Werewolf 3 Game Thread

[Meiz]

@Jkaen

Should we aim for GES and novice next?

[Serdoa]

Serdoa - Why'd you vote for me? You made this comment to Rowain, saying his vote on me was pointless:

Rowain, are you not still on scooter, a vote which will be of no consequence anyway? If you are so sure that F&I is a villager, why are you not changing your vote to zakalwe?

You said this with about 15 minutes to go. Why did you then swap to me, rather than voting for Zakalwe or fire&ice?

At the time I wrote it, the vote on you was pointless and I couldn't understand why Rowain would ask Jkaen to change his vote - obviously believing F&I is innocent - when he himself wasn't making his count by sticking it on you and being alone with that.

Now looking at it, I feel that Rowain is probably innocent. First his crusade against PB was - as said by others - not very wolfish, now his try to get Jkaen to not vote for a villager - again not really wolfish. Of course it is possible that zakalwe is a villager as well and that in the end it was at that point of time completely without consequence for the wolves for whom the villagers vote and so a good possibility to gain some cover. But thats stretching it pretty much I think.

Anyway, your question was why I swapped to you. It was because it made it to a 3-way-tie and so novice had to decide. Several people have already stated that novice might be a wolf, so I wanted to have him make the decision between 3 players. Just to see whom he votes for.

[Serdoa]

@Meiz

Wouldn't going for Jkaen making the most sense, according to his list?

[Meiz]

Wouldn't going for Jkaen making the most sense, according to his list?

Little too obvious list for a wolf?

[novice]

Novice - With a few minutes left you swapped to Zakalwe, then to me, then to fire&ice, then back to me, all in a span of under 15 minutes. Why? You voted for all 3 candidates in the last 15 minutes?

Even with the time constraints, I actually explained myself while doing it. I was trying to keep the score tied to see if anyone got tempted to swing the vote from one suspect to another.

Then with 2 minutes left I gave up and cast my tie-breaker vote on F&I. Then suddenly there were three votes on scooter and I had the opportunity to lynch you. So naturally I went for it.

[novice]

List of Remaining Players:

• Scooter - Grizzled Smith
  
• Zakalwe - Cacophonous Bard
  
• Serdoa - Brewer
  
• Ichabod - Children's Teacher
  
• Lewwyn - Carpenter
  
• Mardoc - Glass Blower
  
• Gold Ergo Sum - Bricklayer
  
• Meiz - Retired Barbarian
  
• Rowain - Vintner
  
• Novice - Farmhand
  
• JKaen - Herbalist
  
• Roland - Bowyer
  

So right now we're 12 players, 3 wolves and 9 villagers.

Night 5: 3-8
Day 6: 3-7
Night 6: 3-6
Day 7: 3-5
Night 7: 3-4

So we have two more mislynches left. If we mislynch on day 6, 7 and 8, we lose on day 8. If we get a baner save, we'd still lose on night 8.

So we need to nail the 3 wolves without using more than 5 lynches.

[Serdoa]

Little too obvious list for a wolf?

So wrong this list, nearly as it was crafted this way...

Really Meiz, look at this list and tell me that any villager would have been able to get it so extremely wrong. I don't buy that - even by chance one of your top 5 suspects should be a wolf (5 of 23 means a little bit more then every 5th player is a wolf). And I know that I am a villager myself. So that makes 6 out of his top 7 suspects which are innocent. Should we lynch you and find out if he is wrong with that as well? I guess you plea for not guilty hm? So that makes the top 7 suspects of him innocent.

I believe that Jkaen is one of our wolves. He crafted this list to prove his innocence, hoping that someone would point out that this would be too obvious for a wolf when it becomes appearant that this list is completely wrong.

[Jkaen]

Whats the chance that people would target the top of my list like this, I could hardly expect this case to come up defense wise.

I did say the reason I was so sure on Bruid was because I thought I spotted a slip, the problem was I determined it was a mason slip not a WW one.

Although yes I admit I do seem to be a bit rubbish at this game

[zakalwe]

I'd rather lynch F&I than Zakalwe, and these last minute switches make things just random. We get Rowain tomorrow, right?

I'd be happy to take you up on this offer. I was tempted to vote for him when he had two votes and fire&ice and I had four each; but I thought the voting ended an hour earlier than it did (daylight savings time) so I couldn't risk it. I really wish someone would fix the forum clock, btw.

I doubt I've earned that transfer to the night kill list just yet, but I thought I'd go on record with this just in case.

[Gold Ergo Sum]

Holy crap, did all hell break loose on RB with my absence?

Between the last minute vote switching, the wolf mod-kill, and the RBP4 drama, I don't think I am allowed to go snowboarding again.

I guess even with the mis-lynch, we came out ahead?