Werewolf 3 Game Thread

[novice]

Mardoc, what have you done for us lately?

Oh, and if someone wants to metagame, check the creation time of that RIP picture he posted.

[novice]

Mardoc, what have you done for us lately?

Oh, and if someone wants to metagame, check the creation time of that RIP picture he posted.

And by he I mean Bruindane.

[Meiz]

Mardoc, what have you done for us lately?

Oh, and if someone wants to metagame, check the creation time of that RIP picture he posted.

How do I check it and what was it?

[novice]

How do I check it and what was it?

I don't know and I don't know.

[Meiz]

I don't know and I don't know.

Damn, I was sure you cached a wolf and really got my hopes up

[Mardoc]

Mardoc, what have you done for us lately?

Apparently nothing. I was suspicious of Bob, of all people, for his lack of posting and I thought trying to draw out the seer with the post that instead meant he was the seer.

Going back through the thread to see if anything stands out more now that we know MJW and Bob were innocents. So far all I have a mild suspicion of Lewwyn for his voting yesterday and his 'wow, lucky' posts right after the werewolf kill.

[Gold Ergo Sum]

Eek. In a no PM game, this just got very tough indeed.

Worst baner ever.

How could the baner possibly know who to protect this early on? If I had to guess, the baner probably protected you novice, since you are the mayor, and thus an obvious target.

It seems to me, this early on, the best the baner could've hoped to do would be to force the wolves to waste a night kill, rather than expecting to actually guess right on protecting the seer.

[scooter]

How do I check it and what was it?

I tried, but I don't think it's possible to check it. You can't check it from within the browser (or at least, I can't seem to be able to do it in FF), and saving it to your computer gives it a new created time for the day you saved it. FF doesn't tell you anything about when it was created, and IE just tells you it was created on the 16th, which is kind of a no brainer. Nice thought though...

Going by the forum clock, from the time Sareln posted the kill to the time Bruindane's post was submitted was 22 minutes. Count in time for seeing the post, upload, replying to the post, etc - we're looking at 15-20 minutes or so. Certainly plausible, but definitely something to keep in mind. Bruindane, how did you do it so quickly?

[Serdoa]

Uh, GES, and how does the Baner know that novice is a villager? He doesn't - so why should he protect him?

[Meiz]

I've been reading through the thread and looking for no-content posters (ouch, do my eyes hurt...). One name stands out for me much more than others, Mardoc.

I see that Zakalwe pointed out the same fact during night time. Basically Mardoc was very active and used the whole day to wake people up by throwing votes for less active people, and cheering them to play for the village team. Everything is nice and well, but when you actually pay attention, his posts do not have a single original idea or suggestion.

Another fact that is the timing of his switch against Cull. Let's assume that Cull is a villager, which is quite likely, as there are only 5 wolves. If this would be the case, it would be favorable for the wolves to get Cull killed instead of MJW. Situation was 8v5 in MJW's "favor", but Mardoc's switch made it much closer race (7v6), making Cull a valid candinate for lynching. This does not prove a Mardoc as wolf, but it adds more suspicion to me personally, when added to his posts.

The more I read his posts, the more convinced I have become. I have to say, this will most likely be a permanent vote on my part for this day.