|
Are you, in fact, a pregnant lady who lives in the apartment next door to Superdeath's parents? - Commodore |
|
Werewolf 12: Game Thread
|
Jkaen Wrote:Easy way to resolve this, can anybody else with no role please step forward, if so I will drop the think on commodore, if not can people give me more benefit for the theory Jkaen, it's not that simple. Presuming the two pack theory, it's quite possible for both of you to be wolves. And you're not the first to propose lynching Commodore, not by a long shot.
EitB 25 - Perpentach
Occasional mapmaker
Wow Molach, weighty post. We should vote to lynch you more often, it seems. For now, though, consider the objections sated. I don't really want to see Tasunke fall off the radar, though. He claimed a role and lied about it at least once, and it cannot be ignored that his timing for having a limitation is very convenient for him...he scans Sareln, finds nothing or at least nothing he wants to reveal, and then when he can use it to help the village, he finds himself limited.
Ichabod, care to help Tasunke out again?
If only you and me and dead people know hex, then only deaf people know hex.
I write RPG adventures, and blog about it, check it out. Commodore Wrote:He claimed a role and lied about it at least once, He did? He's been less than forthcoming, true, and been willing to let us assume things about his role, but I haven't seen a direct lie. Care to point me to it?
EitB 25 - Perpentach
Occasional mapmaker Mardoc Wrote:Jkaen, it's not that simple. Presuming the two pack theory, it's quite possible for both of you to be wolves. And you're not the first to propose lynching Commodore, not by a long shot. How is that relevant? If there are no other vanilla roles then commodore is a WW. It then means that single argument cant be used against e, and people have to use other ones they make up. I am not saying commodore being guilty clears me (although it helps), but it does mean we get a wolf Mardoc Wrote:He did? He's been less than forthcoming, true, and been willing to let us assume things about his role, but I haven't seen a direct lie. Care to point me to it? I'll rescind that. Change "lie" to "made Commodore think for some odd reason his watcher limitation implied a limited number of watches rather than a limitation on his rate of watching". So my bad. Made an ass out of you and me. Nonetheless, the whole shiftiness still smells a bit. I'd think that a gimped watcher means a wolf watcher.
If only you and me and dead people know hex, then only deaf people know hex.
I write RPG adventures, and blog about it, check it out.
I'm with Jkaen here. Suspecting him because he assumes that Commodore is a wolf because there seem to be no other vanilla villager is dumb imo. I completely agree with him on that: If there is no other villager coming forward and telling us that he has no power, I assume that Commodore lies (because I have one and Jkaen probably does too and as none of the others have said anything to the effect of not having one, I assume now that everyone has one).
I also agree with Molach that Tasunke has a very "convenient" power it seems. And that it would make sense that he can only use it every other day because he is a wolf and they might have to switch who is allowed to do night actions. As for Tasunke lieing: I don't care if he did not directly do it. He is always revealing only as much as needed, not clarifying if we assume something wrong. He is the perfect show of a shady, non-helpful player - and taking into account how much votes he already got, he should be much more interested to help the village and make people believe. But he does not. Instead, the only thing he makes me want to do is lynch him. That said: Tasunke |
