WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[Lewwyn]

Alright chumps lets do this!

Leeeeewwwwwwyyynnnn Jeeeeennnkiiiiinnnsss!!!

Oh.

At least I got Chicken.

[novice]

My post restriction is indeed gone, helping kill a wolf let me grow a spine and start speaking up for myself. So ask away, Pindicator.

I would think Lewwyn was killed primarily because he gave off investigator vibes, so framejobwise it's wifom. I think Lewwyn's latest post on Pindicator was good though - Pin was mentally prepared that Injera was a wolf, but still waited until last minute to vote him, and then immediately had a scum buddy analysis ready?

Also, Pindicator, why is it significant that Lewwyn asked Slowcheetah for his nose? And was Meiz one of Lewwyn's suspects?

Pindicator

[Bigger]

lewwyn was killed because his instincts have been sharp this game - he was on the wolves trail. (I didn't see what he saw in Injera before the lynch, but it was there). I think we should look at who he suspected.


waterbat, seriously, WTF was that?

[Bigger]

I still suspect slowcheetah, but Pin and mattimeo voting for him off the bat make me really not want to lynch him today. hmm.

I dont know what to think of waterbat. Maybe he got stoned last night?

In any case, a Pindicator seems appropriate.


Novice, very happy your restriction is lifted. I couldnt understand your point in half your posts;.

[Bigger]

Darn it wish I knew what that actually meant!

me too. I still haven't figured out what an impatient werewolf is.

[Bigger]

lewwyn was killed because his instincts have been sharp this game - he was on the wolves trail. (I didn't see what he saw in Injera before the lynch, but it was there).

also because I think I made it pretty clear I was going to follow his lead going forward. so he effectively had a voting power of 2, maybe more as I probably wasn't the only one willing to follow him. I'm not sure if it was a mistake on my part to be so obvious or not.

[Bigger]

Since I'm now not sure about Waterbat, I want to see other alignments first. Slowcheetah=wolf would imply Waterbat=innocent, I think.

I don't follow, why would slowcheetah's alignment tell us anything about waterbat's alignment?

Why don't you think that it's possible both waterbat and I are innocent?

that's possible, just highly unlikely - based mostly on your day 2 voting patterns and not even taking intuitive reads into account. In fact, I thought previously you might both be wolves, until Lewwyn pointed out how your accusation of waterbat made that unlikely.

[pindicator]

My post restriction is indeed gone, helping kill a wolf let me grow a spine and start speaking up for myself. So ask away, Pindicator.

Glad to see that is gone. Although you were getting pretty good with the quotes.
I want to ask you who you think your top suspects are. How kind of you to start it off with me. But humor me - I say you are wrong about me being a wolf, so if this mislynch gains steam you'll need to have ideas on who to pursue after. We've gone most of the game with you just being able to post little bits here and there; I'd like to see you be able to explain what you've been thinking behind your votes.

I would think Lewwyn was killed primarily because he gave off investigator vibes, so framejobwise it's wifom. I think Lewwyn's latest post on Pindicator was good though - Pin was mentally prepared that Injera was a wolf, but still waited until last minute to vote him, and then immediately had a scum buddy analysis ready?

What's wolfy about thinking over the possibilities? Were you wondering who was going to be night killed last night? Don't you think ahead towards the end of the day and start to wonder: "If this guy flips wolf, who was trying to save him and how can we find a wolf there? Or if he flips village then who was pushing loudest for them and why?" Injera turning wolf seemed better at giving us info, since we hadn't seen any wolves yet. And I got excited when we Injera turned out to be a wolf, so I got carried away with that when I posted.

Speaking of which, do you think we should try to figure more out about waterbat's chicken post before pushing him about his Day 2 voting? This feels like a setup in several different ways: first to try to get lewwyn's night kill framed on me, and then with suspicion on waterbat all of the sudden it looks like he can't defend himself. It's a little too convenient, and it makes me really think I was wrong about my post implicating him. Not saying he's innocent either, just that I think it's better to be able to communicate with him rather than railroading him if he can't say anything other than chicken. Especially when there are other people that to be looked into.

Also, Pindicator, why is it significant that Lewwyn asked Slowcheetah for his nose? And was Meiz one of Lewwyn's suspects?

Speculation. I have no idea if slowcheetah had his nose or not. But Lewwyn asked people if they had his nose on two separate occasions: both at night, and both were people he suspected at the time. Yes, he suspected Meiz in Day 1, or at least early on he did, because in post #17 he voted for him. Then for day 2 he had suspicions against slowcheetah - see posts #443 & #446. So I'm guessing his PM role told him that a wolf had his nose and he could only ask them once per night. Which is why I think it's significant he asked slowcheetah - I also think slowcheetah's lack of response is significant. Everybody else has made jokes bout it when Lewwyn brought it up; but slowcheetah ignored it.

[Rowain]

Sad to see you gone Lewwyn.

[Bigger]

I think its more likely waterbat is screwing with us. I find it curious that you're that only one concerned with what it means. It's easy to decode regardless - he finds me, mattimeo, sareln and slowcheetah suspicious, he thinks TT is a wolf, and he especially thinks you are a wolf. and he's voting for you (last red name counts).

xposting with Rowain, you=Pindicator