WW 34--The Slugfest!

[Rowain]

I re-e-e-e-eally hope that you re joking here, I don't see a vet like zak getting nervous about first day joke posting.

Have you read more of the thread?

Why is everybody saying Zak is scum, but then not voting for him?

Who says zak is scum?

Reckon you'll still be around to lynch him after those two days?

What exactly are you asking here?

Oh, was that a joke? Good!

What do you think was a joke and what was you asking in your first question.

[Jowy]

Do you think Zak is scum or was it a joke?

[BRickAstley]

Yeah, I can also get behind Rowain, though after some more posts it'll probably end up feeling like town Rowain doing his town Rowain thing anyways.

[BRickAstley]

And Rowain yes I have, and you seem to be the one that is moreso trying to go back and justify odd acting than zak or anyone else at the moment.

[novice]

If you guys are going to spam the thread with gifs, at least have the decency rehost them on dropbox (Bob for mayor!) so I can view them from work.

I re-e-e-e-eally hope that you re joking here, I don't see a vet like zak getting nervous about first day joke posting.

Well that reasoning doesn't apply since Zak said he thought Rowain was serious.

Goreripper, because the "blunt, laconic alter-ego" routine is already wearing really thin.

I tend to agree, and would probably vote GoreRipper now if I wasn't already.

Or alter the colour slightly to fuck with Novice.

Hah, doesn't work, as long as it looks reddish it's counted.

[Lewwyn]

C'mon Rowain. You followed up on novice's "Zak seems grey" thing with "Zak rings my scum meter, but let's not lynch him for 2 days". Possible motives:
A) you think Zak is scum and he's your buddy
B) you think Zak is scum and you want him to stay alive as third party
C) you know Zak is scum but want everyone else to think he's scum so you don't actually have to lead the charge because you're scum
D) You don't think Zak is scum, but you want to make sure everyone keeps Zak in mind in case he is scum
E) You think Zak is too important to kill even if he's scummy (Trying to think like you...?)

Four fifths of the reasons that I can think you would say what you said are bad for town.

So do you think he's scum or not?

[novice]

Actually to reconfirm and elaborate on my Goreripper vote (I hear vague and mysterious is so 2014):

Ok. It looked like a serious question, that's all.

No. At no time. In no place. In no world. In no universe. Did that look like a serious any thing.

Change your avatar to Drax The Destroyer because you are an alien with no conce0t of humor. All though town points for that because mafia Zakalwe is fat and funny.

First paragraph attacks Zak's credibility. Second paragraph backs out from actually voting him. Seems fishy.

Goreripper is what I meant, silly tapatalk won't do enbolden words

If that was meant to be a vote you need to post it in red.

[Rowain]

Do you think Zak is scum or was it a joke?

So do you think he's scum or not?

No I don't think he is scum with any assurance but I found his reaction odd which put him on my radar (=pinging my scum-o-meter). But so far nothing what he did or didn't do makes me sure enough to deserve a vote. Not to mention your point E (you might find that bad for town but I disagree here).

OTOH BRick declaring that zak wouldn't take it seriously while zak has apparently done that and using this wrong logic as a reason to lynch me smells a lot like scum.

[BRickAstley]

Ok, you're right, I guess I did miss that from zak. Let me get outta joke post mode and re-examine what happened.

Zak: joke post
Rowain: prodding/joke post
Zak: defense against prodding
Rowain: Finger of Suspicion
Zak: explanation of previous post
Rowain: reasons for FoS
Zak: "Ok"

And based on that, I think I still would find Rowain to be the more guilty one of the two, because I can sympathize with zak not wanting to let people start to slowly make dirt to have to dump on him later, and Rowain's response seems to fall in line with a goal of trying to have someone already existing on zak that can be called back to later.

Also keep in mind, this early a lot of this is entirely conjecture and reading into words that is more likely to not be reasonable later on, but I'm trying to start somewhere.

[BRickAstley]

Do you think Zak is scum or was it a joke?

So do you think he's scum or not?

No I don't think he is scum with any assurance but I found his reaction odd which put him on my radar (=pinging my scum-o-meter). But so far nothing what he did or didn't do makes me sure enough to deserve a vote. Not to mention your point E (you might find that bad for town but I disagree here).

OTOH BRick declaring that zak wouldn't take it seriously while zak has apparently done that and using this wrong logic as a reason to lynch me smells a lot like scum.

Okay, I could take that argument about the scum-o-meter, but I find issue that you followed it with:

...but I have decided to prefer zak not getting lynched during the first 2 days.

That statement seems to say "I think he's worthy of a vote I just don't want to day 1" , not "nothing he did makes me sure enough to deserve a vote".

As for what I said yes, my claim that zak wouldn't take that seriously has false, and caused by me not reading the whole thread correctly and still being in a 'joke post' mood about it all. I would find it scummy too, but all I can say is to attribute it to stupidity, not slyness or craftiness.