Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
Mr. Nice Guy Wrote:Anyone else care to join me on JKaen, or will we be forced to go for PB/Rowain?
I see no reason why we can't have 3 choices up there. 4 is pushing it a bit, and anything more is just a waste, IMHO.
I'm curious - of the two, who do you feel more strongly about, and why? How do you feel either will affect Jkaen's guilt or innocence?
Posts: 575
Threads: 6
Joined: Dec 2005
Lewwyn Wrote:I also feel that to lynch PB would reveal more information and shed more light on the votes already cast. He is part of the root of discussion and therefore would shed the most light. While I suspect Jkaen, his death would be less illuminating because has been less controversy surrounding him. By process of elimination, pocketbeetle becomes my vote of choice and necessity.
These two might be at each other's throats the whole game. It must be a net loss if we continue to have these two dominate the conversation every day.
pocketbeetle as I trust Lewwyn's tea leaves more than my own.
![[Image: pocketbeetle.jpg]](http://i1180.photobucket.com/albums/x420/Bruindane/Werewolf/pocketbeetle.jpg)
I just imagine PB is feeling battered after three days of lynch attempts.
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Ok, had tonight to sleep on things and calm down a bit. It wasn't the fact I was being accused that annoyed me, I am fine with that (although you're all wrong) it was the fact I put a hell of a lot of work into those analysis and got them dismissed as spam that irratated (should probably appologise to Roland at this point for my comments in the WW2 lurker thread when I did similar to his posts)
As for my defense, I have been accused of adjusting my play when people point out shortcomings in order to appear to help the village more... This is exactly what I have been doing as I am still learning this game. Hence it is impossible for me to defend myself.
Since it seems the MNG vote is going nowhere today, I guess I go for somebody else on my list and switch to Pocketbeetle
Posts: 748
Threads: 6
Joined: Dec 2010
For what it's worth Jkaen, I thought the analysis posts were excellent work and extremely commendable. I'd meant to say so at some point but it got lost among the various other things I've had to say which had more direct relevance to the game. Please keep it up if you can regain the motivation. I was quite looking forward to you getting up to me 
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Irgy,
I did you in post 974, you will be glad to know you are a villager
Posts: 748
Threads: 6
Joined: Dec 2010
Oops, that's a bit embaressing. Here I am thinking I'm up to date. I think I probably missed that whole page of them when I lost track of which page I had already read up to one morning. Some more reading for me to go back to I guess
I love my list of no-content posts there too, a spectacular effort on my part I dare say. Chalk this up for another one too. I wonder how it compares to WW2, I was a master of no-content in that game.
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
I started feeling guilty after a while about labelling them no content posts for everybody. A lot are 'cool we got a WW', lynch tables, mechanics discussions, jokes etc that make the game more enjoyable. Just ones I couldn't draw any conclusions from
Posts: 2,313
Threads: 16
Joined: May 2010
Jkaen Wrote:it was the fact I put a hell of a lot of work into those analysis and got them dismissed as spam that irratated
I would like to point out that I expressed my gratitude. I am not convinced you are a villager given the limited evidence of your voting record, but the effort was useful to me nonetheless. I read them all and will read any ones you do in the future.
I am not sure what Bruindane was doing earlier. I read it all twice and it made even less sense the second time.
Right now I am inclined to flip a coin between PB and Rowain. I don't have much of a read on either. The voting around PB is weird, but so is Rowain's crusade against him. I think I will get a chance to check again in the morning, so if there is a late run maybe I can actually be involved in it this time.
Posts: 7,902
Threads: 13
Joined: Aug 2006
So, last night I considered voting for either Mardoc or Mr. Nice Guy. Looking through Mardoc's posts, I noticed he was away for the week-end, so I figured I'd give him some more time to speak up. "Unfortunately", his last post here looks quite villagery to me, particularly the "denying info to the village" part. So I'm going with Mr. Nice Guy for now. He's in my "high density wolf" group, and I cannot really find anything to suggest he is innocent. Also seems like he should be a good "consensus" candidate, since many believe Pocketbeetle to be a wolf. If PB is a wolf, then where would you expect the other wolves to be placing their votes, back when it was a three horse race between Pocketbeetle, Selrahc and Novice? And who was the only remaining person to vote for Novice after the dust settled?
You may have thought you had me going there, appealing to my vanity by flattering my poetry. No more, Mr. Nice Guy.
Posts: 5,294
Threads: 59
Joined: Dec 2004
[Size="7"]An Interlude[/Size]
All of the recent rain had made the fields a mess, and Cull pondered this as he checked each of his irrigation ditches. It was nice out here, away from the village squre, especially now that all anyone wanted to talk about was who was a werewolf, who wasn't, and who they were going to hang. At least, he thought to himself, he could beg a few hours here to tend his crops to get away from all the insanity. His crops, at least, would not judge him. As he was climbing over one of the fences, his foot slipped, and Cull fell.
Normally a fall isn't that fatal - honestly, there was no reason for this one to be particularly deadly either. A rock in the wrong place, a slight twist to the ankle and neck as he falls, these things combined in just the right way, and what was once a rather pedestrian fall is now a deadly encounter. On the bright side, he didn't feel a thing. Novice was sent to find him after he failed to return. He came back with the news, and wanting others to help him bury Cull.
The village though, asked Novice only one question. Not "how did Cull die", nor "did he suffer?" No, the only thing they wanted to know was: "was he a wolf?"
[COLOR="Red"]Cull was mod-killed!
Cull was a villager.[/COLOR]
List of Remaining Players:
Notes on Ruling:
Strenous objection from all wolves on the basis that Cull or his replacement would unambigiuously be a normal villager, not a power-role, not a wolf, and therefore completely trusted. It's a tough break for the village, but I think this was the best way to resolve it without costing the village a hanging opportunity or the wolves a night-kill slot. Thanks for playing Cull, hopefully you'll be able to find more time later for other games!
As to the rest of you, see you all in 8 hours or so! 
Blog | EitB | PF2 | PBEM 37 | PBEM 45G | RBDG1
|
