Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
pocketbeetle Wrote:It's much more likely we'll just end up lynching an inexperienced villager who's talking too much.
I prefer to kill villagers that talk too little (and yes that means you PB  ) especially if they are otherwise very talkative. In WW1 you had 24 posts in one day here you have exactly 2. Trying too hide that you sleep in the barn because you're busy at night?
@Selrahc: sorry this is a game and I will happily lynch whom ever I find right to lynch no matter if it is his first game or not. Or are you,as one with lot of experience, volunteering to climb the gallow?
Bobchillingworth
Unregistered
Since we can't edit posts...
Roland- I enjoy reading your more concise posts much more than the essays from last game  Don't feel compelled to write exceedingly large posts just because people associate them as being your "thing" or whatever. As several people have noted, you write quite well- but reading walls of text is monotonous regardless of the quality of their composition. Apologies if this post seems patronizing, btw- my intention is only to encourage you to carry on with your present style.
Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
Bobchillingworth Wrote:Since we can't edit posts...
Roland- I enjoy reading your more concise posts much more than the essays from last game Don't feel compelled to write exceedingly large posts just because people associate them as being your "thing" or whatever. As several people have noted, you write quite well- but reading walls of text is monotonous regardless of the quality of their composition. Apologies if this post seems patronizing, btw- my intention is only to encourage you to carry on with your present style.
Nah, not patronizing at all. I do need to find balance, in more than just my involvement in the game (although my posting style [length?] should naturally follow a more balanced approach to the game).
Personally, I'm liking Irgy and Lewwyn as possibilities at the moment, although I won't say I'd miss MJW. It's all well and good to say he MUST be a Villager, but we don't have any proof. Besides, his contributions are questionable, his likelihood in getting mod-killed higher than average, and his overall behavior not conducive to ferreting out 'Wolves via actual processes. His main goal is generally to lie through his teeth and hope someone slips up because of it - not the greatest strategy, IMHO, so I can't say I'd miss seeing him even if he is a Villager.
I need to review the thread a bit more before I come to a final decision, but I'm comfortable with my Lewwyn vote for the time being - I'm still deciding whether he truly is just that fired up, or whether he's a 'Wolf and trying to fit (break) the Villager mold.
Posts: 3,140
Threads: 26
Joined: Feb 2009
Quote:@Selrahc: sorry this is a game and I will happily lynch whom ever I find right to lynch no matter if it is his first game or not. Or are you,as one with lot of experience, volunteering to climb the gallow?
It is a game, but I'd prefer it was a fun one. In the first two days it is likely that all evidence will be sketchy at best. Maybe it might be worth holding in suspicions of new players for the first few days, to create a more fun initial atmosphere? I certainly think so. Just because things are a game doesn't mean that they must be taken dead serious. In fact I'd hope it meant the reverse.
Is it really that onerous a burden for you? To not kill new players for just two days?
And, no, I'm not volunteering to be lynched. I know that isn't in the best interests of the village, because I know my own role. That would be actively bad play by me, rather than just (possibly) mildly sub-optimal.
I wouldn't be too put out about being night killed though. Whoever the wolves kill is going to be innocent, so I'd rather it was me than a first timer.
Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
One last Tally before I'm off to bed:
@Roland we have a little bit less than 17 hours left
@Selrahc I think we are all grown ups and not little kids. Besides as far as I see no firsttimer is on the chop right now.
Mayor:
8v: novice(Bobchillingworth, Zakalwe, novice, Roland, Gold ergo sum, sandover, MJW, Cull)
3v: Rowain(Ichabod, scooter, Rowain)
2v: Meiz (Bruindane, Selrahc )
2v: fire & ice (fire & ice, Jkaen)
2v: Irgy (Mardoc, Meiz)
1v: Ichabod( Pocketbeetle)
1v: Mr Nice Guy(Irgy)
1v: uberfish (Mr Nice Guy)
1v: Jkaen (Lewwyn)
- Bruindane votes Meiz
- MJW votes Roland
- Irgy votes Mr Nice Guy
- Meiz votes scooter
- Selrahc votes Meiz
- Sandover votes Lewwyn
- uberfish votes Rowain
- Bobchillingworth votes novice
- zakalwe votes novice
- fire & ice votes fire & ice
- Mr Nice Guy votes uberfish
- sandover switches to MJW
- novice votes novice
- Meiz switches to Meiz
- scooter votes Ichabod
- Pocketbeetle votes Ichabod
- Rowain votes Selrahc
- Roland votes novice
- Ichabod votes Rowain
- scooter switches to Rowain
- Gold ergo sum votes novice
- Mardoc votes Irgy
- Jkaen votes Fire & Ice
- Rowain switches to Rowain
- sandover switches to novice
- Meiz switches to Irgy
- Lewwyn switches to Rowain
- uberfish switches to No Vote
- Lewwyn switches to Jkaen
- MJW switches to novice
- Cull votes novice
Not voted: Serdoa, uberfish
Lynch:
5v: MJW(Serdoa, Selrahc, Bobchillingworth, Mr Nice Guy, Cull)
4v: Lewwyn ( Roland, Zakalwe, Ichabod, MJW)
3v: Pocketbeetle (Rowain, scooter, novice )
2v: fire & ice( fire & ice, Irgy)
2v: Cull(Meiz, sandover)
2v: novice (uberfish, Pocketbeetle)
1v: sandover ( Gold ergo sum)
1v: Meiz( Jkaen)
1v: Irgy(Bruindane)
1v: Mr Nice Guy(Mardoc)
- Lewwyn votes MJW
- Bruindane votes Zakalwe
- novice votes fire & ice
- Serdoa votes Rowain
