Werewolf 7 game thread

[zakalwe]

The mayor tally is slightly incorrect, because I voted for myself (after Meiz voted for me). Seems like that's a lost cause though, so I'll support Serdoa. He seems innocent and I also think he has pretty solid judgment.

[Catwalk]

I don't feel confident about either of the mayor candidates. I'd still like to support either Meiz or zakalwe, who both read fairly innocent to me. If both of you agree, we have 3 votes and there's no clear winner at present. As stated before, the mayor race is pretty important this time around with no seer and a wolf with voting powers.

[Serdoa]

catwalk, I am not sure I understand. The two people you trust most do trust me the most in regards to the mayor job. And due to their votes it seems right now that I will be elected. And now you ask them to switch off of me so that you can put 3 votes on someone? So that we have 4,4,3,3 votes on 4 different candidates? How exactly is that helping to not give the wolves the perfect opportunity to get that job?

[Ichabod]

Sareln, Uberfish is currently voting for me as mayor:

I hadn't voted for mayor yet because I think the best thing to do would be to elect someone whom no one finds suspicious in the second half of day 1: Ichabod The other player who feels village atm is Serdoa.

[Catwalk]

[quote=Serdoa]catwalk, I am not sure I understand. The two people you trust most do trust me the most in regards to the mayor job. And due to their votes it seems right now that I will be elected. And now you ask them to switch off of me so that you can put 3 votes on someone? So that we have 4,4,3,3 votes on 4 different candidates? How exactly is that helping to not give the wolves the perfect opportunity to get that job?

I can't really argue with this, and I know we're running out of time. I still think it's not a good mayor vote, but I like Gaspar and Lewwyn even less. I do agree that a really close race means handing the wolves the office on a silver plate. So with hesitation, Serdoa.

[Serdoa]

Oh, one thing that is really important: It is your turn in FFH2PBEM12 Sareln!

[Catwalk]

To clarify, I meant that I don't like Gaspar and Lewwyn as mayor currently because I don't feel any confidence they're innocent. Nothing personal to them or Serdoa, of course. I think quite a few mayors will be eaten this game, so plenty of time to vote in new ones later

[Serdoa]

[quote=Serdoa]
I can't really argue with this, and I know we're running out of time. I still think it's not a good mayor vote, but I like Gaspar and Lewwyn even less. I do agree that a really close race means handing the wolves the office on a silver plate. So with hesitation, Serdoa.

Thanks. And as I should make my vote count (and I doubt we'll have another target anyway as long as uberfish doesn't come up with a great post)

uberfish

Not 100% sold on him tbh but he probably knowed that he paints a target on his back with his gambit. And the only other suspect I have is Rowain who won't gain traction anyway.

[Rowain]

I love you too Serdoa

For the Lynch: I must confess I'm not that happy about the uberfish-bw.

One thing that irks me is the fact that already the excuses why it was uberfish fault. OTOH his announcement and his explaination are strange.

Anyway I think I try a different person: Mr Nice Guy

Afterall he is trying hard to snuggle with zak.

[Roland]

My bad, I misread. Still want to know if he's your fellow wolf in this game, though :neenernee

As I said, I've never been a 'Wolf - including this game. The closest I've come to being anything special was being a Mason once.

I'm having a hard time understanding your statements, please correct me if I got any of this wrong:
1) He's fooled you 2x out of 3 as a wolf in the past.
2) You think you've learned how to read him better since then.
3) He seems different this game, and that leads you to conclude that he's more likely to be a villager.
4) He used to be either smart or ballsy.
5) Now you suspect he might be both, and that leads you to conclude he might be wolf? Or still leaning towards him as villager? Not sure where you currently stand.

1) Correct.
2) Yes.
3) He seemed, from his original explanation, to be pulling a gambit as a Villager. That was my first impression, and it was far from concrete.
4) He's always been smart, and he's always been ballsy, but whenever he'd try to combine the two it'd usually backfire hard - of course, I'm pretty sure he was a 'Wolf when he did his most daring gambits. When he was a Villager, his ploys were much more subdued - but definitely trolling for responses.
5) I suspect he's learned how to pull of a gambit as a 'Wolf better than he has in the past, and I think he would have been fine if not put under such pressure. The back and forth has made me question my original inclination, so if anything I'm in the middle between 'Wolf and Villager. I don't have strong feelings either way, but I've lost that original Villager vibe I had, so in lieu of that what's left is all the growing suspicion against him, and some of it from people I'd trust.

catwalk, I am not sure I understand. The two people you trust most do trust me the most in regards to the mayor job. And due to their votes it seems right now that I will be elected. And now you ask them to switch off of me so that you can put 3 votes on someone? So that we have 4,4,3,3 votes on 4 different candidates? How exactly is that helping to not give the wolves the perfect opportunity to get that job?

Serdoa put it perfectly, and made me see something else. Catwalk's been on my radar since the get-go, but with people like Meiz saying that's just his style I was willing to give him a bit of a reprieve (also because, like someone else whom I forget, I'm not big on lynching newbies in the first day or two). Right now, though, I can't decide if he's just fishing for answers or trying to spread doubt - worth pondering.