WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[waterbat]

Bah. Back to the drawing board.

no, not back to the drawering board.

i need a WHY YOU NO meme.

WHY YOU NO lynch pindicator first?

To be honest, even though I didnt think Bigger guilty, I did fear him turning up red-meat eating wolf and I would have missed the third wolf-wagon this game.

I know bigger had suspected me, but his turning up wolf just means he doesn't know any better than the rest of us village peoples. I feel bad - if he hadn't kept mentioning me as wolf, would I have mounted a defence? probably not, its hard to do much on an iPhone - although - my power supply came in - this is NOT posted on an iPhone!

when Sun comes up, whether I am dead or alive, please lets get on the pindi-train. I think TT might be onto something - that we have 1 deep wolf - lets get the obvious one out of the way.

Oh - also, nice playing with you Bigger (and presumably Mattimeo). Too bad our watcher bit the dust - he'd be nice to have now. (watcher can tell who visited a target, right?)

I dont necessarily suspect Rowain, even though I was annoyed at him, as if he chickened me as wolf - why not subsequently push for my mislynch?

anymore - more to come in daybreak, assuming I don't meet the cruel hand of fate tonight

[pindicator]

I'm thinking about a reveal to get the conversation going into a productive direction. As I said before, just my role will not clear me, but I think how I used it will show my intentions are for the village.

And I may need to reveal before the night is up, because wolves are likely going to target mattimeo tonight. So mattimeo needs to hit a wolf. I think bigger's advise is pretty good there: narrow it down to your two most likely wolves and flip a coin. If we don't have a night kill then you can tell us who you targeted. That'd be hilarious to have him prevent kills two nights in a row

So maybe I should reveal before the night is over to help him whittle down the choices. I'll think on it -- heading out to see a film after work with some friends -- and then hopefully I'll have a resolution.

[Bigger]

if Bigger is innocent, it will surprise me

Surprise!!

Can't say i didn't warn ya. :neenernee


good luck village

[Mattimeo]

Given that it's likely my head on the line tonight, I would be very much appreciative of a mass claim.

Also, joining Bigger on the 'I told you so' wagon

[pindicator]

(Not quite the green light I was looking for, novice. But you said it was okay, so here goes...)

I am the village Matchmaker. I got a one time ability to make a private forum for two people. After the first day I was reasonably sure that zak was village, and I wanted to get novice talking, so I put them together. The "weird" part is that I can see this room but cannot post in it. At least, I gather that's weird because it took some doing to signal to zak and novice that I could see what they wrote.

I didn't signal right away because I wasn't sure they were village at first. But between their initial reactions (it seemed wolves may not be so chatty if they were already chatting in a second thread) and their successful run on Injera, I put them as village and it was time to reveal that I could read their posts.

This is why I think these actions prove I'm village: zak & novice can collaborate that I've used this to help out, that I've been on board with their plans to hunt wolves, and that I've used my access to their forum not to undermine their efforts but to help them along, and for it we've caught 2 wolves. Unfortunately we were wrong on Bigger, else we may never have felt the need to reveal.

How did I signal? I started by copying phrases that one or the other wrote, and after a few times zak asked if maybe I had brought them together. That's when I posted this (post 408) and saw zak catch on that I was the matchmaker who had brought them together. So yes Lewwyn, you were right when you later quoted that post - i was trying to be casual but not for the reasons you thought!

I thought that was enough and they understood, but after my drunk posting (honest drunk posting btw, just stupid by me because it did not help discussion at all) both zak and novice start suspecting me openly in the thread, and I realized they don't know I could read what they were saying. So I started being more obvious, copying whole passages of their posts in that thread into the main thread until they realized I was able to read what they wrote.

So, that's my role and how I've used it. Novice and zak should be able to confirm, and this should show why I've asked about revealing a couple times in thread before actually doing it. I didn't want to give up what are essentially masons without good reason, but I think mattimeo is worth trying to save for it. Apparently so do zak and novice, too.

[pindicator]

Heading to bed - i'll be able to answer questions in the morning

[Rowain]

I would like to see Molach lynched tomorow

For the last spot I'm leaning more towards Jkaen instead of Sareln or waterbat.

(Explnations will follow in some hours)

[zakalwe]

Pindicator speaks the truth.

[novice]

Pindicator speaks the truth.

Verily.

[Twinkletoes89]

I would like to see Molach lynched tomorow

For the last spot I'm leaning more towards Jkaen instead of Sareln or waterbat.

(Explnations will follow in some hours)

Rowain, why can't you seem to settle on who you want to lynch? You seem to be hopping all over the place in the last day or two and its starting to annoy me.

Its starting to suggest to me that you are trying to set up mislynches, and with Bigger's innocence I am starting to wonder about your innocence