WW15 - Chiron is a harsh mistress

[Jkaen]

Let me put 2 and 2 together for you.

Waterbat has contacted the name seer. Waterbat knows who the name seer has scanned so far and who the seer was probably going to scan last night. If Waterbat were a NAP he would not be coming to talk to me and giving me this information as it only helps to narrow down the search of Marr.

At this point there are only three people Marr could be. Selrahc, Zakalwe and you Jkaen.

Ok, that is why you think/know he is innocent, but bear in mind.

1. He has contacted you only, we havent seen what info he has given you
2. I am far from convinced that you are innocent, and that there even is a name seer, although from what you just told me, maybe I can work out who has claimed it

[Lewwyn]

Jkaen

[Lewwyn]

No fuck this, your obstinate posturing is too much. You can't be a wolf. No matter how much you piss me off.

Selrahc and Zak are our troublemakers.

[Maniac]

Another possible weakness in waterbat's story. Just a tiny one though.

On day 3, I firmly believe I talked to the name-seer. He told me he scanned Mardoc and the result was "Drone".

"Drone" is Molach's role. If a name-seer scanned him, shouldn't the result be "no name"?

[Lewwyn]

Another possible weakness in waterbat's story. Just a tiny one though.

"Drone" is Molach's role. If a name-seer scanned him, shouldn't the result be "no name"?

Are you kidding me?

[Maniac]

To elaborate, if a nameseer got drone as a result, then for a portion of the people a nameseer would also more or less act as a roleseer. Seems unlikely given we already have a dedicated one. This makes the existence of a nameseer less likely.

[Lewwyn]

I mean seriously Maniac WTF. I'm just sitting here dumbfounded. We're the ones who called people no names. You don't think the GM gave NAMES to his roles in order to tell them apart? He has to give a name seer something, but it can't be "villager" or it would be like an alignment. Drone is just a role name we have no idea if that means he's NAP or not.

[Lewwyn]

To elaborate, if a nameseer got drone as a result, then for a portion of the people a nameseer would also more or less act as a roleseer. Seems unlikely given we already have a dedicated one. This makes the existence of a nameseer less likely.

Dude. If you're a name seer and you are given the name drone as a result, do you know what that role does? A role seer would know what the role does. I mean come on are you doing this on purpose?

[Maniac]

I mean seriously Maniac WTF. I'm just sitting here dumbfounded. We're the ones who called people no names. You don't think the GM gave NAMES to his roles in order to tell them apart? He has to give a name seer something, but it can't be "villager" or it would be like an alignment. Drone is just a role name we have no idea if that means he's NAP or not.

1. You're assuming a name seer exists.
2. the name of the role is something the roleseer should get, not the nameseer.

[Lewwyn]

1. You're assuming a name seer exists.
2. the name of the role is something the roleseer should get, not the nameseer.

WTF.

YOU ARE EITHER NAP OR A STUBBORN NARROWMINDED NINCOMPOOP!