Werewolf 3 Game Thread

[novice]

Zakalwe

If he were a villager he would have been eaten.

[Rowain]

In Memoriam sandover:

Meiz->Lewwyn->zakalwe->Cull->Pocketbeetle->Cull (d1)
novice->Rowain->Selrahc (d2)
zakalwe->Meiz->Mr Nice Guy->Pocketbeetle (d3)

[Mardoc]

Good write-up, again, Sareln. And too bad on losing Sandover.

On to the game:

Of the arguments presented today, I think Mardoc's are very optimistic but I'd like to investigate them further by voting for Novice.

I agreed mostly with Mardoc's post, and I kept my vote on Novice for that reason.

I asked for help to lynch PB before anybody put out any theory. I didn't ridicule Mardoc like some people did and my obfuscating better arguments worked so well that Selrahc got lynched by 9/21 people. Clearly the village has to get rid of me else I obfuscate them into lynching another wolf

So far, these are the most suspicious things I've seen! Now that I know how hilariously wrong I was, I'm starting to think anyone who agreed with me or defended me is suspicious

In fact, I'm starting to get reluctant to post, since everything I say is wrong.

But, gotta carry on anyway. Maybe I'll at least get something else wrong in a way that turns out to be useful. I'm still way back in the thread, though, reading through Jkaen's summaries. I'll be out of date for a few hours yet, I'm sure.

[Gold Ergo Sum]

Sandover? Huh.

I must be terrible at this game because very little is making sense to me ATM.

[Meiz]

So far, these are the most suspicious things I've seen! Now that I know how hilariously wrong I was, I'm starting to think anyone who agreed with me or defended me is suspicious

I was about to write that my only suspicion against Mr. Nice Guy is him agreeing to your theory

In fact, I'm starting to get reluctant to post, since everything I say is wrong.

Welcome to the club, Mardoc . I will try to find a new theory soon, for all of your amusement.

[Roland]

Sandover was eaten!

Sandover was a villager.

Nuts. I was hoping to hear more from Sandover. He never really got a chance to shine, in either game. At least he doesn't have to worry about eating that hat now.

[scooter]

Are you referring to me? Honestly, you give me too much credit if you think I can swing the Village towards lynching you. I have nothing to lynch you over! For crying out loud, do people really think I have that much sway here? Honestly, I don't see it, especially this game, and I'm not looking to reprise that role from the last game. That was more than enough spotlight for me, thanks. I don't want to be that responsible for every lynch that goes down - I'm nowhere near confident enough in my ability, and I don't want to deal with all the backlash being directed solely at me. :neenernee

Relax scooter. I honestly, truly mean it when I say I have no suspects. Shocking, I know, but there you go. Not you, not Serdoa, not anyone.

Well, except Sandover. :neenernee For posterity's sake.

I was talking about Meiz.

[scooter]

Zakalwe

If he were a villager he would have been eaten.

Can you elaborate on this? I'm not disagreeing at all, I just feel like I missed something, as I can't think of why he'd be eaten.

Well, except Sandover. :neenernee For posterity's sake.

Was I the only one that thought it was odd that this was said right before we found out Sandover was eaten? I've been gone for the last 4 hours or so, and then when I got on here, I checked right away to see who was eaten. I saw it was Sandover, thought it was odd, then shrugged and backed up to catch up on the posts that I missed. When I saw this post from Roland, it looked really odd since I knew that I was about to come to Sareln's "Sandover was killed" post. Roland, what were you referring to here?

(Full Disclosure: I admit it could just be paranoia, but I needed to ask)

[novice]

Can you elaborate on this? I'm not disagreeing at all, I just feel like I missed something, as I can't think of why he'd be eaten.

Okay, here's some anti-village advice, so wolves, look away.

When selecting a night kill:
* Pick a skilled player
* Pick someone who's not too suspected of being a wolf, as you would be doing the villagers' job easier
* Don't pick someone who's practically a confirmed villager either, as they could be baner protected.

Zakalwe fits the bill, just as Bob did on night 1 and Uberfish did on night 2.

[Rowain]

And sandover does not fit it? Or for example you?