WW14 - The Edge of Reason

[pindicator]

Not buying it pind.

The main reason is your point 4. If you havea deep cover wolf you don't get them to do the night kills, you get the wolf under suspicion anyway to do the kills

This is pretty b.s. reasoning you know.
The watcher was killed. And unless someone was going to track novice (and who was going to do that when he had no suspicion)? Then on the next night everybody knew mattimeo was going to get night killed and nobody managed to find out who did that. So no, your counter to point 4 is b.s.

And you know that.

Why are you obvtown, jkaen? I don't get that. All you did was do a convenient "bad" role claim to explain why you were not going to be night killed and why you shouldn't be lynched. In a weird roles game that is the decidedly least weird.

Wolves are either novice/jkaen or waterbat/somebody (maybe TT? maybe jkaen? want novice's take on why he's obvtown but i probably won't get it). Waterbat didn't want to be the first to post the anti-novice argument (#1162 & #1172) and now that it's out there he's hedging that I'm a wolf for putting it forward (#1218)

Maybe I should vote molach just to make sure I piss EVERYBODY off. I'm pretty frustrated at this point but I'll vote waterbat instead. Novice deserves a win more than waterbat does, IMO -- so I'd rather be wrong about novice being a wolf and let him win than be wrong about waterbat being a wolf and let him win, and I'm willing to admit I was wrong in thinking waterbat was village yesterday.

GG village, have fun lynching me and losing

[waterbat]

i disagree i was the only one that didnt want to do an anti-novice statement.

You were delaying as well. I wanted to hear your argument first because I really feared the gift-wrapping of novice and parlaying it into a wolf victory.

i agreed that Jkaen's "refutation" of point #4 was b.s. reasoning.

bah. the refusal to line up against novice as me frustrated too, pindicator.

I'm voting for novice am I not? i tried to get the others to go with me - what more do you want?

and fuck you on the "who deserves it more" lines. you should play for the village win if you are village

[Jkaen]

This is pretty b.s. reasoning you know.
The watcher was killed. And unless someone was going to track novice (and who was going to do that when he had no suspicion)? Then on the next night everybody knew mattimeo was going to get night killed and nobody managed to find out who did that. So no, your counter to point 4 is b.s.

And you know that.

Why are you obvtown, jkaen? I don't get that. All you did was do a convenient "bad" role claim to explain why you were not going to be night killed and why you shouldn't be lynched. In a weird roles game that is the decidedly least weird.

Wolves are either novice/jkaen or waterbat/somebody (maybe TT? maybe jkaen? want novice's take on why he's obvtown but i probably won't get it). Waterbat didn't want to be the first to post the anti-novice argument (#1162 & #1172) and now that it's out there he's hedging that I'm a wolf for putting it forward (#1218)

Maybe I should vote molach just to make sure I piss EVERYBODY off. I'm pretty frustrated at this point but I'll vote waterbat instead. Novice deserves a win more than waterbat does, IMO -- so I'd rather be wrong about novice being a wolf and let him win than be wrong about waterbat being a wolf and let him win, and I'm willing to admit I was wrong in thinking waterbat was village yesterday.

GG village, have fun lynching me and losing

Its not me who said I am obviously town, ask the others about that

[Jkaen]

Well, not leaving things open for a last minute wolf swap to swing it, so lets confirm up Pindicator

[pindicator]

and fuck you on the "who deserves it more" lines. you should play for the village win if you are village

Fine. Point taken. Although all I want to say is "f you village" and self vote. I don't see how a wolf would say this in your spot: if you are a wolf you're getting your mislynch so why voice up?

Fine. you're village, i was right yesterday.

Jkaen and novice it is

[waterbat]

Well, not leaving things open for a last minute wolf swap to swing it, so lets confirm up Pindicator

At 3-1-1-1 , I suspect a swing isn't possible.

Molach, TT - any chance you aren't locked in?

I think pindicators case is sound and he is either village or he is gift-wrapping novice. I think its the former In the latter case, Who knows what/who his follow up case would be.

If he is furry,
This last ditch vote on me seems to be engineered to set me up tomorrow.


I really should have called in sick day. Back on my iPhone and driving until 21:45

[waterbat]

I disagree on jkaen as I don't think injera double faked us on the bigger post.

Jkaen, TT, molach: 2 of you are innocent. Its time to move to novice.

[pindicator]

waterbat, do you think jkaen or novice is the safer bet for wolf? I lean towards jkaen. Novice's case is far more circumstantial - only his actions today show wolfy

[uberfish]

Pindicator (4) - Jkaen Molach Novice TT
Novice (2) - Pindicator Waterbat

[waterbat]

I disagree on jkaen.

Did you see the injera post I quoted?

I'm on novice because I believe he is wolf. Still have little clue on partner.