Realms Beyond Werewolf 2 : Game Thread

[Gaspar]

And right after that scooter jumps in trying. Good job, scooter!

[scooter]

Honestly, we're winning this game more than anything because the wolves are doing a piss-poor job during the day. 4 Days, and I'm the only innocent villager you've been able to cast any consistent suspicion on. Play better, wolves, it would make the game more fun for the rest of us.

In the midst of all the debating, this made me smile . We can taunt the wolves all day long if we want, because they have to kill the seer tonight . 2 for 3 suckas!!!

[scooter]

And right after that scooter jumps in trying. Good job, scooter!

More than once in my post I invited you to defend yourself or to refute/correct things that I said. Please do try to change my mind if you are innocent, because I don't know who to accuse right now. You getting upset because people are pointing out that you are suspicious does you no favors though. Using a defense of "hey I mess up, so what?" is a pretty weak defense, because if you are a wolf, your "messups" could be very deliberate.

Here's the thing. With each person you have to evaluate what would they do if they are a villager, and what would they do if they are a WW. I did that with all 3 people in my post, and I outlined why the WW shoe seems to fit pretty well for them. That said, I don't feel one of them fits well enough to accuse yet (notice no red fonts), so I'm asking for each of these people to explain themselves. You reacting like that only raised my suspicion further rather than lowering it, so I suggest you try for real now please, because I want to know who to vote for today.

[Roland]

Scooter, for once in this entire campaign I agree with you. Letting Uberfish lie for one night might be the better choice at this point.

Unfortunately, that leaves us with a conundrum: who to vote for instead? I could pick any number of people on MY list. The problem is making it stick. I'm seeing some names in common with my own suspicions popping up, and some names on my list who are NEVER mentioned - which makes me equally question my own evidence, and question everyone the ignorance of everyone else.

I'm going to have to give this some very deep thought. I do urge everyone, though, to keep the discussion going. At the very least it helps the time pass, and more enjoyably.

Also, Gaspar, I'd consider it a personal favor if you'd ease off in your bitterness. As I've said (repeatedly), at this point it's only serving as a distraction. I understand your frustration - all too well - but it's not helping anyone here build trust, nor is it helping to illuminate the 'Wolves. You can do as you like, of course, but I think I've earned the right to make that request of you - if not for me, you probably would have been dead twice now.

[scooter]

Scooter, for once in this entire campaign I agree with you.

Don't get used to it quite yet, I don't discriminate on who I disagree/agree with, so nobody's safe from my loud mouth.

[Gaspar]

I understand your frustration - all too well - but it's not helping anyone here build trust, nor is it helping to illuminate the 'Wolves.

This is entirely a matter of perception. I've personally found many of the reactions quite illuminating. And the last post in particular was quite a bit of fun to write. As I've said from Day 1, there's more than one way to hang a wolf, and sometimes you can get more from rattling cages than you can by walls of logic or magical vote charts.

You can do as you like, of course, but I think I've earned the right to make that request of you - if not for me, you probably would have been dead twice now.

While I appreciate the efforts, I wasn't a suspect of anyone on Day 1, and nothing was stopping the Selrahc train on Day 3, so I think I only owe you one lifesaving action.

Nonetheless, I'm happy to return the favor today. I've already voted for the mayor and the lynch, so I won't post again until Day 5. The wolves would only eat me at this point out of spite, for reasons I stated in my last post, not to mention the seer-meatshield we have at this point.

[Mr. Nice Guy]

Surely, since you're obsessed with me, you have screengrabs of my logins...
Isn't anyone who didn't see the obvious nature of that lynch suspicious for either being implicit or stupid? Those are really the only two choices, aren't they? Which are you? Implicit or Stupid? You don't seem dumb, but I don't have your SAT scores or anything.)
...
Anyway, yes, the mistaken group who didn't buy the lynch Selrahc play. See you were mistaken. Hahahaha, you made a mistake. You screwed up!!!! HAHAHAHA! ....
Play better, wolves, it would make the game more fun for the rest of us.

Really, this post made the whole game much more enjoyable for me.

I didn't respond to your PM because I thought it suspicious. At that point in the game, I didn't yet trust anyone, and I certainly wasn't giving anyone any information I didn't need to. You cannot argue that I have not consistently played the game in such a fashion. I still don't have any reason to believe you're not a wolf, your game has been horribly nondescript other than the torch you've been carrying for me. I'm not saying I think you're a wolf, I'm saying I have no read on you whatsoever.

That's good enough a reason for me. I'd still like to pick your brain about your observations if/when you can trust I'm a villager. Maybe it'll just have to wait until game over?

[haphazard1]

I didn't respond to your PM because I thought it suspicious. At that point in the game, I didn't yet trust anyone, and I certainly wasn't giving anyone any information I didn't need to. You cannot argue that I have not consistently played the game in such a fashion.

Actually, I will argue exactly that. You say you did not trust anyone yet on Day 1, but apparently you and Roland were working together quite a bit that day. Or so Roland has said, more than once, while explaining some of the odder aspects of his own behavior.

I still don't have any reason to believe you're not a wolf, your game has been horribly nondescript other than the torch you've been carrying for me. I'm not saying I think you're a wolf, I'm saying I have no read on you whatsoever.

Nice job of calling Mr. Nice Guy a wolf, while claiming you aren't calling him a wolf. Well done.

The Gaspar strawman is about the only tool the Wolves have at this point. 2 of 3 lynches have been the bad guys.

Yes, and the one lynch which did not get a wolf -- who was the alternative that day?

We are told that the wolves can swing votes with clever tactics and communication, since they have numbers and all know who is and is not a wolf. They certainly did not manage to save their fellows Day 1 or Day 3. Either they did pull off the save Day 2, or they really are playing a completely incompetent game.

[scooter]

Nonetheless, I'm happy to return the favor today. I've already voted for the mayor and the lynch, so I won't post again until Day 5. The wolves would only eat me at this point out of spite, for reasons I stated in my last post, not to mention the seer-meatshield we have at this point.

In that case, Gaspar. Sareln is my runner-up at the moment for reasons stated earlier.

[Lewwyn]

We are told that the wolves can swing votes with clever tactics and communication, since they have numbers and all know who is and is not a wolf. They certainly did not manage to save their fellows Day 1 or Day 3. Either they did pull off the save Day 2, or they really are playing a completely incompetent game.

Really? Why is the only option that they were "saving" a comrade? Couldn't it be that there really were 3 innocents on the block that day? Sunrise, Meiz and Gaspar? Guys please remember at one point we had a 3 way tie going in the voting.