Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
Bah, I have a lot of questions to ask you and novice, Roland...
There's a lot of things that I can't understand right now.
Ah, almost forgot:
Lewwyn
Posts: 6,630
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2010
I'd like to hear your reasoning when you are back from work Roland. I am pretty set on Jkaen being a wolf but I am willing to vote with you (and Ichabod - and therefore subsequently Rowain) for Lewwyn if you are really sure that this won't be another villager lynch - well, as sure as you can be as a villager of course.
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
Day 1 and 3 are good proof of Lewwyn's guilt. See how the votes change in day 1 when Lewwyn starts getting near the top. And Bruindane last vote on PB, sealing the deal on day 3 when Lewwyn started getting near the gallows (curiously the same Bruindane who said PB was probably innocent).
Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
Sareln Wrote:Night post about to be edited to include the name of the new mayor (Roland).
Thank you Sareln.
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
I thought novice was the baner, and that's why I "protected" him with my accusations after day 2...  . Sorry to see you go. It's quite unfortunate that I thought Ichabold, Novice and Roland as certain villagers, and then two of them are masons. I still hoped that Zakalwe and Jkaen would be them, and then I would have had 5 persons to trust almost completely.
Lewwyn
Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
Ichabod Wrote:Day 1 and 3 are good proof of Lewwyn's guilt. See how the votes change in day 1 when Lewwyn starts getting near the top. And Bruindane last vote on PB, sealing the deal on day 3 when Lewwyn started getting near the gallows (curiously the same Bruindane who said PB was probably innocent).
I think Ichabod nailed it pretty well (and to answer your question - yes, I was PMing novice yesterday, you sneaky bastard; although I have been PMing myself all game long, too :neenernee). I'll elaborate more later, as I said - too much going on at work at the moment (ironically). However, I will say this: I've been eying Lewwyn since Day 1, so I admit a certain amount of bias. It wasn't until last night the evidence clicked into place (voting records). All game long I've been kicking myself for pulling my vote off Cull, because it just hasn't felt right - and I should know, since I was side-by-side with Lewwyn in WW2.
Anyway, what makes me hesitant about Jkaen versus Meiz is 1) I suspect Meiz over Jkaen, and 2) I'd bet money only one of them is a 'Wolf. I'm almost 100% sure on Lewwyn (in my own mind), about 80% sure on Meiz, and about 60% sure on my last suspect - but without nailing another 'Wolf it's going to be hard to pin down that third suspect.
Again, I'll get in-depth tonight. Bottom line: don't follow me if you truly don't believe me. I'm not about to lead a crusade. I'm laying out my cards because I have nothing left to hide anymore, and I want to win this. You're all free to agree or disagree. Just try to color in the name of your target in the voting records and ask yourself "Does this fit?" That's what I did - and it got me back to my first suspect: Lewwyn.
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Right hopefully nobody will shout at me if I now vote for one of my suspects who has also been voted on by both our trusted villagers at this point already today
Lewwyn
Posts: 739
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2004
Personal Voting Records
Werewolves
Selrahc
[/SPOILER]
Villagers
[b]novice[/b]
[b]Roland[/b]
[/SPOILER]
Unknown
Jkaen
Lewwyn
Mardoc
Meiz
scooter
Serdoa
zakalwe
[/SPOILER]
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Roland Wrote:Anyway, what makes me hesitant about Jkaen versus Meiz is 1) I suspect Meiz over Jkaen, and 2) I'd bet money only one of them is a 'Wolf. I'm almost 100% sure on Lewwyn (in my own mind), about 80% sure on Meiz, and about 60% sure on my last suspect - but without nailing another 'Wolf it's going to be hard to pin down that third suspect.
Or both are villagers. I know I am, and I suspect Jkaen might be too.
Am I the only one still eyeing scooter?  . Someone said it perfect earlier (novice?), he plays like a villager, but it's like he's not really doing his best. That's the constant feeling I've been having regarding him for the whole game.
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
You suspect scooter, Meiz??
Hm... Interesting...
Why haven't you said so when we were debating between him and Rowain?? You were online at the time, I know it. You sticked to Rowain without saying a word about any other suspects.
|
