Werewolf 2 Lurker Thread: Spoilers!

[novice]

danski was eaten
villager

Dantski's death seems to have gone unnoticed in the Game thread... Anyway, GG Dantski.

[zakalwe]

Would have made more sense to kill Lewwyn, I think? He was 100% confirmed innocent as a mason. Dantski was just scryed, a case could be made that he could theoretically have another secret role that scries as innocent.

Though Dantski has been making much better calls than Lewwyn so I guess that's the reason they chose him.

[sunrise089]

If you are smart you know that a mod's angry does not go unused.

I've seen plenty of examples of a (good) mod's anger going unused actually.

[Dantski]

Votes against your wrongly spelled name shouldn't count

[MJW (ya that one)]

Also, wtf? There's SEVEN werewolves! . If the village messes up 4 times, they're dead, even with a baner save. The funniest thing about that is that MJW has been PMing me and Kyan every day saying that there's a secret "godfather" role (he suspects Roland). Me and Kyan have just been ignoring him. I can't believe he was actually right about that.

[luddite]

yeah well... it wasn't roland at least...

[zakalwe]

Some interesting thoughts here.

What I think is curious is its almost as though Serdoa is playing on the wrong team. He's acting like he screwed up yesterday and is mad about it, particularly the sour grapes "we're only winning because the game is rigged." 6 wolves out of 21 players is a pretty stiff hill to climb to start with, and the way the decisions have gone down since then have been decidely anti-village, so if we pull this off, I'm not going to be feeling like we got any gifts. My best guess, Serdoa is a villager who gave himself the secret role "Wants the wolves to win" and screwed up yesterday.

[novice]

Some interesting thoughts here.

I was coming in here to post the same thing. That is amazing by Gaspar.

[Kyan]

I'm about to come accross as a dick, but...

I find it EXTREMELY coincidental of some of Gaspar's inspirational thinking. Firstly, he has mentioned in the game thread that Selrahc's role may have changed between putting himself forward for mayor and being made the devil.

This example is more telling in my eyes. Who would have thought of that? Nobody in this thread had any inkling... Suddenly, immediately after it's revealed in the lurker thread, the post appears.

With this newest revelation, well, maybe im too suspicious but yeah. It's also worth noting that both of these revelations were only revealed by him after this was revealed in the lurker thread. No other player has voiced any opinions like these, nor had any of us lurkers previously.

[zakalwe]

*Signs in for the meta-WW2 game.*

In spoiler tags just in case.

If Gaspar is cheating like you imply (no point in sugarcoating it), why would he go out of his way to incriminate himself in the game thread? It's not like he is using the information he has learned here as very direct support for his arguments. He could easily build an argument for Serdoa's innocence without painting him as a possessed. No matter how you spin it, swinging the vote at the last minute towards lynching a wolf is hardly the most incriminating of actions.

Possible cheating aside, it really seems like the villagers have a much better handle on things now, and a villager victory seems quite likely to me now. For all we know, your own (illegal) hinting in the game thread by re-emphasizing the owl mechanics after you were dead may have contributed heavily to that.