Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Sandover Wrote:Sure, I can do that. After lunch.
Maybe it's time to hurry up a little?
Sandover
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Sandover Wrote:Hey, I resent that! Identifying MJW was easy and had very little to do with luck. I'm surprised so many just failed to see that.
Or failed to care perhaps?
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Pocketbeetle
Post 1 - Novice Lynch, Ichabod Mayor for out of game reasons
Post 2 - no strong feelings on MJW or Lewwyn, keeps vote
Post 3 - Likes Irgy's theory about MJW being a game long hiding place for wolves if not voted off
Post 4 - comments (i think) of Lewwyn using circular logic
Post 5-6 - identifies a Cull - Lewwyn link
Post 7, 14, 19, 20, 21 - no content
Post 8-10 - defends against a roland post linking him to Cull, follow up defends this point more strongly. Likes idea of Novice against Selrahc
Post 11 - doesnt like PB, novice, selrahc options
Post 12 (#674) - Long post listing his Rowain suspicions. boils down to him be too certain against PB, and even if we are wrong its just a bad villager on too much of a crusade
Post 13 - links rowain quick response to wolf like behavior suggested by Irgy
Post 15 - 16 - asks mardoc, then brundaine to clarify their voting reasons against him
Post 17 - states Selrahc as his risk reward - Rowain as low risk/reward
Post 18 - general defense agaisnt the Rowain campaign
Post 22 - New day vote against Rowain picking back up on the battle between the two of them
Post 23 - minor defense of Zak stating he sees no argument
Post 24-25 - joke (?) suggestion of Lewwyn and Rowain as masons, stating Lewwyns post made no sense
Post 26 - Stating Roland convinces himself wrong often.
Analysis,
To be honest, I can't really draw too much. His ideas against Rowain seem weaker than I recalled, but basically it comes down to Rowain launching a crusade against PB, and he countering. There is very little content that doesn't relate to this.
Thats somewhat understandable as he wants to live, but the arguments seem to be grasping at straws somewhat and are based on if you are so sure about a certin villager, you are at best a bad villager. But at least he is presenting an argument.
I think the Rowain / PB battle is going to take a lot of focus, and provide easy hiding places for a while so I dare say the village will have to come down on one of them soon.
Another key note is that he seemed to want to link Cull to Lewwyn strongly, but defended with a surprising vigor the link to him to Cull.
Does suggest maybe a PB, cull WW pair with Lewwyn being dragged in as a cover / sacrifial villager should Cull get lynched.
I would like more theories from PB, but at the moment he is tied up having to defend against Rowain, but based more off the cull comments I find him slightly suspicious, say 7/10
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Meiz,
Given I switched as you corrected from PB to Rowain, and not Selrahc, do you still see me as trying to save Selrahc?
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Sandover Wrote:Novice's identity is far from known, in my mind. I agree its not confirmed, but I think strongest is hard to argue
Quote:Hey, I resent that! Identifying MJW was easy and had very little to do with luck. I'm surprised so many just failed to see that.
Ok, I may have been harsh there, you never suspected MJW, but it was not clear who you did suspect
Posts: 1,311
Threads: 3
Joined: Nov 2009
Meiz Wrote:Maybe it's time to hurry up a little?
Sandover
I should've seen that one coming from miles away. 
Posts: 1,311
Threads: 3
Joined: Nov 2009
Jkaen Wrote:Ok, I may have been harsh there, you never suspected MJW, but it was not clear who you did suspect
Pocketbeetle.
Now if you excuse me, I'm off to make some sandwiches.
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Jkaen Wrote:Meiz,
Given I switched as you corrected from PB to Rowain, and not Selrahc, do you still see me as trying to save Selrahc?
I actually thought it correctly when I wrote it, just wrote the wrong name. I feel the momentum was behind Rowain, so I can still see it as a saving attempt. But I have stronger suspects than you, those being PB and Zakalwe.
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Jkaen Wrote:Meiz,
Given I switched as you corrected from PB to Rowain, and not Selrahc, do you still see me as trying to save Selrahc?
by switching to rowing you can be seen as attempting to save selrahc. Switching from pb to rowain instead of from selrahc only makes the case stronger because you were never on selrahc.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Jkaen Wrote:Meiz,
Given I switched as you corrected from PB to Rowain, and not Selrahc, do you still see me as trying to save Selrahc?
by switching to rowing you can be seen as attempting to save selrahc. Switching from pb to rowain instead of from selrahc only makes the case stronger because you were never on selrahc.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
|
