Werewolf 3 Game Thread

[Roland]

Maybe all we villagers stop trying to do fancy stuff which feels like we are really smart when actually the only ones we are misleading are our fellow villagers? I mean, that would be really smart now, wouldn't it? I don't think the wolves are misled by anything we have done so far anyway.

I'm not even remotely sure who or what this is supposed to be addressing. Now I'm even more confused.

[Meiz]

That's the only trick I had. Promise

So this is just not spam, here is my list of definitely innocents (more up you are, more sure I aim):

Meiz
Gold Ergo Sum
Novice
Serdoa
Lewwyn
Ichabold
Mardoc

If you are a wolf and are in this list, please speak up. While you wolves are at it, please let me know who am I missing.

[novice]

Maybe all we villagers stop trying to do fancy stuff which feels like we are really smart when actually the only ones we are misleading are our fellow villagers? I mean, that would be really smart now, wouldn't it? I don't think the wolves are misled by anything we have done so far anyway.

I'm not even remotely sure who or what this is supposed to be addressing. Now I'm even more confused.

He was referring to this:

I'm guessing it's because of my night time comments regarding a theory involving lynching novice next. I have to confess, I've tried to protect him since the end of day 2 from the night killings, with the accusations. Not sure how wise that is, but at least he is still alive :neenernee

[novice]

So this is just not spam, here is my list of definitely innocents (more up you are, more sure I aim):

Meiz
Gold Ergo Sum
Novice
Serdoa
Lewwyn
Ichabold
Mardoc

please let me know who am I missing.

I would take Mardoc off that list and add Roland and Bruindane. That leaves these suspects, listed most suspicious first:

Scooter
Rowain
Zakalwe
JKaen
Mardoc
Fire & Ice

[Rowain]

Given that there are 6 names and 4 wolfes left we can kill all 6 and win.

[scooter]

I have no idea what you're talking about. Btw why are we the only ones posting in this thread?

I'm talking about the fact that nothing I will do will change your opinion that I'm a wolf. You started on day 2, saying I was a wolf because I wasn't posting much by way of opinions (this was on the day I was gone for most of the day and got 150ish posts behind). I responded saying it wasn' true, and cited several examples. You ignored my response. You stated me as a possible wolf several more times, and each time I responded, you ignored my response. I write a lengthy post that to me, should be quite helpful, and you dismiss the entire post by saying you don't think voting records mean much right now. So I'm quickly realizing there is nothing I can do to convince you otherwise, because you'll always come up with some new reason to vote for me. If Zakalwe turns out innocent, you'll jump on that. If Zakalwe turns out guilty, you'll say I was just trying to establish a cover.

You accused me of never calling BS on any theories. I've done that several times. Actually when YOU were getting votes early on, I said many times that I thought the case against you was terrible, and that we should focus on the other candidates. When PB was getting votes, I stated again that the case against him was silly and we should be focusing on alternatives. And I could go and dig up quotes to prove it, but if I did that, you would just ignore my post and continue to vote for me. So what's the point? Hence, the tunnel vision comment.

The other problem is that you continue to ignore the bulk of what I say and respond to the tiny part that you don't think is great. For instance, in that very post you ignored the meat of the post, where I said this:

I also have no idea how Zakalwe, Ichabod, fire&ice, Rowain, Gold Ergo Sum, JKaen, and Lewwyn could possibly be more likely villagers than me. Or even you for that matter.

Because you knew you couldn't really answer it - I had made a good point. You instead picked out this tiny part right here:

or you are a villager with a severe case of tunnel vision.

And really, Roland said it great here:

By the way novice, not to sound like I'm singling you out or anything, nor trying to discredit your theory, but as an outside observer I do believe you've been rather dismissive of scooter and his input at times. I don't know if I'd go so far as to say you've been "obsessed", or possessed of "tunnel vision", but I do feel as though you've been... less than neutral when assessing scooter's input.

This is the "diplomatic" way of saying what I was saying - key part in bold. I've been contributing, but you've been too convinced of your "intuition" that you've totally dismissed everything so far. Hence my frustration. If you at least had good reasons for voting for me I wouldn't mind, but the last thing we can afford right now is this kind of borderline nonsense.

[novice]

I have no idea what you're talking about. Btw why are we the only ones posting in this thread?

FWIW this was supposed to be funny. I really need a drummer.

I just posted a list of innocents which is my current assessment, I gave reasons during the last day phase but the answer boils down to gut instinct in many cases.

I would like to hear from the rest of the village. I'm willing to listen to the majority.

[Ichabod]

I'm here now! Tried to read the discussions of today, but my head is filled by other stuff.

When I was still able to play this properly, I suspected zakalwe, but I'm not sure about it...

The only thing I can add is that I'm innocent and that you shouldn't waste a vote on me. I really have no clue about who are the wolves. If I appear to be online all the time is probably because I left my home computer with the forum opened. I'm not secretly planning wolf tactics to kill the village

I'll give a better look into Rowain. I don't think he did anything right during this game and he votes without much reasoning. Maybe I just skipped through his reasoning posts (if that's the case, I'm sorry)...

[Meiz]

I would take Mardoc off that list and add Roland and Bruindane. That leaves these suspects, listed most suspicious first:

Oh yeah, I forgot Brundaine since he's been afk. I would add Roland, if there wasn't the constant fear of Roland the puppet master at the back of my head. Am I just giving too much credit for him?

[Ichabod]

Ah, I don't think Jkaen is a wolf. He said I had a connection with PB and a bunch of other stuff that seemed to be the work of a misguided villager.

Maybe he fooled me, but I was suspicious of him back then and I'm not now...