WW #43 - The Asha'man

[Gazglum]

Hm, he didn't self vote, it was just something he said after the lynch.

Yeah, there was no self vote. And remember if he is scum buddies with Prometheus, there were no good options for him. Chances are that Prometheus had the better role, so I would expect scum Rowain to be resigned and irritated in that situation.

He made one last push for saving Prometheus too:

With Prometheus not jumping on the vote Rowain waggon immediately I think he is town and we should not lynch him.

unvote

That was a hard push to save Prometheus, which he then abandoned only after the rest of us piled on. He then hypocritically said of DP today:

For the other 3: Dp101: His posts so far fit for scum and he was also the one who voted for me besides Prometheus. He didn't want to lynch Prometheus. (Bussing a scumbuddy is hard if you are both newbie scums).

Sure, I've been hypocritical as well this game, but I have tried to point it out where it has happened.

Rowain is scum, guys. And probably feeling justifiably a bit peeved that luck has gone against his team.

[Meiz]

I think Gaz had played the strongest town game at that point (and still is), so I was pretty much fully trusting him already. I also really liked his immediate strong reaction to Adrien's night kill, of course enhanced by me thinking I've prevented the nk that night.

For saving him instead of Jkaen, Gaz sums it pretty nicely above.

[Rowain]

More to the point, another successful scan pretty much clears me AND another player. That's 2! As opposed to Jkaen's 1!

It only clears if you die and your role reads Cop. So far your claimed scans do neither clear you nor any of those you cleared.
So that is 0 compared to the 1 we had.

To get the 2 (fenn and novice) we would need to lynch you .

[Lewwyn]

In the meantime, Novice is not a member of the mafia. I scanned his last night because, especially given I already knew Fenn's alignment, I didn't like Novice's attack on him. I thought it looked like an attempt to bail out Prometheus. But he is not mafia, and since he threw away Godfather we know he is not that.

Given this I'm much more confident in Meiz being scum. He was blatantly trying to manipulate me into keeping my vote on novice yesterday and was insinuating I was scum for changing my vote off of novice and onto Prometheus.

[Gazglum]

To get the 2 (fenn and novice) we would need to lynch you .

Lol. This is like the 17th post where you have half-accused me of being scum, but not gone through with it. Come on, Rowain, let it out. Put my name in red if you want to go down this road.

[Meiz]

Given this I'm much more confident in Meiz being scum. He was blatantly trying to manipulate me into keeping my vote on novice yesterday and was insinuating I was scum for changing my vote off of novice and onto Prometheus.

You mean the part where I accused you of bussing your scum partner Prometheus?

[Rowain]

To get the 2 (fenn and novice) we would need to lynch you .

Lol. This is like the 17th post where you have half-accused me of being scum, but not gone through with it. Come on, Rowain, let it out. Put my name in red if you want to go down this road.

Well Gazglum I have a huge problem right now: Either you are scum then you have played an extremly dirty game or you are town then the GM has allowed you to cheat your way to metaclearing yourself with citing his PM not once but twice. I don't think I am going to be happy with a town-win reached that way.

If you happen to be town then I think Meiz has despite me not really believing it to be scum. And the 2nd one has to be DP101 simple because 2 nk-immune (well I'm not really immune but practically) are alittle bit too much anyway.

[Lewwyn]

Given this I'm much more confident in Meiz being scum. He was blatantly trying to manipulate me into keeping my vote on novice yesterday and was insinuating I was scum for changing my vote off of novice and onto Prometheus.

You mean the part where I accused you of bussing your scum partner Prometheus?

In a game like this with only 12 players bussing a scum partner reduces the chance of victory astronomically. And if it can be avoided it should be. Why would I bus Prometheus so early in the day when there was plenty of time for me to help lead a charge elsewhere? Or even stay on novice who almost got lynched too? I could have just stayed on novice and said "Yes I think Prometheus is scummy, but novice is more scummy." and that would have been perfectly acceptable. You accusing me of bussing Prometheus like that is manipulative in that it supposed to make me feel like I shouldn't be voting for Prometheus.

[Rowain]

To get the 2 (fenn and novice) we would need to lynch you .

Lol. This is like the 17th post where you have half-accused me of being scum, but not gone through with it. Come on, Rowain, let it out. Put my name in red if you want to go down this road.

That is not an accusation btw but merely pointing out that to get those 2 cleared we have to know you are a cop which only happens after your death.

I don't vote you because I don't believe you would play that dirty for a win. But the alternative isn't much to my liking either. So I'm sitting here grumpy throwing stones in your direction when ever there is a chance.

[Gazglum]

That is fair, and I shall take your stones.