WW #43 - The Asha'man

[Gazglum]

Re Zak's death, that just makes me laugh when I remember Prometheus' statistics about how unlikely it was anybody else would be a hider.

[Rowain]

Yes, but even though he is a cop it doesn't mean he scanned me.

That's is true but if someone claims cop and then votes for somebody chances are good that is what happened.

[Rowain]

BTW Gaz your mentioning Jabbz pm's to you are borderline lawbreaking. As they remove any doubt you are a cop.

[Gazglum]

BTW Gaz your mentioning Jabbz pm's to you are borderline lawbreaking.

I'm a creative guy, maybe I made it up for verisimilitude.

[Rowain]

BTW Gaz your mentioning Jabbz pm's to you are borderline lawbreaking.

I'm a creative guy, maybe I made it up for verisimilitude.

That would be very low but it would beg the question if you even are a villager/cop then. Maybe zak died because he hid behind you?
Do really want to go this road?

[novice]

I think his point is that mentioning a PM proves nothing as it could be made up. So it isn't lawbreaking.

[novice]

Novice (not quoting post for purposes of length), is your vote on me unrelated to your post regarding Zak, or are you seeing something I'm not?

Unrelated.

[novice]

Well he would not hide behind Dp101 and fenn. He would not hide behind me . For Gazglum or Jkaen but both were likely NK-targets so I wonder if he gambled with his life there.

From those that remain : Meiz, Lewwyn, novice it is you novice whom he would love to see cleared . You are also the closest to the sure-town end in his list. So I think you would be his primary target.

I was thinking about this while watching two episodes of White Collar, and I agree that, absent clues to the contrary, Zak probably continued his "hide behind a likely townie" policy. I think that translates to Meiz, Lewwyn or me.

In my defense I'm pretty sure Zak noticed Gazglum's "breadcrumb" too, so he may have felt it unnecessary to clear me.

[novice]

Novice (not quoting post for purposes of length), is your vote on me unrelated to your post regarding Zak, or are you seeing something I'm not?

Unrelated.

So, I'm sorry that we're not engaging more with you, Dp. The reasons for voting you aren't really ones you can explain away, though. To quote Zak:

Dp101. His contributions are not convincing. Voted for anyone but Prometheus yesterday. His sudden characterization of a couple of Novice posts as "very suspicious" seems extremely convenient. Discarded Mafia Lover, showing that he was willing to play as Mafia.

IMO this just makes you an objectively good lynch. To defend you need to find other reasons from your own play that show you're likely town, or find someone else who is an even better lynch.

[Dp101]

Novice (not quoting post for purposes of length), is your vote on me unrelated to your post regarding Zak, or are you seeing something I'm not?

Unrelated.

So, I'm sorry that we're not engaging more with you, Dp. The reasons for voting you aren't really ones you can explain away, though. To quote Zak:

Dp101. His contributions are not convincing. Voted for anyone but Prometheus yesterday. His sudden characterization of a couple of Novice posts as "very suspicious" seems extremely convenient. Discarded Mafia Lover, showing that he was willing to play as Mafia.

IMO this just makes you an objectively good lynch. To defend you need to find other reasons from your own play that show you're likely town, or find someone else who is an even better lynch.

Thanks for actually giving reasons why I am scum and how to not appear scum rather than just "your reads are crap and your play is inconsistent" which is kind of hard to actually debate.