Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
We got a werewolf! well done us 
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
We can be proud of ourselves 
Posts: 15,358
Threads: 112
Joined: Apr 2007
Geez, I leave for the morning and what on earth happened in the last few hours? Bruindane was a werewolf? And there was a last minute attempt to kill me and save zakalwe, which resulted in fire&ice being lynched? And fire&ice was a villager?
I'm gonna need some time to digest this.
Posts: 6,630
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2010
Kinda funny that Roland made sure to lynch a villager (though I tried to rally people to vote for him too, so no offense there Roland). I just feel the only break we are getting is that Bruindane didn't play on - might I ask, was there some discussion that one of the wolves would get himself modkilled to make up for the sudden disapperance of Cull or what?
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Well looks bad for Roland, and good again for Novice for now.
Anyway can one of the wolves tell us if that was on purpose?
Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
Well, I'm about ready to give up on putting forth ANY theories from now on. Clearly I don't know anything. Moreover, it seems I screwed up some elaborate plan to make a 3-way tie, which I was not aware of, and instead lynched a Villager. So... yeah, I won't be surprised if I get lynched tomorrow.
All I want to know is what does this mean for our numbers? It seems had I not lynched fire&ice, if he got modkilled tomorrow we wouldn't have lost another missed lynch because, as it turns out, Bruindane was a 'Wolf. So not only did I lynch a Villager - costing us 1 miss - but we could have waited and simply had him modkilled without losing that missed lynch.
I give up. I have zero read on anyone in this game. I'm just going to follow along.
Posts: 6,630
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2010
Roland, I have the same issue. But then, if we look at Bruindane, I think he was called innocent by quite a few players and I will try to find out by whom and for what reasons.
Btw: Jkaen, how many points did get Bruindane on your list?
Posts: 5,294
Threads: 59
Joined: Dec 2004
Serdoa Wrote:Kinda funny that Roland made sure to lynch a villager (though I tried to rally people to vote for him too, so no offense there Roland). I just feel the only break we are getting is that Bruindane didn't play on - might I ask, was there some discussion that one of the wolves would get himself modkilled to make up for the sudden disapperance of Cull or what?
Answered in lurker thread. Such is the way of things. I wouldn't spend too much time thinking about why Bruindane dropped and just move on with the game.
Blog | EitB | PF2 | PBEM 37 | PBEM 45G | RBDG1
Posts: 15,358
Threads: 112
Joined: Apr 2007
Okay, I've spent some time looking over the last minute frenzy. I think there could be some important things to be learned by it. I have a few questions for a few people that I'd like answered... FWIW - I don't intend for any of them to be leading questions (I suppose my last one is a little bit, but not the rest of them). In other words, just because I"m asking you a question doesn't mean I'm assuming you are suspicious so just relax and answer the question . Though I'll admit there was one or two things that WERE suspicious to me. So I figured let's get these questions answered and see if we can learn some things from them. Here we go:
Serdoa - Why'd you vote for me? You made this comment to Rowain, saying his vote on me was pointless:
Serdoa Wrote:Rowain, are you not still on scooter, a vote which will be of no consequence anyway? If you are so sure that F&I is a villager, why are you not changing your vote to zakalwe?
You said this with about 15 minutes to go. Why did you then swap to me, rather than voting for Zakalwe or fire&ice?
Lewwyn - What was with your vote swapping? You swapped to me, then attempted to do a last minute swap to Zakalwe, not getting there on time. What was your thinking there and why'd you do that?
Novice - With a few minutes left you swapped to Zakalwe, then to me, then to fire&ice, then back to me, all in a span of under 15 minutes. Why? You voted for all 3 candidates in the last 15 minutes?
Rowain + Novice: Why do we have this crazy suspect triangle between the three of us? Novice suspects Rowain and I. Rowain suspects Novice and I. I wasn't heavily suspecting either of you until your recent strange behavior. Don't either of you find it unsettling that the people you highly suspect agree with you on the other person you highly suspect? I tend to think that this behavior is so bizarre, that one of the three of us (and probably no more than that) is a wolf, and I know it's not me.... So...
Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
Serdoa Wrote:Btw: Jkaen, how many points did get Bruindane on your list?
Jkaen Wrote:My Current hit list
8/10 - Fire and Ice, MNG
7/10 - Cull, PB
6/10 - Sandover, Meiz
5/10 - Serdoa, Scooter
4/10 - Ichabod, Rowain, Roland
3/10 - Mardoc, Zakalwe, Irgy
2/10 - GES, Novice
1/10 - Bruidane
0/10 - Jkaen
|
