Role Deck of Madness Draft Feedback

[Rowain]

Quick thought: if you roll strong town cards, maybe don't opt to play scum? I keep feeling like I'm missing something in this thread and in the WW35 lurker thread. Namely, that in a normal game if someone wants scum and gets town that's not considered a bug. It's unclear to me that in a setup that at least offers the possibility of making interesting choices the game is flawed because some choice combinations make it the right decision to play town.

Because that is like handing a child a box of candy but forbidding it to eat some.

[zakalwe]

Some incentives to stray outside your comfort zone might be nice or even necessary. . If we had simply lynched people blindly in order of how much they usually enjoy being liable they were to pick scum, we would have won WW35 quite handily.

Edited for precision.

[Rowain]

If we had simply lynched people blindly in order of how much they usually enjoy being scum, we would have won WW35 quite handily.

I have my doubts. Especially regarding Jkaen.

[zakalwe]

Jkaen, TT, Q, and Lewwyn were all high up on my "liable to pick scum" list. Novice was a bit further down but certainly not at the bottom.