Meiz, is Rowain now a wolf because he was defended by another wolf in the public thread or scooter a wolf because he was accused by another wolf in the public thread? Just asking...
|
Werewolf 3 Game Thread
|
Serdoa Wrote:Meiz, is Rowain now a wolf because he was defended by another wolf in the public thread or scooter a wolf because he was accused by another wolf in the public thread? Just asking... You got me there, obviously theres no way they would play with different tactics. Why make it too hard for us? (Sorry for the sarcasm, I think you're a villager so we're on the same team here  )Yes, I think Rowain is a wolf and there are other reasons than Brundaine's defence (if you read my two big posts regardin Rowain). And yeah, I can't understand how scooter doesn't think it possible that two wolves would accuse each other to gain cover. Actually I think he is trying to do that himself to avoid lynch. Why am I so sure on Scooter? I've used the method of identifying most likely villagers and scooter does not get to that list by far margin. I'm not saying it's perfect, but it's good enough for me to suspect him.
Some points about day 1 and 2:
We have two known wolves until now, Bruindane and Selrahc. So we should watch what they did in the game. Let's go: 1. Selrahc and Bruindane voted Meiz as mayor in day 1, right at the beggining. Interesting... The two known wolves. Later Meiz voted for himself. He competed aginst novice for a short while during the mayor voting phase. After that we saw both Meiz and Bruindane switching to Rowain, again the best candidate against Novice. It leads me to believe that the wolves were trying to elect one of them as mayor. First they tried Meiz, later Rowain. Not very suspicious, but something to have in mind. 2. Bruindane voted for Selrahc very early in day 2. Interesting. Maybe the wolves had given up on Selrahc and intended to use him as a decoy for the rest of the game. Here's Bruindane post: http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showpost....tcount=617 What does it do to help us now: Selrahc didn't vote for PB for a long time, even though that could end up saving him. But as soon as he got a chance to vote for Rowain he did it. Assuming that the wolves had already given up on Selrahc, maybe he voted for Rowain to give cover to the one who ended up being lynched (If Selrahc ended up killed, why would selrahc, a wolf, vote for Rowain, another wolf? And if Rowain ended up killed, why would selrahc vote to kill a wolf if he's a wolf? A little confusing the way I wrote, but I guess you guys can understand it). 3. Lewwyn got some votes in day 1, 2 and 3. Neither Selrahc, nor Bruindane ever voted for him. And Rowain haven't done it too. Anyway, what I'm trying to say is: Rowain is pretty suspicious. I still have a lot of catching up to do, but I rather vote for him right now. Meiz and Lewwyn are on my list too, but I have to keep on reading.
About Meiz:
He tried to save Selrahc (jumping on the BW against me) Voted happily to lynch villagers the following days. First PB where he voted together with me. The very same one he wanted to lynch the day before when incidentally a wolf was up for lynching. Afterwards happily lynched MNG and fire &ice. And I asume you have no problem to lynch another villager today. That you get immediate support from Roland (who accidentially  broke the tie ) is not really surprising.About Bruindane supporting me. Well I aimed to lynch a villager. Does it really surprise you that he did help me along with that. (BTW Roland also supported me very strongly here). Rowain Wrote:About Meiz:Actually I tried to save PB at this point. PB was being accused mostly on inactivity, and I wanted to give him more time to get a chance to participate. The evidence against PB was just not there. Rowain Wrote:Voted happily to lynch villagers the following days. First PB where he voted together with me. The very same one he wanted to lynch the day before when incidentally a wolf was up for lynching. Afterwards happily lynched MNG and fire &ice.Unfortunately PB did not better his game on the following day, even when he was participating, so I honestly thought him as a wolf. Especially as I believed you to be a villager at this point. MNG and fire&ice, what can I say? I thought they were wolves too, and I was wrong. Rowain Wrote:And I asume you have no problem to lynch another villager today. That you get immediate support from Roland (who accidentiallyMost definitely not, hence my vote against you. Unlike you, I'm not recommending people to lynch me, knowing I'm a villager and knowing that we cannot affor wrong lynches. Ichabod Wrote:1. Selrahc and Bruindane voted Meiz as mayor in day 1, right at the beggining. Interesting... The two known wolves. Later Meiz voted for himself. He competed aginst novice for a short while during the mayor voting phase. Hah, that looks pretty bad, doesn't it?  . Damn you clever wolves  I wish I could explain that, but I have no idea on that. Rowain Wrote:About Meiz: I'll happily lynch Meiz tomorrow, if it makes you feel any better. I'll happily lynch him today, and you tomorrow, if you prefer. I'm not picky on the order. I leave it up to the rest of the crowd.As for me, if you still believe so strongly that I'm a 'Wolf go ahead and lynch me. I'd honestly like to see who you have for followers - bring all the 'Wolves out of the woodwork, since they're (almost) the only ones who are going to follow you. After all, they need that extra Villager lynch.
Strange that those people that claim so hard that they don't want to lynch villager did that we equal vehementz during the last days.
If you are a villager (and I doubt that) you believed PB to be a wolf you believed MNG to be a wolf and you believed f&i to be a wolf But you didn't believe thatSelrahc was a wolf. Wouldn't you think you should consider your logic faulty? You and Jkaen are either wolves or the most stubborn people possible (and that is using nice words). |
