WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[Jkaen]

So basically you are saying you are sulking?

[novice]

Molach, to provide an alternative to Rowain.

I'll be a bit busy this game day, on vacation and travelling.

[Jkaen]

I need to re-read at soem point, but going waterbat for now

[zakalwe]

Rowain, you said you might catch Waterbat in a lie, but I really wonder which lie that would be, when all he could say was "chicken". Also, your excuse "well, he did answer" isn't a very good one. Why force him to spend time drawing a sunrise using ASCII art?

Is Waterbat still your top suspect? What's the case against him?

Same question to Jkaen, since he just voted for Waterbat.

[Jkaen]

Truth be told no real case at all, just from the reading through he sticks in my mind as slightly scummy. I have no argument at all worth posting, hence why I said i need a re-read

[Rowain]

Rowain, you said you might catch Waterbat in a lie, but I really wonder which lie that would be, when all he could say was "chicken". Also, your excuse "well, he did answer" isn't a very good one. Why force him to spend time drawing a sunrise using ASCII art?

He has been quite successfull to get his opinions known despite the restriction. So I wanted to give him a chance to hang himself. The first possible lie was that it didn't stack. The seciond possible lie was that his first restriction is gone with the chicken-curse. The end of the chickencurse question was just a fluff-question to hide my knowledge about it and to hide the importance of Q1 and 3.

Apparently you don't believe me. That is not the problem. But if you don't believe me than you must have an alternative interpretation of my action.

So tell me what do you believe was the reason for my action?

[zakalwe]

No, I didn't call for the person to reveal. Was simply curious as to if someone was going to come forward. Also was curious who would be first to correct me that I only considered the doctor side and not the role-blocker side. Anyway - Matt's claim preempted that however. Seems like I can't win anything this game.

Waterbat, am I reading you correctly here? Looks like you're saying that you deliberately omitted role-blocking as a potential cause for the no kill, as a trap for the wolves?

[zakalwe]

Rowain, you're saying it's my job to explain your behavior? I fear that may be beyond my capabilities. :neenernee

[Rowain]

Rowain, you're saying it's my job to explain your behavior? I fear that may be beyond my capabilities. :neenernee

Why didn't you believe my explanation for my behaviour then?

[zakalwe]

I don't feel obliged to accept a bad explanation just because no better explanation immediately springs to mind.