Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
My Current hit list
8/10 - Fire and Ice, MNG
7/10 - Cull, PB
6/10 - Sandover, Meiz
5/10 - Serdoa, Scooter
4/10 - Ichabod
3/10 - Mardoc, Zakalwe, Irgy
2/10 - GES, Novice
1/10 - Bruidane
0/10 - Jkaen
Novice
Post 1 - F&I for RP reasons
Post 2-3,6-8,10,13-14,16,21-24,26-32,45-46,48,51-52,54-57,59 - no content
Post 4 - suspect MJW is innocent
Post 5,15 - Wake up votes on PB
Post 9 - Self vote for mayor
Post 11 - Vote for Lewwyn following zak
Post 12 - minor uberfish suspicion
Post 17-20 - very late swing on cull to try and sway vote (which failed)
Post 25 (day 2) - low post mardoc vote
Post 33 - follows Meiz onto Selrahc mainly on lack of other options
Post 34-40 - the fool conversation
Post 41-42 - general defense based on being mayor
Post 43 - Rowain vote as no strong villager feeling
Post 44 - nudge roland to post
Post 47 - switch to Selrahc catching the WW
Post 49 (night 2)- still suspects Rowain as wouldn't vote Selrahc
Post 50 - happy to lynch me
Post 53 (day 3) - Lynch Rowain due to not changing vote
Post 58 - suggests cull or Lewwyn vote run
Analysis
Well its pretty hard to look past the Selrahc kill, tried another late switch on Cull on day 1 too but missed. There is a chance that Selrahc was sacrificial, and having the ability to name your successor is pretty powerful for a WW mayor too. But right now I don't think they would throw away Selrahc that early as novice was under no real pressure at all. Saying 2/10
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
My Current hit list
8/10 - Fire and Ice, MNG
7/10 - Cull, PB
6/10 - Sandover, Meiz
5/10 - Serdoa, Scooter
4/10 - Ichabod, Rowain
3/10 - Mardoc, Zakalwe, Irgy
2/10 - GES, Novice
1/10 - Bruidane
0/10 - Jkaen
Rowain
Ok, time to see if my current vote makes sense
Post 1 - lynch MJW due to RP
Post 2-6,9,11,14-17,19,21,23-24,26-28,30,34-38,41,46,48-50,52,58-59,67,69-72,87 - no content
Post 7 - Suggests Bob and Sandover as targets due to strange voting
Post 8 - Selrahc for Mayor
Post 10 - Rowain for mayor
Post 12 - Lynch Lewwyn mainly as not to Lynch MJW
Post 13 - Lynch PB due to lack of posting
Post 18 - Suspect Roland, PB, Serdoa for non-standard posting habits
Post 20,22,25 - Dsiagrees with the protect the new ones idea
Post 29,33 (night 1) - Marks Seroda as a wolf for wanting to see how the major votes
Post 31-32 - States the last minute novice switch says nothing
Post 39-40,42-45 - The start of the PB crusade commenting on the quick build up of votes on Cull and the pick up on posts from PB, suspects wolves saved PB
Post 46 (day 2) - votes PB
Post 47 - Identifies reason for bob kill
Post 51,53,55-57,61-66,68 - Calls for support on pb claims lynchpin to his theory (maybe this is the cull bandwagon one?).
Post 54 - suspects Roland, uberfish, sandover, scooter, mardoc, novice
Post 60 - general defense
Post 73-86 (night 2) - Calls again against PB suggesting he was saved and that since Selrahc was a WW that means PB is the void wolf
Post 88-90 - Votes PB and supports argument
Analysis
Seems to have locked onto a vote swing on Cull in day 1, and pursued it with no end, convinced that PB is a WW and is going to let nothing stop him. To be honest I don't think he is a WW, just a very bad misguided villager (even if PB is a WW in the end, there is not the level of support there right now to warrant this crusade). Why not vote for another of the switchers instead to see how that works into the theory for example?
I have made the mistake on day 1 or voting off a misguided villager, won't do it again, so will be switching my vote and just start ignoring his posts I think (4/10)
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
My Current hit list
8/10 - Fire and Ice, MNG
7/10 - Cull, PB
6/10 - Sandover, Meiz
5/10 - Serdoa, Scooter
4/10 - Ichabod, Rowain, Roland
3/10 - Mardoc, Zakalwe, Irgy
2/10 - GES, Novice
1/10 - Bruidane
0/10 - Jkaen
Roland
Post 1 - Novice mayor, Lewwyn Lynch for out of game reasons
Post 2,8,12,27,29,31-32 - no content
Post 3-4 - says Lewwyn's MJW vote was not suspicous
Post 5-7,10 - defends posting rate
Post 9,11 - votes cull due to low posts
Post 13-16,25 - defends cull bandwagon
Post 17-20 - Links cull to PB
Post 21-24 - Pushes scooter for reason on his vote
Post 26 - Comment on Mardoc theory being reaching
Post 28 - Suspicions on PB and Lewwyn
Post 30 - Suspicion on me
Post 31 - Defense against Rowain, again on post count
Post 32 - Suspects PB and Selrahc and Me
...
