Posts: 2,511
Threads: 4
Joined: Mar 2012
Jkaen Wrote:Not buying it pind.
The main reason is your point 4. If you havea deep cover wolf you don't get them to do the night kills, you get the wolf under suspicion anyway to do the kills
I don't agree with this fully.
hmm i am thinking to last game where some wolves had night kill ability, some didn't.
maybe novice's post restriction comes back if he doesnt keep up the killing <shrug> This is total speculation, plus if he was jailed, it would have come back, right? 
I need to go now, but will be on phone.
--
Best dating advice on RB: When you can't hide your unit, go in fast and hard. -- Sullla
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
waterbat Wrote:I don't agree with this fully.
hmm i am thinking to last game where some wolves had night kill ability, some didn't.
maybe novice's post restriction comes back if he doesnt keep up the killing <shrug> This is total speculation, plus if he was jailed, it would have come back, right?
I need to go now, but will be on phone.
That was the first time that had happended. Not having seen any PMs obviously I don't know the wolves kill rules or win conditions, but would be surprised if we didnt return to all wolves can kill again
Why would his post restriction come back if he was jailed?
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Maybe you all see something I don't but not convinced by any arguements right now, so really can't see me lynching Novice today.
Annoyingly my top 2 suspects are Molach and Pind who were the top 2 suspects, although I see Novice has drawn up level now.
Did we really have both wolves up at the start of the day?
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Ok, thought more on the vig roles, and I think we may have a few double edged swords here based on Zaks power:
Zaks - Could mason up with anybody of his choice, but increased the chance of them dying
So what if we have:
TT (as villager) - Can vig shot, but only works on villager, would hence identify wolf though for later kill
Pind (as wolf) - Can draw 2 villagers together to give them mason status, but can then read everything they say.
Hence I think TT's vig power is more in fitting with this game. Going to stick on Molach for now
Posts: 3,251
Threads: 18
Joined: Nov 2010
Have a minute now.
Jkaen Wrote:Ok, thought more on the vig roles, and I think we may have a few double edged swords here based on Zaks power:
Zaks - Could mason up with anybody of his choice, but increased the chance of them dying
So what if we have:
TT (as villager) - Can vig shot, but only works on villager, would hence identify wolf though for later kill
Pind (as wolf) - Can draw 2 villagers together to give them mason status, but can then read everything they say.
Hence I think TT's vig power is more in fitting with this game. Going to stick on Molach for now
Not much to add, Zaks power could kill a wolf, as could mine. Others are for information, and especially TT's power could do severe damage (if kill is blocked by other means 2 innocent villagers might well be lynched). And we've never had 2 normal vigilantes in a game before.
Can't help but think I should have lied about my role. I was last to claim (?) so 3-shot tracker would be good & safe. I tracked injera doing a kill which is why I was early & mercilessly on him. Got no other useful results so no real need to claim before. It would actually have been stupid, as it clears me as villager. Even fits with my horoscope, a tracker would surely meet strangers. No harm in lying at this time, as mislynch is game over.
However I am a 1-shot keyword vigilante.
On later.
Posts: 13,563
Threads: 49
Joined: Oct 2009
I literally don't have time for this, but since I'm on the block:
Pin, yesterday you forced a tie, said afterwards that both were obvious villagers, and said that you had hoped WB would lynch. It makes no sense. Now you're very active and painting me as the mythical deep cover wolf. And now WB joined you. I think you've crossed the line from misguided to nefarious.
Pindicator is a wolf swinging for the fences.
I have to run.
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
So you point out we have never had 2 vigilantes before.
Can you hence explain why you:
a. Are not voting for the other person who claimed vigi?
b. Have not been all over him since his claim about 2 days ago?
Posts: 4,471
Threads: 65
Joined: Feb 2006
Pindicator (3) - Molach Novice TT
Novice (2) - Pindicator Waterbat
Molach (1) - Jkaen
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Crossposted there with Novice.
Would prefer a Molach lynch but can live with a Pind one if needs be
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Uber, waterbat is on Novice
|
