one of you 3 is a wolf.

[pindicator]

I do believe his claim.

Perhaps to get browny points with say zak? Besides it easier to defend your vote when you are on the same target as he is.

Does this mean you think zak is village? Or do you mean something else?

And I fail to see any other place for a wolf to be. You 3 all wanted to lynch Bigger and suddenly you 3 have seen the light and are now voting with Bigger vs VM. Yes I absolutly do believe that one of you 3 is a wolf.

I'm not saying you're wrong, there could be a wolf amongst slowcheetah or waterbat but I'm not one (sorry Lewwyn, I wasn't lucky enough to draw scum the only two times I've played). When I cast the vote that tied Bigger & VM one thought I had was that it would be interesting to see who votes which way after to break the tie, because I was reasonably sure at least one of them was a wolf. But with Bigger's claim being plausible that would mean they were both villagers. So why would a wolf stick his neck out like that to swap from villager to villager? Just to get on zak's good side? That seems rather weak attempt to get the favor of one person when it's going to trigger the radar of every other person paying attention.