WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[Rowain]

Yeah, if Bob gets saved last-minute so we can lynch a villager, I'm going to have some strong day 2 thoughts about a couple people who seemed determined to save him.

What if Bob gets lynched and turns out a villager?

What makes you sure that Cyneheard,Adrien (or naufr) are villagers?

[Meiz]

Tally is there, thanks BRick.

Meiz, your blue-black is nigh unreadable on RB-green.

Sorry, no idea what happened there. Hopefully work when highlighting the text

[AdrienIer]

Gaspar's early game was very good (and suspicious of Pindicator BTW), he could be an excellent wolf but I'll put him on my town leans.

[pindicator]

Meiz, with 290 I was looking more for Lewwyn's thoughts on the Bob train because I remembered him nailing Bob in a past game and I wanted to get more of a read on Lewwyn.  See my previous post to AdrienIer.

Personally I don't know how i feel about the Bob train.  I don't like how unhelpful and antagonistic his posts are.  But that's what I remember from Bob as both wolf and villager, so I'm trying to look past that.  I don't like him enough to defend him like I thought some newbies deserved, as the personal attacks don't belong here.

[Lewwyn]

Sorry about the Adrien quote, its stuck on multi-quote and I have to delete it every single time I post in this thread, I don't know how to get rid of it. I keep going back to the first page and clicking multiquote to deactivate it and it doesn't work...


I just want to clarify that I find Scooter's threat VERY scummy. It's pre end of day and he's threatening people before we even know how stuffs going to shake out. Why not let people play it out and then call people on it the next day rather than forwarn people? You don't KNOW Bob is a wolf so you can't say with such certainty. Instead you are trying to make sure he dies. Your extra certainty is scummy.

[scooter]

Two things:

1) Who is determined to save him?

2) I think its very counter productive to try and make people afraid of voting for what they feel is best.

1) Well it's interesting that Gaspar was the first vote on Bob right after I was the first to point out Bob looked suspect, and then after Bob got into a lynchable position, suddenly he "doesn't like the way the train formed on him" and starts looking for other options, despite Bob showing up in the middle of this and engaging in blatantly anti-town behavior?


2) You're right, and I should have worded that differently. But I don't love how much cover we're giving wolves right now either.

[scooter]

Previous post was crossposted with Lewwyn.

[Commodore]

@Commodore
Do you believe that Bob, Lewwyn & Gaspar are all 3 scum?

What conclusions do you see if Bob gets lynched and turns out as a wolf and what if he turns out as a villager?

It's day one. I feel like all of you are scum (hey, the Man Who Was Tuesday thing did happen to me once before).

In all seriousness, I'm not assured of anything right now, but I do find it suspicious how this Rally to Save Bob is being spearheaded by some of the people I was nervous being on his train with. If Bob is a wolf, the pack must be pretty happy to have a murky *two* other candidates available.

On the other two trains, Cyneheard reads to me as genuinely flabbergasted and drained. Oh course that doesn't mean he's not also a wolf, but I don't see the skepticism about his defense. AdrienIer is floating a little less now, definitely not clear but I've yet to see any red flags.

If Bob get lynched and he turns wolf, I think we need to carefully look at who switched to save him. If he turns village, I suspect that at least one of my fellow train members is a wolf, and we might want to look who undermined the Cyneheard train that was rolling along.

[El Grillo]

Rough morning, catching up on the overnight posts.

Rowain, I voted to prod Bob at the time as one of the remaining vets who hadn't had much to say. I was hopeful at the time that putting a third vote on him would prompt him to respond with some more reads of his own, which in hindsight according to his posts he wasn't going to do in any case. As I said earlier I disagree with his choice here and think it's anti-town (and for that I didn't even get a direct mention in his post, I presume I got lumped into "and others" during his critique of Lewwyn).

Another thing that stood out is Cyneheard's silence over the past 18 hours as he's become a clear lynch alternative. He left us with a (plausible-enough) excuse that he regretted signing up for the game, but telling us that you're not enthusiastic and planning to contribute less hurts the town, especially if it's true. He set himself up to be another easy mislynch, because we can't judge his intentions, only his posts.

I'm keeping my vote on Bob.

[AdrienIer]

With 15mn remaining and my name being near the top I'm going to go for a weak Bob vote to avoid an unpleasant surprise 10s before deadline