Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Rowain Wrote:@Meiz
When I have learned that I was wrong about PB I stopped pushing for other lynches.
I did consider that I' m not that good in detecting wolves as I thought.
But you and Jkaen - you continued to push for lynches day after day although proven to be wrong every day.
So after a failed lynch, it's better to just give up? You become worthless, so it's better not to present any new theories? I think I have managed to get a compelling case against you, and I truly believe I'm right on this one. I can never be 100% sure as a villager, but that's just the nature of the game.
Posts: 6,630
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2010
List of Remaining Players:
- Scooter - Villager? (think about that scooter when we meet in PBEM14)
- Zakalwe -
[COLOR="DeepSkyBlue"]
- Serdoa - Villager
- Ichabod - Villager
[/COLOR]
- Lewwyn - Villager? (switch Day1)
- Mardoc -
- Gold Ergo Sum -
- Meiz -
- Rowain - Villager? (crusade against PB)
- Novice - Villager? (switch Day1)
- JKaen -
- Roland - Villager? (just because I don't want another argument :neenernee)
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Exactly, I have been wrong, but as I said, those people were up there on seperate reasons, if Mr X and Y was only on my suspect list because I thought they were both acting together and then I found out Y was innocent, then yes I would drop X.
But that isn't the case.
As for:
Quote:If you want the villagers to win you should start lynching wolves and not continue lynching villagers.
Thats what we are trying to do. If you have insider knowledge, and want to just admit you are a wolf and tell us the names of the otehr 2 as well, then we will not have to lynch any more villagers
Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
@Meiz
You have been wrong on day 1, on day 2, on day 3, on day4 and day5 and are now wrong again.
The same with Jkaen. All his top suspects were villagers. Now it can happen that villagers enter the suspectlist. Thats not avoidable.
But beeing so complete wrong as you 2 and still not questioning your own thought-process, your decision-making - means either wolf or idiot.
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Rowain Wrote:@Meiz
You have been wrong on day 1, on day 2, on day 3, on day4 and day5 and are now wrong again.
The same with Jkaen. All his top suspects were villagers. Now it can happen that villagers enter the suspectlist. Thats not avoidable.
But beeing so complete wrong as you 2 and still not questioning your own thought-process, your decision-making - means either wolf or idiot.
I see this is a bit touchy subject for you, so I'll try to be gentle. Fortunately this is not just up to me and Jkaen. I hope we know the truth at the end of the day 
I again admit that my track record is horrible so far, but I'm not the only one who has suspected and lynched a villager here. This game is actually quite hard if you don't know the villagers and wolves before the game  . Fortunately it gets easier once time goes on
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Ok, I was just working on people on my list, but as you have pointed out I should stop doing that
Rowain Wrote:A) If we lynch PB and he stay villager I will not defend myself against a lynch next day. I have stated that I expect that to be the prize of failure.
B) Especially you should not lecture people about good, bad or fake evidence. You the man who defended a seer-screend wolf (is there any harde evidence possible?) and wanted to lynch a villager instead.
C) I appreciate that you defended me but rest assured if I ever get the impression that you are a wolf it will not hold my hand.
PS:
To ask you for your hard evidence you were talking about. And as with PB I have no hatred against you . Not here and not in WW2.
Hence, after a bit of a delay while I voted based on my list, I hearby take you up on your offer to not defend yourself from a lynch if PB proves to be a villager
Posts: 8,244
Threads: 30
Joined: Jun 2004
Meiz Wrote:I again admit that my track record is horrible so far, but I'm not the only one who has suspected and lynched a villager here. This game is actually quite hard if you don't know the villagers and wolves before the game . Fortunately it gets easier once time goes on
The problem is not that you lynched one villager. Failures are bound to happen. But beeing constantly wrong and not starting to doubt your own reasoning is the problem.
On any single day you have voted to lynch a villager (including me on day2) and you still thumb your chest proclaiming that you have a wolf now. Hence my statement.
Jkaen Wrote:Hence, after a bit of a delay while I voted based on my list, I hearby take you up on your offer to not defend yourself from a lynch if PB proves to be a villager
First off I said the next day. Second someone like you who has happily lynched more villagers than I should not take my offer.
Since you have been proofen to be wrong several time: Are you willing to put the same offer up? Would you lynch yourself if I'm a villager or not?
How deep runs your believe that I'm a wolf?
If Serdoa, Ichabod, Lewwyn or novice call my debt I'll vote for myself.
Posts: 7,902
Threads: 13
Joined: Aug 2006
As the morning bell chimes
The village rallies
In these troubled times
Who will do our tallies?
Vote Tally:
6v: Rowain ( Meiz, Roland, Ichabod, Zakalwe, JKaen, Mardoc )
2v: JKaen ( Serdoa, Gold Ergo Sum )
1v: Roland ( Rowain )
1v: Zakalwe ( Scooter )
1v: Scooter ( Novice )
1v: Mardoc ( Lewwyn )
All voting
History:
Posts: 6,630
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2010
I'd rather like to see a tally - if I am allowed to call you for stuff :neenernee
Posts: 6,630
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2010
Oh come on zakalwe, right when I request it - why are you able to read my mind?
|
