WW48: Melllvar's Grand Competition!

[Meiz]

Good morning everyone! Apologies for not being around yesterday (and it's very concerning for me that no one noticed - how many other people are lurking and getting away with it?).

We have 48 hours. As long as people post their thoughts as widely as possible, doesn't matter that much if they don't come early in the day. Just don't wait until deadline is closing and you "have to choose from the available options".

I'll use this post to include a strange fact. Gaspar says he stopped roleplaying and even changed his avatar. Yet he sounds just like before  

 

[WarriorKnight]

I'll use this post to include a strange fact. Gaspar says he stopped roleplaying and even changed his avatar. Yet he sounds just like before  

 

Waldorf: That was wonderful!

Statler: Bravo!

Waldorf: I loved it!

Statler: Ah, it was great!

Waldorf: Well, it was pretty good.

Statler: Well, it wasn't bad...

Waldorf: Uh, there were parts of it that weren't very good though.

Statler: It could have been a lot better.

Waldorf: I didn't really like it.

Statler: It was pretty terrible.

Waldorf: It was bad.

Statler: It was awful!

Waldorf: It was terrible!

Statler: Take him away!

Both: Boo! Boo!

[Meiz]

[Gaspar]

FWIW, I'm the first one to criticize Rowain's... unorthodox play generally. But really, he's just putting the horse before the cart and telling us what's in the cart. We lynch Commodore for reasons repeated ad nauseum. If he flips scum, then pindicator is the obvious next target, for reasons repeated ad nauseum. If Commodore flips town, it doesn't clear pindicator, but it does make all the other circumstantial evidence around pindicator void and we need to reassess him based on his play today. I don't see anything dangerous about it.

I'm not sure if the folks criticizing that are scum or just missing that point, so I figured I'd restate it.

RE: other stuff so that we're not spending an early day only talking about two people...

If I were still roleplaying I'd have just called them obtuse idiots rather than suggesting they missed the point.

Adrien is definitely rising up my suspicion as well, as he is using the psycho killer strategy (you're talking a lot, but you're not saying anything.) I actually thought he was lurking until I double-checked and there is nothing there. He did mention Gaz right before the night-kill, which is probably a point in his favor.

GES still waiting on that magnum opus...

Did Kaiser get targeted by a muzzle?

[WarriorKnight]

@Gaspar regarding Kaiser:

Btw. I remain having a busy weekend, I will likely only be able to invest some time and effort around 3 PM CEST on Sunday, so I will be quite for roughly the first 1/4 of day2.

[Rowain]

@Cyneheard
Perhaps it is even Gazglums role that to stay hidden. I don't know Patsy Stone - is she something like a secret agent?.
What we know Gazglum is dead and while the probability for him being town is indeed a lot higher than otherwise we can't take that for granted.

Can we now let Gazglum rest in peace and concentrate on what matters = scumhunting ok.

I would like that you now put as many words and thoughts in a post about your reads of the players as you did for that dead horse.

[Cyneheard]

Adrien is definitely rising up my suspicion as well, as he is using the psycho killer strategy (you're talking a lot, but you're not saying anything.)  I actually thought he was lurking until I double-checked and there is nothing there.  He did mention Gaz right before the night-kill, which is probably a point in his favor.

So that's a point in his favor because you'd think the wolves would NOT want to talk about the person they're about to kill? That feels like WIFOM territory, especially if they're expecting him to flip town (which they might have been? I'm layering hypotheticals on hypotheticals here at this point though). I'm not sure that it's much of a point in his favor.

[Kaiser]

Thank you very much for inviting me to participate in this amazing mind game about werewolves and villagers. I am learning much about human and mammal deception and investigation tactics and interaction. This will represent a very good sample for further in-depth research in Kaylon.

I am back on the PC and did a quick skim, I will give everything since my last big post a good re-read (meaning I have to cover ~400 post, which is a bit disheartening) there seems to be a lot of new data available to look at.

I have seen that Rowain and others have been asking me direct questions. I will get to them after getting a better overview to properly address them.

[Lewwyn]

@Cyneheard
Perhaps it is even Gazglums role that to stay hidden. I don't know Patsy Stone - is she something like a secret agent?.
What we know Gazglum is dead and while the probability for him being town is indeed a lot higher than otherwise we can't take that for granted.

Can we now let Gazglum rest in peace and concentrate on what matters = scumhunting ok.

Yes scumhunting is good. Is Gaspar scumhunting? When I died and Gaspar was dead we talked during WW46 and basically every other time he talked he was complaining that the village was ignoring why he was killed and who he suspected. Now one of the two main people Gazglum suspected was Gaspar so that makes it more difficult. But the other was GES. I don't think ignoring what Gazglum thought was necessarily a tell, but in the case of Gaspar it makes me suspicious. If Gaspar is a wolf he would kill the guy who is suspicious of him without a doubt. Village Gaspar would also be very concerned with why and what the dead person had stated. I didn't like Gaspar's first post of the day when he came in and said nothing had changed his mind and he was voting for commodore. He has followed up with enough discussion afterwards that I'm less worried about it.

In any case I don't think completely ignoring Gazglum and what he's said is the correct thing to do.

[Lewwyn]

I think that exchange may have won my heart.

You are easily fooled my friend?

It may have also won my vote. The day isn't even half over yet.