- Rowain votes MJW
- sandover votes Meiz
- MJW votes Irgy
- Irgy votes Meiz
- Serdoa switches to MJW
- Meiz votes fire & ice
- Selrahc votes MJW
- MJW switches to fire & ice
- novice switches to Pocketbeetle
- uberfish votes novice
- Bobchillingworth votes MJW
- zakalwe votes sandover
- fire & ice votes fire & ice
- Mr Nice Guy votes MJW
- sandover switches to Lewwyn
- scooter votes Bruindane
- Pocketbeetle votes novice
- fire & ice switches to Pocketbeetle
- Roland votes Lewwyn
- fire & ice switches to MJW
- Irgy switches to fire & ice
- Gold ergo sum votes sandover
- Mardoc votes Fire & Ice
- Fire & Ice switches to Fire & Ice
- Bruindane switches to Irgy
- Jkaen votes Meiz
- sandover switches to Zakalwe
- Zakalwe switches to Lewwyn
- novice switches to Lewwyn
- Rowain switches to Lewwyn
- Meiz switches to Lewwyn
- Lewwyn switches to No Vote
- Lewwyn switches to Cull
- Meiz switches to Cull
- Cull votes MJW
- Rowain switches to Pocketbeetle
- Lewwyn switches to No vote
- sandover switches to Cull
- Ichabod votes Lewwyn
- scooter switches to Lewwyn
- Mardoc switches to Cull
- scooter switches to Pocketbeetle
- MJW switches to Lewwyn
- novice switches to Pocketbeetle
- Mardoc switches to Pocketbeetle
- Mardoc switches to Mr Nice Guy
Not voted:
Lewwyn
Posts: 939
Threads: 8
Joined: Dec 2010
Since I am no longer going to die I choose to switch my vote to :drumroll: Lewwyn He was an avid talker who wanted to move the lynch votes around and now that he is close to the top he has stoped talking.
Also mayor vote Bruindane idk if this helps him or somthing but he seems to know the cast of charecters well.
Posts: 3,140
Threads: 26
Joined: Feb 2009
Quote:@Selrahc I think we are all grown ups and not little kids. Besides as far as I see no firsttimer is on the chop right now.
Being little kids has absolutely nothing to do with it. I'm not suggesting that anyone is going to go off in a huff if they get killed.
Day 1 and Day 2 have much less solid reasoning than any other day. To be killed off on those days, whether by night kill or day kill, is a little irritating.
I think it would be a more pleasant game to play in if those semi-random kills aren't happening to players who haven't played before.
I'm not asking for blanket immunity from suspicion for those players. And if someone does something truly suspicious, they probably deserve to be lynched or night killed.
It's just a suggestion, but I think it is one that makes the game a more pleasant one. If new players are killed before they get a chance to do anything at all it hurts the game.
It was also a suggestion more directed at the wolves than the villagers. Since it looks like a firsttimer isn't going to be lynched today.
Posts: 575
Threads: 6
Joined: Dec 2005
I appreciate the vote for mayor, Fire&Ice. I do think Rowain has a better chance to catch novice though. Sorry [strike] Meiz[/strike].
[strike] Irgy[/strike] appears safe today, so I'll toss my menhir at Pocketbeetle. I'll be tossing a fresh menhir at you tomorrow Irgy.
![[Image: votes.gif]](http://i1180.photobucket.com/albums/x420/Bruindane/Werewolf/votes.gif)
The recent debate isn't particular informative, but voting for PB will put him within reach of MJW and Lewwen and I'm hoping that is helpful.
Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
Selrahc Wrote:Being little kids has absolutely nothing to do with it. I'm not suggesting that anyone is going to go off in a huff if they get killed.
Day 1 and Day 2 have much less solid reasoning than any other day. To be killed off on those days, whether by night kill or day kill, is a little irritating.
I think it would be a more pleasant game to play in if those semi-random kills aren't happening to players who haven't played before.
I'm not asking for blanket immunity from suspicion for those players. And if someone does something truly suspicious, they probably deserve to be lynched or night killed.
It's just a suggestion, but I think it is one that makes the game a more pleasant one. If new players are killed before they get a chance to do anything at all it hurts the game.
It was also a suggestion more directed at the wolves than the villagers. Since it looks like a firsttimer isn't going to be lynched today.
Firstly, I couldn't agree more. Thank you for putting forth your thoughts on the matter Selrahc - I think it's an admirable goal, and truly within the spirit of what Realms Beyond is all about (not just Variant Scum, but fostering a helpful, friendly community).
That said, I can't see why you (Rowain) would take such a firm stance against what was merely a polite request for fairness, equality, and enjoyment for all. Frankly, I'm a little put off by your attitude, although maybe part of that is the language barrier. At any rate, it's making me inclined to start a bandwagon against you. :neenernee Shouldn't be too hard, after all.
Anyway, the gears are already turning for me. Of course, I'm probably way off, but I already have a few people lined up to keep an eye on. I don't think we've struck gold on anyone yet, to be quite honest (although it is still too early to tell, unfortunately).
16 hours to go... suddenly it doesn't seem like so much. 
Posts: 748
Threads: 6
Joined: Dec 2010
For the benefit of other non-Americans, I looked it up:
PST = GMT-7
9pm PST deadline = 4am GMT = just under 4 hours from now.
For the benefit of myself:
= 3pm Sydney time (at GMT+11)
Is 9pm PST still the relevant time? I don't know. I can't tell when the synchronisation post was made, it seemed to be in the middle of the night, more like 3am not 3pm for me. Which is exactly as different as you can get, so I'm confused. Have I got my AMs and PMs confused or something?
|
