WW11 - Civilization

[MJW (ya that one)]

Divine Right because I am a king, you will have a different tech as that makes no sense for you

Okay then. I have to think if your role claim makes sense, from the metagame viewpoint. If it does I'll just stick to tusanke unless something else happens.

[Meiz]

Ok, after re-reading Jkaen's posts there are couple of bizarre things, which make me doubt my earlier statement...

You said:

I did also get told i have kowledge of a tech like subject that linked to my ability, and assume it is just fluff

So how does Divine right fit to the feud?

If you have the same power as MJW, why did you vote against him in http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showpost....tcount=278 ?
After all, you knew he had the same power. Didn't that make his claim more believable and therefore make you see him as more likely villgaer?

[Meiz]

I worded that a bit badly. First question is out of interest and the MJW voting is the bizarre part I was talking about.

[Jkaen]

Divine Right fits me believing a king not a (whatever Napoleon is) should rule France

Its my understanding powers are determined first then teams decided

[zakalwe]

Posting from my phone.

I may be willing to lynch Scooter or Sareln. I am not gung ho about Tasunke, I was just. correcting the tally.

[Mardoc]

Okay then. I have to think if your role claim makes sense, from the metagame viewpoint. If it does I'll just stick to tusanke unless something else happens.

Uber made a point of telling us that he would assign powers first, then choose teams randomly. I can easily believe that Jkaen is a feuder with you, without that meaning anything about whether he's civilized or a NAPster.

[Meiz]

Jkaen you missed the important question.

The first question was a brainfart, sorry about that

[Meiz]

Argh, sorry, the message was sent before it should have been.

I meant to add: knowing what MJW had told about his role, you still didn't hesitate to vote for him. So you're basically saying you suspected he was pulling a clever wolf plot?

[Jkaen]

Didn't that make his claim more believable and therefore make you see him as more likely villgaer?

Its my understanding powers are determined first then teams decided

[MJW (ya that one)]

Jkaen

1. There is nothing much to suggest that he is not a wolf. There are just a bunch of fluff posts by him and wasting his vote on useless votes. The only time he started posting was when he was under attack.

2. There are some minor things to suggest that he is a wolf. He gave up his starting tech to easily. If he where a villager he would just say "I have a tech that makes no sense for you to have" or use a phase from the tech name that shows that. He also gave up his "power" too early. 3+ hours is forever in this game.

There is also the issue that Jkaen said he was acting like a power-role or wolf but then said he was not a powerole. So he said he was a wolf indirectly.

3. I think his roleclaim does not make sense. First I think becoming immune from night kill is a "random" role. It is unlikely uberfish would clone the "random" role for the feuders. It is also boring to make them the same. Also I think at least one "random" role is too good to clone.

If it is not "random" then the feuders are overpowered together when on the same villager team. Why? Because the fact that there is a feud has a high chance of leaking. When one of the feuders eats it the wolfs would want to kill the other one as quickly as possible to aviod the feuder from using a power of his. However, the abilty would prevent the nightkill from working. So if it is not "random" this step-up has a high chance of the village being given a free night-save.

---