LURZKERS THREAD (for siege of the dragon)

[Tasunke]

Night 1 = bad luck.

Damn swinginess of roles ...

[Qgqqqqq]

Also Tasunke you completely f***d up with the reveal - I was looking forward to 96 hours of meta.
Even revealing D3 or whatever I'd find questionable, but you just gave the village a massive boost. :/

You really need to trust the players too - if I was you I'd edit that stuff you snipped back in.
Tasunke PM'd me saying the reason he snipped was he didn't want Noble to PM players and cause them to quit - sorry Tasunke as you obviously didn't want this published, but I feel its important to get this point across.
I can pretty much gaurantee that NO-ONE in this thread would PM players about its contents, and besides, players have invested a lot of time into this (well... some of them have ) the're not just going to up and leave.

[Qgqqqqq]

I love how, pretty much every game I've asked the lurkers how I played badly, and been left with a smug silence. .

[Qgqqqqq]

Oh, I also really, REALLY dislike your telling the players (pretty much) which players were killed by each faction.
Its fine to mess around in meta, but just say that they died mysteriously or something in the other post.

[Qgqqqqq]

I suspect three elementals, each resistant to one faction

[Qgqqqqq]

Only a spoiler in relation to pins:

In response to zaks p486 in main thread (apologies as this device prevents multi-quoting) - it is now fairly obvious that zak and i are in different factions, I really enjoyed working with you D1. As I have mentioned earlier, I really was playing as I would village (I still don't, and probably never will, understand how the case on me could be taken seriously) and I was in no way stringing you along D1. I love the innocent child comment ( ), but

[Qgqqqqq]

but I really did feel persecuted (paticularly by Serdoa) and it really did feel like an us vs them situation, with zak being the only us.
If he is SK then nice play, as I would have followed him pretty well anywhere (if I was village) so long as Serdoa lived.
I also think that though he might have discounted the argument from the start, he threw his hat into the ring after Serdoas "insult" post, as it is after that that he joins the discussion. I also agree that Serdoa was hard to commu

[uberfish]

It's ok to give death flavours, just a GM choice, and probably a good thing in a game with this many kills in it - Scum are getting a lot of information out of it too. Someone should be analyzing who had motive to kill pind though.

Still think zak is some sort of scum with immunity regardless, and MJW's late switch off Q isn't suspicious. MJW isn't stupid and could easily not have helped restart the Q wagon in the first place if he wanted to save Q. If I was still alive I'd just lynch zak. Mattimeo is also a good lynch for not doing anything except defending himself.

Btw, Azza should probably just have claimed himself that he was an elemental and that he had a partner or partners that would be able to confirm him if necessary to save novice from having to reveal.

[Qgqqqqq]

icate with. Heck, he must have been asked that non-Qdefence 4-5 times (and he never really answered it). The fact that Serdoa a) insulted me and then b) practically spat in my face when I offered to explain post game (by mentioning that he had "even taken the time to read [my posts]" got me up in arms and precipetated(?) zaks defence.
In summary, I really felt zak and I were on the same wavelength D1, at a time when it felt like the world was against me.
Oh, and another thing?

[Qgqqqqq]

[spoiler]
Written on phone
Pity it took an hour
]/spoiler]