WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[Twinkletoes89]

What I will say though, is that I am pretty sure we will find at least one wolf out of these four:

Pindicator, Zakalwe, Bigger, Sareln.

These were the four people who made the late move towards lynching Rowain in the last day. At one point he was level with Slowcheetah for lynching and with a lot of momentum. As we know slowcheetah was a wolf, I am sure we will find one or more hiding in there as it would have been a chance to save him.

[pindicator]

@Rowain - I'm sorry to keep bringing this up, but can you give me an answer that isn't so coy? I just don't get your thought process behind waterbat.

I'd like to get some communication on this before the end of the day. Else i may start thinking Bigger's claims have merit. They are plausible, after all. Are they more plausible than bigget being scum? That is the question

[zakalwe]

That seems like a reasonable assumption, Twinkletoes. My preference is still to lynch Bigger today, and then take it from there.

A mass claim feels premature to me.

[Twinkletoes89]

Given a choice between Bigger and Sareln, I still think Sareln should go first.

Bigger at least talks a lot, which gives us more to hold him to account and if he is innocent then we have a more useful villager.

Sareln gives us nothing.

[Bigger]

What I will say though, is that I am pretty sure we will find at least one wolf out of these four:

Pindicator, Zakalwe, Bigger, Sareln.

These were the four people who made the late move towards lynching Rowain in the last day. At one point he was level with Slowcheetah for lynching and with a lot of momentum. As we know slowcheetah was a wolf, I am sure we will find one or more hiding in there as it would have been a chance to save him.

Your point assumes that Rowain is innocent. It is disturbing to me that so many people are making that leap. If anything, his role claim makes him appear more scummy, as has his activity since slowcheetahs lynch.

I also feel I should point out once again that slowcheetah wasn't in the group that switched to Rowain, he stayed on me. That is a big clue to both my and rowains alignment.

[pindicator]

Given a choice between Bigger and Sareln, I still think Sareln should go first.

Bigger at least talks a lot, which gives us more to hold him to account and if he is innocent then we have a more useful villager.

Sareln gives us nothing.

I'm not in love with sareln, but I can follow that reasoning. I think if Bigger flips wolf then sareln is likely where the last wolf is, but if Bigger isn't a wolf then maybe sareln is indeed being sareln.

[Rowain]

I'd like to get some communication on this before the end of the day. Else i may start thinking Bigger's claims have merit. They are plausible, after all. Are they more plausible than bigget being scum? That is the question

What exactly do you not get? and why do you so insist on the waterbat-thing. And how do you see it: Was chickening waterbat scummy, towny or neutral?


Jkaen I would still like your answers to my questions. zakalwe too:

Who do you see as missing wolf if Bigger turns wolfy?

And who do you see as the 2 missing wolves if Bigger turns up innocent?

So far only pindicator has really bothered to answer.

And since I am in 20questions-mood:
Sareln whom would you vote for if it weren't your nape on 2nd place?

To help you: Molach

[novice]

Jkaen I would still like your answers to my questions. zakalwe too:

Who do you see as missing wolf if Bigger turns wolfy?

And who do you see as the 2 missing wolves if Bigger turns up innocent?

Would you like me to answer this, too?

I see Sareln as a pretty obvious fit with a Bigger wolf, although I prefer to lynch Bigger first, to keep our momentum going.

If Bigger flips villager I think his Waterbat + Rowain theory merits looking into.

[Rowain]

Thank you

[Bigger]

rowain