Ok, I am burning out at this point, bit off far more than I could chew with this task and my internet connection is spluttering. Have read the rest of his posts, but pretty sure he is a villager, all his posts are pretty good theory and content wise, so hopefully that suspicion is long dead now. Can't rate him fully as scan reviewed the 2nd half of his posts, so he is only getting a 4/10. pretty sure it would have been lower if i did this earlier
Posts: 716
Threads: 6
Joined: Jan 2010
Sorry about this, but is there anyway to replace me in this game?
Quite frankly, I can't play with any sort of attention, or time to this game that it should get(can't even spend 15 min scrolling through, sad) ATM.
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Is there a lot of spoiler info in the spoiler thread? Otherwise you could recall the latest confirmed villager kill. Uberfish could just take your spot if the lurker threads doesn't have loads of info. Since he was a villager he wouldn't know any other roles and could easily fill Culls role no matter what it is.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 15,372
Threads: 112
Joined: Apr 2007
novice Wrote:Regarding scooter - It's not that he's suspicious per se, but it almost feels like he isn't trying his hardest for a village win.
Could you share what makes you feel this way about me? I guess I'm not sure what I've done to make you think that? Was it the Fool debate? I dropped it as I felt I was in the minority on it, but I really did think what's best for the village is for no one to ever claim Fool... If it was my absence yesterday - sorry - I just wasn't around much, and when I was around, my attention was distracted a bit towards the kick off for PBEM14. I just spent like an hour catching up on all this (yeesh, there's a lot), so perhaps I can be a bit more helpful now that I feel much more caught up.
Posts: 1,160
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2010
JKaen may have buried this with his lists of posts, but I think this needs to be brought back up:
Lewwyn Wrote:Long Post guys!
Also Zakalwe is decidedly different from WW1. You may all say that this is him gaining experience and trying to act differently, I say its because he has a different role. People are who they are and they play roles the way they play roles. In WW1 he had a set theory and was pretty well following it. Now you tell me because he was wrong about TT that he has given up on theories completely? That he has thrown out his thinking cap? That he is willing to be suspicious of lots of people but NOT continue to vote for them? He has been decidedly a chameleon in this game. Read his posts f you do not believe. Maybe he has been RPing and playing the game in a more "light hearted" manner, but anyone who is roleplaying to his extent is definitely taking the game seriously, but he's not laying out his suspects as aggressively as he has in the past. Again I've already addressed the "mellowed out over the TT thing" part. His village won in the end. You think he believes he did poorly and must change his character? People think I did poorly in WW2, but I do not, and we won, so I'm not changing the way I play. If you think Zakalwe has learned his lesson, you're not giving enough credit to Zakalwe's spine and stubbornness.
Much as I'm enjoying reading Zak's posts, I agree with this. Zakalwe is playing WW3 completely differently than how he played WW1. Frankly, we have the advantage of having a baseline to use for Zakalwe, and he just isn't matching that baseline. Like I said last night, I could be swayed to Rowain, but Zakalwe is more suspicious because of his baseline.
More than anything else, Lewwyn's post is quite valuable, and should not be hidden away. Who's been hiding it away most? JKaen. Suddenly, now that I'm putting pressure on him, he's posting a lot. This feels familiar.... because it is. In WW2, for those who didn't follow, Irgy was generally quiet and under-the-radar for most of the game. Then I started putting pressure on him, and he suddenly posted. In fact, a quarter of his posts came after I started accusing his fellow wolf Scooter. Now we look at this game. JKaen has been generally quiet through the first two days. Not as quiet as me, but posting enough to stay off the radar without posting enough content to go on anyone's radar. I bring that fact up, and start accusing him heavily, and suddenly he posts again and again and again, so fast that it's impossible to respond to everything. Only... once again, there's not much content that's new or original. Just a rehash of other's posts.
This strategy he's using is a tired werewolf strategy. While Rowain, Zak, and others are suspicious, JKaen is playing the game with the paws of a wolf. He is the one we should be lynching today.
Having said all of that, and having put myself out there against him at least 3 times now, I'm not surprised that JKaen has me at 8/10 on his suspicion list. What a shock, eh? My question... what could I do, specifically, to make myself less suspicious in your eyes, JKaen?
You can get a look at a t-bone by looking up the bulls ass but I'd rather take the butcher's word for it.
Posts: 15,372
Threads: 112
Joined: Apr 2007
Cull Wrote:Sorry about this, but is there anyway to replace me in this game?
Quite frankly, I can't play with any sort of attention, or time to this game that it should get(can't even spend 15 min scrolling through, sad) ATM.
Why sign up for something you can't commit to? I don't mean to pick on you, but this seems to happen to you a lot here at RB, and it isn't fair to those who sign up with the intention of playing the game out - whether it be WW, PB, or PBEM.
Posts: 939
Threads: 8
Joined: Dec 2010
About the cull thing I have no problem with him being replaced or killed.
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
I will try to do the decency of at least reveiving Lewwyn's post, but due to a bit of budying up and him starting the villager lynch my gut says 7/10.
Which makes my WW as: F&I, MNG, PB and Cull.
@ MNG
oh dear, is there anything I can do in this game that is not considered a classic WW strategy?
As for making you less suspicious to me, lets start of with you posting your 4 werewolf suspects and the reasons for all 4 as I would like to see what theories you can have without being able to possibly piggyback on others
My vote today: while one of my 4 has a vote, I would prefer to target a 8/10 if I can, so lets go with MNG for now
|
