Werewolf 13: Lurker Thread [No Live Players]

[Molach]

Hm. Suddenly there are two alphas missing. Sorry Bigger I think I'd go for you now. 1 missing could have an explanation, but hm.

Question is if thestick scry is still legit. I think it is.

Lewwyn why zeta? Instead of gamma.

[Rowain]

Thoughts on balance:

I mostly agree with what Lewwyn said about balance. In hindsight, the short wolves pushing Rowain after the scry might have been a mistake. Rowain's reaction might have been a mistake too, he could have shaken off the accusations easily, and the short wolves weren't planning a claim. It also could have been better for the short wolves to sacrifice Zak than to have Bigger claim. OTOH we don't know the alternative outcomes for any of these decisions, and I don't think they are obviously better.

for novice

[spoiler]
There is no might - it was a mistake. After zaks claim of silverblood (which got a bad reaction immediatly long before Biggers claim) it was clear that zak is not saveable.
So drawing attention to himself and telling town that he has a scan-ability when he knew that my death would reveal that such ability is in possession of the wolves was in anyway or form a mistake.

Tomorrow the village only has one decision: lynch thestick or lynch Bigger. Had Bigger been silent the village would be as clueless as it gets with just 2 days past without any discussion.

About balance: I think this game was quite in favor of the wolves.
The first 2 days and 2 nights went nearly as well as possible (2 silverbloods take a wolf with them 1 sleeper gets lynched) and still the wolves (well the last pack) do have a chance to win.

PS and yes the village might think itself into knots too afterall this game suffers a great deal of village-silence

[/spoiler]

[waterbat]

If the village shuts up for the night and a case isn't made against Bigger, he could turn up dead in the morning. Zak flipping zeta will only matter if the packs decide bigger will definitely be an easier target afterward thestick. If he turns up being correct on thestick, Its going to be more difficult.

I didn't think about the reveal, but with cover and no way to communicate those intentions before doing so, I doubt they will consider it either.

Does the village need to decide if zak was recruited N1? If they think that, it means the short alpha still has skry ability - which would clearly fit the bigger- zak connection. However, I think zak was recruited later ( after bigger skryd Rowain ) and bigger has been making up the results since then.

[waterbat]

Agreed molach - bigger seems a better target first. Will the packs decide the village will go for that?

As far as the question about zeta, I thought the same thing. Leaving a few slots open for other converts, perhaps

I'm still a proponent of the 3.3.3 theory. I think we might even see another silver death tonight.

[waterbat]

Prediction for night kills: mng scooter serdoa

The problem is going to be packs choosing the same target, but like I said, an extra kill silver kill might get thrown in.

[Catwalk]

If MNG is not eaten, anyone not voting for him will be outing himself as a wolf.

[waterbat]

Regorraring up this thread hard core! Of course, now with bigger looking more like the short alpha and talking like he still has his powers, the other packs are going to be even less likely to hit him as he might also still be immune.

[waterbat]

Thanks catwalk for breaking those up! Not voting for him? You mean for mayor assuming scooter does die?

[pindicator]

Thanks catwalk for breaking those up! Not voting for him? You mean for mayor assuming scooter does die?

Thats a good point; village should be looking at MNG for mayor if scooter does die tonight. It seems pretty likely 1 or 2 packs will target scooter too. Besides being mayor he is the most active villager.

So assuming the short pack is down to just its alpha, how likely do you think that the alpha renounces its powers to be able to night kill?

[waterbat]

Pindi: I think he already renounced it before recruiting zak. I don't think they killed zak N1, so their alpha doesn't have powers.