Addendum @ Meiz I'm not voting for me 
|
Werewolf 12: Game Thread
|
Sareln Wrote:@ Pling if you thought my first vote for Ichabod wasn't serious, that's your fault. I think saying it's "my fault" is a little harsh, it was a bare vote at a time when most people weren't being serious, I'm not sure how I was supposed to tell it was serious  Commodore - you're not helping me think of you as less odd or as more innocent. I'm comfortable leaving my vote with you. General note: I may or may not be back again later this evening, probably not tho.
...wounding her only makes her more dangerous!
 -- haphazard1It's More Fun to be Jack of All Trades than Master of One. Mardoc Wrote:As for the current situation - maybe it's because of the number of players, but it feels like fog to me. I can't keep straight who's accusing who and for what. I do find Ichabod self-contradictory - your reason for voting me was my vagueness, and now you're castigating people for being certain of themselves? I'm as confused as you are, Mardoc. That's too much to handle right now with so much players. I don't suspect you because you were vague. I'm probably the most vague player right now, so that would be pretty hypocrite of me. I suspected you because I felt you were taking too much precaution about your vote on pling. But that's just one thing, it doesn't mean I'm dead certain that you are a wolf. What I'm criticizing about "players who are certain" is that being sure on day 1 can be two things: 1. You are good at fooling yourself. 2. You really want people to follow your vote, because of 1. or because you want to be able to say later: I was the one who caught the wolf. So, you try to appear certain so that people will follow you. Of course, there's also 3. A wolf trying to replicate the behaviours mentioned above. But overall, there was no need to say this. Wether it's true or not, it won't change the game in one bit, nor will it help the village getting wolves (maybe a bit by making people avoid tunnel vision). The big reason why I said it was because I didn't like the current lynch candidates (MNG and Rowain) and some people seemed to be "certain" about them. So I was kind of urging them to look at other points of view now that we still have time to discuss. Catwalk Wrote:With time ticking, I would like to suggest that we pick one of the top four candidates for tonight's lynch: Commodore, Mr. Nice Guy, Rowain and Ichabod. It's unlikely that other candidates will gain sufficient traction, especially with Europeans going to bed in a few hours.  Not this again!Catwalk, I still don't see any value in narrowing the field beyond the point where everyone in it is plausibly in danger. You were a villager last time you reasoned this way, but you're still wrong! @Rowain - can you remind me of the connection between MNG and Zak? Because right now, I'm suspicious of MNG and not of Zak, so the connection ought to change that, either clearing MNG or making me suspicious of Zak. @Ichabod - I grant that what you're describing is suspicious. I'm not really convinced what you're describing is what I actually did, though. But then I remember my own train of thought, which was feeling Pling was off, but not being able to explain why, not until I had worried at the problem a bit. Maybe I didn't communicate that well.
EitB 25 - Perpentach
Occasional mapmaker
Unofficial Tally
----------------- Rowain (5) - Serdoa, zakalwe, Gaspar, Catwalk, Novice Commodore (4) - Jkaen, Lewwyn, uberfish, pling Mr. Nice Guy (3) - Injera, Rowain, Pindicator Pindicator (3) - Ichabod, Meiz, Mardoc Tasunke (2) - Mr. Nice Guy, Commodore Ichabod (2) - Sareln, Tasunke Molach (1) - Bigger No vote - Molach Showing Work: Rowain Wrote:Addendum @ Meiz I'm not voting for me What, you're suggesting I... I made a mistake? Impossible I tell you! I believe the votes atm: Rowain (5) - Serdoa, zakalwe, Gaspar, Catwalk, novice Commodore (4) - Jkaen, Lewwyn, uberfish, pling Mr. Nice Guy (3) - Injera, Rowain, Pindicator Pindicator (3) - Ichabod, Meiz, Mardoc Ichabod (2) - Sareln, Tasunke Tasunke (2) - Mr. Nice Guy, Commodore Molach (1) - Bigger pling (1) - pindicator No vote - Molach And this doesn't make any sense: Catwalk Wrote:With time ticking, I would like to suggest that we pick one of the top four candidates for tonight's lynch: Commodore, Mr. Nice Guy, Rowain and Ichabod. It's unlikely that other candidates will gain sufficient traction, especially with Europeans going to bed in a few hours. pling Wrote:I think saying it's "my fault" is a little harsh, it was a bare vote at a time when most people weren't being serious, I'm not sure how I was supposed to tell it was serious You're right. Fault's a little bit harsh but reading it was feeling weird as you attributed to me ideas that I hadn't even thought :neenernee. You could see how that would bring out the harsher side  .Looks like there's no will for Ichabod today. I am liking Rowain more for innocent than not right now. I think it's a bit weird how MNG snapped at me earlier, so I'll vote Mr. Nice Guy. |
