Are you, in fact, a pregnant lady who lives in the apartment next door to Superdeath's parents? - Commodore

Create an account  

 
Werewolf 3 Game Thread

There are plenty of reasons that the wolves may have not killed scooter. The last few kills have been Irgy, ichabod, novice(right?) and I daresay that those were all good kills. Basically they have had better targets and can only kill one person a night.

Dunno, I don't see it. I'm pretty ambivalent about Scooter and I don't suspect him like I do my other suspects. What's the point of not lynching me if we don't nail a wolf instead? We'd simply trade one villager for another and given the suspicion on me, I would have simply stayed my execution to the next day, at which point we would auto lose lynching two villagers in a row.

No, I won't vote for scooter. I will vote for GES or Jkaen. I"m not even sure I would vote for Serdoa if the option came. He's third on my list, but third is a grey area. I wouldn't and won't risk that. I would rather that I, the most suspected villager, died and then everyone would stop trying to link people to me and look around with fresh eyes. There are too many theories swirling that hinge on me being a wolf. I've had a finger in every pot, I suppose? The price of being a bit erratic.

I'm trying my best to save the village. I don't want anyone blaming me for our loss when I turn up villager.

I will switch to Jkaen if more people are willing to go after him. The list, plus some of his smugger comments, have really raised huge red flags for me. He has consistently tried to be the good little boy. We say he does something suspicious and he asks what he could do not to be suspicious. Then he does that. Then we say he's suspicious again. He pouts and then changes for us again. We don't question it because we think he's bumbling around, but come on! We're feeding him how to be a villager? How not to be suspicious? Selrahc didn't want to lynch new players... What if half the wolves are new players, GES, Jkaen, Mardoc, Bruindane? This is seriously not outside the realm of possibility. It would also explain why there were no wolves up on the block that first day. We were all trying to avoid lynching new players.

My God, I can't believe I didn't see this before. Selrahc played us good. He says jump we say how high. He says lets choose the arbitrary rule on day 1 voting to not lynch new players. We abstain from voting for new players. They get a pass. We continue to avoid them because we're focused on all those players who we were discussing in the first days. It's so simple and so brilliant. And realize, AT LEAST one wolf is a newer player. Bruindane. I can't believe I didn't think of this before.

You're all avoiding them because they were never true suspects to begin with. Then they don't do terribly much in terms of content. We focus on experienced players because they would be "more dangerous". Good lord the most dangerous wolf is the one who's not looked at! Mardoc helped out with this admirable with his 5 wolf theory. We all laughed and said poor misguided new player. And I seriously think that that perception carried over. Whose pride is who's downfall now?

Either Jkaen or GES. I'll take down either at this point.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Reply

Damn it. Now I'm pissed for not realizing this earlier. If you take anything away from anything I've said in the last two day, or even this game take away the message in that last post. What Selrahc told us on Day 1 and what we did while listening to the "veteran" player.

Roland... man I need you to wake up and see this. I can't believe I didn't think of this sooner. Even if it doesn't change your vote.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Reply

Lewwyn, I am still not sure about you and I feel there is evidence against you. Though you are right that the only real "evidence" we have is that Bruindane voted to save you. That is not much and I feel that right now nobody wants to give you a chance because of fear that you are lynched, are a WW and then they will be painted as WW as well. I fear that as well to be honest, but if we lynch you and you are a WW, we could have another wrong lynch, so it is a gamble I am willing to take. Especially if you are a villager and if you are right that the newer players are the wolves.

And FWIW: The later we get in the game, the less players are remaining which can be wolves, so the most important part is to nail a wolf right now. So, I will give you a chance and we will see if after me more players are willing (as they then can at least say I am the WW which misguided them) to give you a chance.

Jkaen
Reply

Thanks Serdoa, I'm hoping it works out. I hope I'm right. Who knows if we'll even get enough movement on Jkaen anyway. We need at least 6 people to override Roland's Mayor vote so you may come out of this smelling like a rose if I end up lynched.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Reply

Only if you are a villager that is.

But I think Roland would agree with that move. Would he choose you in a tie? Hard to say, probably depends on what Jkaen does as well - but we need people on him.
Reply

Tally:

6v: Lewwyn (Roland, Ichabod, Meiz, JKaen, Mardoc, Zakalwe)
2v: Jkaen (Lewwyn, Serdoa)
1v: Gold Ergo Sum (scooter)

Not voting: Gold Ergo Sum

History:
  1. Lewwyn votes Gold Ergo Sum
  2. Serdoa votes JKaen
  3. Mardoc votes Meiz
  4. Roland votes Lewwyn
  5. Ichabod votes Lewwyn
  6. Meiz votes Lewwyn
  7. JKaen votes Lewwyn
  8. Scooter votes Meiz
  9. Mardoc switches from Meiz to Lewwyn
  10. Serdoa switches from JKaen to Lewwyn
  11. Zakalwe votes Lewwyn
  12. scooter switches from Meiz to GES
  13. Lewwyn switches from GES to Jkaen
  14. Serdoa switches from Lewwyn to Jkaen


4v: Meiz (Mardoc, Jkaen, Serdoa, scooter)
3v: Jkaen (zakalwe, GES, Lewwyn)
2v: scooter (Roland, Meiz)

Unclear: Ichabod (I think it would be Meiz for him too, though)
Reply

GES voted for me a bit back actually.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Reply

Tally:

7v: Lewwyn (Roland, Ichabod, Meiz, JKaen, Mardoc, Zakalwe, GES)
2v: Jkaen (Lewwyn, Serdoa)
1v: Gold Ergo Sum (scooter)

History:
  1. Lewwyn votes Gold Ergo Sum
  2. Serdoa votes JKaen
  3. Mardoc votes Meiz
  4. Roland votes Lewwyn
  5. Ichabod votes Lewwyn
  6. Meiz votes Lewwyn
  7. JKaen votes Lewwyn
  8. Scooter votes Meiz
  9. Mardoc switches from Meiz to Lewwyn
  10. Serdoa switches from JKaen to Lewwyn
  11. Zakalwe votes Lewwyn
  12. scooter switches from Meiz to GES
  13. GES votes Lewwyn
  14. Lewwyn switches from GES to Jkaen
  15. Serdoa switches from Lewwyn to Jkaen


4v: Meiz (Mardoc, Jkaen, Serdoa, scooter)
3v: Jkaen (zakalwe, GES, Lewwyn)
2v: scooter (Roland, Meiz)

Unclear: Ichabod (I think it would be Meiz for him too, though)


Thanks Lewwyn, have overlooked that.
Reply

Roland changed his lime vote for me rolleye
Reply

Just noticed something:

JKaen posted his suspect list at day 3. He kept on voting for the top suspects of the list until now.

Really? All the discussion after day 3 didn't make him wanna change his suspect list at all?It's very strange and seems to me like a good excuse for a wolf justify his votes...
Reply



Forum Jump: