I actually hate when people do what I'm about to do but I have a few moments and suddenly feel compelled by this brief burst of agreeing with Rowain to try and add to the discussion. I'm going to try and come up with whatever I can think about each of the players remaining (I'll ignore myself as I'm hopelessly biased there by knowing my innocence.) I'll start with Rowain since I've been talking to him.
Rowain - Odd power, better for a wolf but that means nothing since we know uberfish doles out the powers, asks questions later. Has been his usual curmudgeonly self. Haven't found myself agreeing with him much. Usual penchant for wild conspiracy theories. Probably innocent.
Catwalk - Has some sort of power. Been more reasonable of late than I remember him. Haven't wanted to punch him really at all, which could be a sign of his improving play, my declining play or him being coached by a wolfpack. Probably innocent.
Tasunke -
Probably innocent.
Lewwyn - Who knows? There's been a drunken rampage, but he'd do that no matter what he drew. I always find him suspicious. Usual battles with Catwalk, but that's to be expected. His weird super-analysis post of Mardoc smells fishy but he's also prone to bizarre play. Complete null read.
Selrahc - Everything he's done has blended in completely. I've discounted him to large extent due to disagreeing with the players who've accused him. Has a power that would be stronger for a wolf. Was after Catwalk most of the game, which is usually a waste of time. No real read, but definitely could be guilty.
novice -Confirmed innocent.
MJW - He's been odder than usual. Dropped his usual Sareln vigilante push early - because both are NAP? His power is assumed but we don't know its exactly the same as Jkaen's - could be a lynch prevention or something totally different. I've not agreed with him at any point in the game. Really weird actions end of day 2. Definitely possible NAP.
Mardoc - Seemed very Mardocian on day 1, doubting himself and the like. Has faded more to the back since then. I've assumed innocent for a long time, but could be wrong there.
Sareln - Made courage play to go with zak and I on Ichabod on Day 2 before the tracking result, that's ballsy if wolf. Has lurked as usual. His scooter defense reeked of wolf trying to gain brownie points as we lynched a villager since it was based on such weak grounds. Definitely in the conversation for guilty.
Cyneheard - Has he been playing? Definite lurker wolf possibility.
Slowcheetah - Agree 100% with Lewwyn's read. Definitely lurker wolf possibility.
After typing all that I'm not certain I'm any closer to a good read. But I'm not kidding that I think a vig shot at one of the lurkers seems a decent idea, just so we don't waste a whole day debating someone who won't debate. If we don't have a vig, well its moot, but we usually have a vig. Of the talkers, MJW or Selrahc is probably the most likely guilty but I suppose after how wrong I was on scooter maybe I shouldn't be the one to decide.
