[SPOILERS] Werewolf 3 Lurker Thread

[uberfish]

Really don't see how Cull requesting a replacement due to RL circumstances identifies his alignment as "confirmed village" in any way...

[MJW (ya that one)]

Really don't see how Cull requesting a replacement due to RL circumstances identifies his alignment as "confirmed village" in any way...

Playing as WW is funner so it goes up that he is a villager. Not much though...It might be a cheese trap. The fool should scry himself so he can know when the void-wolf role-blocks him. Almost useless but it might help.

[pocketbeetle]

I won't be signing up for one of these games again.

I find it infuriating dealing with stupid people like Lewwyn, and the tendency of others to follow him mindlessly dents my general faith in humanity.

If either Lewwyn or Rowain are wolves, then I tip my hat to them for playing well.
But I'm pretty resigned to them just being bad villagers, who for some reason decided that they wanted me lynched on Day 1. *shrug*

As always, Roland tends to be both a positive and negative for the village.
He likes to take the high risk plays so he can congratulate himself afterwards if he's right, but the need to grandstand can lead to him failing to see the obvious thing underneath his feet.

Thanks for running the game so well though Sareln, the Cull decision was decisive, clear and fair enough for all sides.
Go team wolf!



Edit:

but at least he didn't slug either the vintner or the carpenter on his way out the door to the gallows.

Are you sure Sareln?
That sounds like some remarkable self control on my part, which I'm not sure I possess currently... ^^

.

[pocketbeetle]

The suspense is killing me - you are doing it always PB! Not only in FFH2PBEM1 but also now here

Thanks Serdoa.

Keep telling Roland to stfu. Someone needs to.

[uberfish]

Awful lynch TBH, the case against you was so weak. I'd have defended you on day 3 if I wasn't dead

[Erick the Red]

There were two things that seemed off to me about this. One was the night 2 kill of uberfish - if PB was a wolf why not kill one of the people set on him? Not just in a short term attempt to remove votes against him, but also to remove people who will become trusted villagers if PB is lynched.

The other is that I would have expected PB to role claim if he really was a wolf. By this point there wasn't much to lose and it might draw out a village role. Off all people I'd expect a wolf PB to hatch some scheme to keep himself alive a bit longer and create confusion.

[pocketbeetle]

I'd love to be a wolf in one of these games.
So much fun!

Sadly it seems I'm better at being misleading than honest.
In fact, going on my track record, my honest act sucks.

Awful lynch TBH, the case against you was so weak. I'd have defended you on day 3 if I wasn't dead

Thanks.

You were too moderate.
The wolves want to keep the hyperactive post bunnies in, not someone like you who was clearly paying attention and weighing the evidence.

[Selrahc]

I was actually intentionally creating a bit of a link between myself and PB, to give someone a case against him later on. I launched my "no killing new players" initiative right after he got a few votes on him(I was waiting for some new player to get votes before starting it, and it happened to be PB). The next day I tried to build on that by not voting for PB, and backing up his theories, but doing it in what was hopefully quite a subtle way.

I passed the info of what I was doing to the wolves, to detonate against PB later. Obviously they didn't need to call on that argument though.

I had a couple of other long term scheme ideas, but that was the only one I directly put into motion before my death. It's a bit annoying that it didn't come to fruition.

[uberfish]

I didn't really pick up on Selrahc trying to connect himself to PB. (because PB didn't really register to me as a "new player" as he'd played WW#1.) I assume I was killed because I correctly identified Selrahc and PB's alignment.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Calm down, Serdoa.

No point in turning this into something personal.

The villager's WANT to make things personal. It makes people put their emotions into the game and increase the likelihood of mistakes. Mistakes help the villagers much more because the wolfs already know who everyone is. I think it is a wolf trying to hurt the village by calming things down.

This still is not enough to put him in my list. He is likely trying to just keep the RBer sprit going...