Werewolf 13: Lurker Thread [No Live Players]

[waterbat]

Scooter, i was getting at the fact that win condition is presented such that this part doesnt need to happen:

then the last remaining wolf night-kills and wins

so if the last-villager is SILVER, it doesn't matter.

If he isn't silver, then yeah - normal game play means the wolf simply wins - unless you open MJW's wormhole spoiler above.

MJW:

Brilliant MJW! The last villager has all the information necessary to pull this off. If the wolves get nervous and kill each other at night, a surprise win for the village! if they don't, and both kill Sareln, its a 1W vs 1W at the end and uber's comment comes into play. Its still possible one of the wolves will get the solo win -- definitely an interesting situation.

[waterbat]

In the end it wouldn't have mattered with the way the night kills fell - you'd just have another wolf left alive instead. So of anybody should be annoyed it is the short and fat wolves.

true! some wolf was going to be left under the covers. Also Novice, I have made a big note to myself for future WW games:

[SIZE="6"]Dear waterbat, if your packmate wants to kill novice, DO SO! No questions asked, pull the trigger!
[/SIZE]

[uberfish]

why Sareln, why

[pindicator]

[SIZE="6"]if your packmate wants to kill novice, DO SO! No questions asked, pull the trigger!
[/SIZE]

Zak, I hope you're reading this :neenernee

[novice]

@Waterbat: I hope you don't draw wolf then.
@Injera: yeah, playing wolf is exhausting.

[Rowain]

In the end it wouldn't have mattered with the way the night kills fell - you'd just have another wolf left alive instead. So of anybody should be annoyed it is the short and fat wolves.

I think had Bigger kept silent on day 3 we would have had a far more interesting endgame and especially far more interesting days after day 4.

[novice]

why Sareln, why

I don't see how Sareln can force a no lynch? He could avoid kingmaking by voting no lynch and letting random.org decide between Bigger and Injera.

[novice]

I think had Bigger kept silent on day 3 we would have had a far more interesting endgame and especially far more interesting days after day 4.

Yes. And it would have been even more interesting to see how day 3 had gone if you had avoided a claim as well.

[Rowain]

Yes. And it would have been even more interesting to see how day 3 had gone if you had avoided a claim as well.

Nope it would have been an infight between zak and me - ending with me getting lynched and zak walking away happily.

[scooter]

Nope it would have been an infight between zak and me - ending with me getting lynched and zak walking away happily.

Or we could have just lynched Injera like I wanted?

In the end it wouldn't have mattered with the way the night kills fell - you'd just have another wolf left alive instead. So of anybody should be annoyed it is the short and fat wolves.

In terms of outcome it would have made no difference, but in reality it's a huge difference. As a result, villagers like me were reduced to watching the wolves play the game at night while the daytime mattered pretty much not at all. Rowain's role-claim was unnecessary IMO and shot off a chain reaction that made the villagers pointless.