WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[Rowain]

El Grillo voted naufragar , Cyneheard, Commodore and Bob

Gaspar voted  Rowain, Cyneheard, pindi, Bob, Cyneheard

Cyneheard voted scooter, pindi, SD

Interesting points for me is that scooter and Cyneheard both used their first vote on each other

Both Meiz and Serdoa left them self a way to move from Cyneheard open but did not jump.

I still think we should lynch AdrienIer

[Rowain]

what the hell are these roles? I need to read about them before i can say anything.

in short the Jack of all trade can have any poweer but in limited supply (usually 1 shot of several powers)

Hider picks a target to hide behind becoming immune to kills but if his target is killed than he dies too. I expect this was the case here.

tracker follows people and can tell where they go.

[GeneralKilCavalry]

Ok, so correct me if i'm wrong, but el grillo "hid" behind gaspar, who happened to get killed? How the hell did cyneheard die then?

With this many roles and no prior disclosure of roles (something I am totally unused to) I have no clue how to evaluate this.

[pindicator]

Lots of crosspost on my last. I need to think and type faster.

I had to go look up hider. Am I right that El Grillo probably had a power with the hiding aspect as a drawback but he used it on either Cyneheard or Gaspar and got unlucky that his target was killed? Then either a vig shot on Cyneheard or there's multiple scum factions? But Cyneheard had plenty of suspicion and taking him out would have been a good use of a vig shot.

[Rowain]

I don't want to spam the thread too much again, but Man I still can't get over the night results. Vigilante (I guess?) you Da real MVP.

Also general thought... Are there 3 Wolves and a Serial Killer?

Are you speculating about setup ?

[Chevalier Mal Fet]

I don't want to spam the thread too much again, but Man I still can't get over the night results. Vigilante (I guess?) you Da real MVP.

Also general thought... Are there 3 Wolves and a Serial Killer?

Hey guys. Checking in. I'm a bit glad that Bob turned out to be town - not that we lynched him, but that I was correct in not thinking he was a good lynch. I obviously whiffed on Cyneheard, though, so right now my scum-o-meter is clearly calibrated too much towards "town" and not enough towards suspicion.

I need time to read and process, but I wanted to at least be present.

Lewwyn, I didn't correct my mistake on you mostly because of the amount of effort to dig through the volume of posts, and we all know by now that it was a mistake. My main effort is to concentrate on more recent events, but I'll try and get a good summary up soon.

I know I wasn't worried about the mistake so much with the amount of posting in this game.

But are you saying that you are clearing me because I hopped onto Cyneheard at the end? Because I wouldn't clear me for that. A wolf might know I'm a villager though and think the village would just accept me as villager now though. Honestly, I thought I would be fighting a bit of resistance today.

No, I'm saying I was mistaken in attributing to you something you didn't say. You're definitely not clear in my book - I keep veering between "wildly scummy" and "eh, maybe town after all?" on you.

[Rowain]

Ok, so correct me if i'm wrong, but el grillo "hid" behind gaspar, who happened to get killed? How the hell did cyneheard die then?

With this many roles and no prior disclosure of roles (something I am totally unused to) I have no clue how to evaluate this.

Vig-shot would be my guess. (vigilante can kill a target in the night) If so this is a clearly better shot than Lewwyn was along time ago

PS I would not concentrate on how many roles there might be. Might be that this result is just a an exception.

[Meiz]

My first instict is Pind scum. I think he played a classic scum day 1 game, participating and giving reads but non-committal, and avoiding aggression back from his targets. Then a concrete pinpointed attack on IMO easy target not near the lynch block (and avoiding easy badwagon on villager Bob). I said it day 1 already but his vote is perfect for Cyneheard save. Pindicator His self aware of it as well, but claiming Adrien did it :D

The adrien vote pulled people off Cyne, namely me and Rowain I think? And it let Adrien go to Bob to "save himself". Or maybe adrien is innocent and he chose Bob over Cyne?

I don't think Adrien had high hopes on starting to move people away from Cyneheard to Pind. I don't think he's persuasive enough to think that. His suspicion felt earnest, but of course I'm colored by the fact that I suspected Pind as well.

[GeneralKilCavalry]

I see your point Rowain, this is just very unusual for me. Usually, a large part of this game is the "math" of who could be whom, and people start claiming "i'm the doctor, no they are the doctor" etc. This is a different meta for me, but I almost like it more.

Kind of a trivial observation, but Cyne's aggression @SD makes me less suspicious of SD. The deeper question is, why did he try to promote the SD bandwagon, and who was he trying to distract from?

Cyne's interactions with me is what pushed some of you to vote for him. Gaspar, Lewwyn, SD are the main interactors here.

[Rowain]

My first instict is Pind scum. I think he played a classic scum day 1 game, participating and giving reads but non-committal, and avoiding aggression back from his targets. Then a concrete pinpointed attack on IMO easy target not near the lynch block (and avoiding easy badwagon on villager Bob). I said it day 1 already but his vote is perfect for Cyneheard save. Pindicator His self aware of it as well, but claiming Adrien did it :D

I know I'm putting my foot in mouth here but your attack on pindi for his Adrien vote looks scummy to me.

At the time pindi made his vote Cyneheard was nowhere near danger. He had exactly 1 vote then ( Gaspars ).