WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[Lewwyn]

34sy t0 ch2ck
Bigger

Oh man. This had me rolling on the couch.

As GingerEagle would say:

[Rowain]

You voted for pind for voting for VM, that seems to be defending him straight off

I attacked Pind that is in my book something very different than defending somebody. Or do you say that you defend Pind (or Meiz) with your attack on me? This would beg the question why do you defend those 2?

You realise the post you quote was an answer to Molach? And was an answer on principle and has little to do with who the newbie is in what game and doesn't have any bearing on this game in particular? Molach stated that attacking the new guy right away is smart play and I have a different opinion.

Please note the key-point: Attacking the new player right away without giving him a chance to introduce himself. That is the crucial point and why I thought pindicator suspicious

[Twinkletoes89]

So what?

It amuses me - we never seem to get the right read on each other. As the record shows, I was innocent every single time and yet you always pushed to lynch me, whilst I think it was the same for you and I always had you near the top of my list!

DISCLAIMER - I am not casting any aspersions on zak's credibility in this game, simply noting with nostalgia our inabillity to read each other.

Why would it matter if you throw your vote around? As long as you have it in a good place come lynchtime, there doesn't seem to be any harm in switching once you have the answers you want. Unless you are a wolf trying to develop a nice voting record?

Mainly because of my spotty accessibility.

I have had times where I've been called into work at short notice, decided to go out with the other half or with friends or simply lose connectivity and if I throw my vote around and then can't get back on to change it then I think that is not serving the village. I want to be able to vote and be sure in my head that should I not be able to come back on before a deadline, I would be able to defend it.

[Meiz]

First pindicator is suspicioous for voting a newbie right at the start of the game before he even has a chance to connect and say a word.

I'm saying that he could have voted for anyone just as easily. I personally think it's a good tactic to apply pressure early for the unknown players to get a better read from them.

2nd: I clearly stated we should give newbies time totalk. But I also said if he gives of wolfsigns we should vote right forhim (without a timerestriction).

But getting him to talk is what gives the possibility to get the possible wolf signs.

3rd Your case rests on the fact that a) I did defend VN which is not true and b) on your assumption that VN is a villager which begs the question why do you believe that.
Do you have more knowledge than we do? Perhaps a little cheatsheet?

It's early in the game and I'm far from making that big assumptions. I said it could be a good wolf tactic to defend an innocent early in the game, but it could also be a wolf defending wolf, villager defending a wolf or maybe you both are villagers. I'm not expecting to hit everything correct, just trying to type what goes on in my head.

[Rowain]

just trying to type what goes on in my head.

If that were true your posts would be empty.

[VM]

00000h, 1nsults! 1 f33l h0m3 4lr34dy!

[Rowain]

What do you mena with insults? Thats just the way we show our love for each other

[VM]

<3 Rowain

Ps: 1ll st1ll lynch y0u

[uberfish]

@uberfish, is there a public penalty for breaking post restriction?

No, any penalties for breaking post restrictions that might or might not exist will be handed out by PM.

[zakalwe]

Reading more carefully, I want to comment on this also...

This was my way of at least challenging him without trying to say definitively one way or another what he is.

So that was your way of being aggressive? "I bet you're scum! Maybe. Although I can't say for sure. Confess!"

You probably should give serious consideration to actually, you know... voting.

@Rowain. So you don't think what's going on inside Meiz' head is "muahaha, Rowain is such an easy mislynch, look at him digging"?

@Uberfish. Can we expect an introduction to materialize in the second post, or will we have to wait until the first lynch scene before we get a theme to work with? Judging by the title alone, it seems like we've got some kind of Bridget Jones theme, which honestly fails to inspire me.