WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[novice]

Bigger, why did you not claim miller immediately on day one?

Also, you never made an effort not to lynch Injera, but you wanted a third candidate? What's the difference?

[Rowain]

Because I rethought about it. And I looked closer at the votes at the time of your switch and your action.

At close look I didn't like your: unvote - make tally- vote Injera routine. It looked abit like 'Do I have a chance to save Injera?' No so lets vote him and get cover.

Additional I do have a huge problem in finding a logical explanation of the votepatterns/actions with you as village. You as wolf OTOH does bring some sense into it.

[Bigger]

Molach, I think, asked me earlier for a list of wolves. here goes:

Most of my info is from day 2. I got very little info from day 1, unfortunately.

almost certainly innocent: zak, novice (still feels wolfish, but I don't see how he could logically be one, so..), then - molach, Sareln
probably innocent: mattimeo

top suspects: pindicator, slowcheetah
In unlikely event pindicator is innocent, then waterbat

secondary suspects:
1. TT (mostly for the claimed Lewwyn killing, yuck)
2. Rowain
3. Jkaen is possible, but would require both TT and Rowain both being innocent

If I had complete control of lynches, I would go pin-slowcheetah- then either Rowain or TT (not sure which first atm).

[Bigger]

Bigger, why did you not claim miller immediately on day one?

Also, you never made an effort not to lynch Injera, but you wanted a third candidate? What's the difference?

what would that have gained? its not a useful role that would have saved me from a mislynch.

The difference is I never made any attempt to save Injera, I just wasn't convinced early in the day. later I was.

Anyway, if I'm mislynched, especially if slowcheetah and pin both switch to me, look at my list.

[Rowain]

@Bigger You know I do agree with most of the list except that I would put Jkaen higher than TT (because of day 2) and me.

But if you look at your innocent list and look at the voting pattern of both days you realise they only make sense if you are a wolf.

So if you turn out as village the innocent list has a problem.

[Bigger]

@Bigger You know I do agree with most of the list except that I would put Jkaen higher than TT (because of day 2) and me.

But if you look at your innocent list and look at the voting pattern of both days you realise they only make sense if you are a wolf.

So if you turn out as village the innocent list has a problem.

do what now?

I didn't go back and look at day 1, as I know two villagers were up for vote that day. I AM village, so please explain again what you are talking about, I don't understand at all.

[zakalwe]

But if you look at your innocent list and look at the voting pattern of both days you realise they only make sense if you are a wolf.

Sorry for being lazy, but can you spell out why this is so? Sounds like there might be a compelling argument in here but it's not immediately apparent to me.

[Bigger]

@Bigger You know I do agree with most of the list except that I would put Jkaen higher than TT (because of day 2) and me.

But if you look at your innocent list and look at the voting pattern of both days you realise they only make sense if you are a wolf.

So if you turn out as village the innocent list has a problem.

this seems to be agreeing with my suspects, and at the same time sowing seeds to discredit my list once I hang innocent

IF I was a wolf, THEN my innocent list would have a problem, duh.

[Jkaen]

@Bigger You know I do agree with most of the list except that I would put Jkaen higher than TT (because of day 2) and me.

But if you look at your innocent list and look at the voting pattern of both days you realise they only make sense if you are a wolf.

So if you turn out as village the innocent list has a problem.

sorry Rowain, I am higher on the wolf list or higher on the village list?

[Rowain]

I do agree with your list of innocents. If you are a wolf those people all beeing innocent makes sense but if you are a villager than there is a problem with this list.