Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Quote:- Role playing is possible for those that choose too - none of the names will give clues to the scumminess of the player, so revealing your name shouldn't help or hurt you stay alive. Having a general knowledge of Alpha Centauri won't really help you catch wolves or fool the village, although it might help you enjoy the game more
Let me just give this one more crack. Marr as a name does NOT give clues as to the scuminess of the player. If Marr was revealed earlier it wouldn't matter. The fact that I know Marr is NAP does not actually hurt or help Marr staying alive. I would have to convince everyone that I wasn't lying. If Marr wanted to he could counter claim versus me and we could all play it out. The fact that Marr hasn't revealed themselves simply lends credence to my role and to the purpose of a name seer, which seems evident through Waterbat's slip of Molach being a drone. I'm really not sure how else to try and get it across that I'm a villager, Waterbats a villager, Marr is NAP and there is a name seer.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Maniac Wrote:Either he's scared of being lynched, or both you and Marr are NAP.
So you believe that Marr exists? And you believe Marr is a villager hiding in fear for his life while I a NAP member walks around trying to get him lynched? Or you believe that Marr is NAP, I'm NAP as well and that I'm doing all of this... why?
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Maniac Wrote:Either both waterbat and Molach are NAP, or novice scanned Molach for his role.
Right so waterbat as NAP slips up and tells everyone that his NAP partner Molach is a drone? That just doesn't happen. Also if waterbat found out the role through novice, you don't think he would keep that information locked up tight? That he wouldn't be more careful about revealing himself? So how do you explain the fact that Waterbat actually did contact me and that we are able to send PMs back and forth to each other. How do you reconcile that with your current conspiracy theory here?
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Lewwyn, the rules dont state name indicated scumminess. it says it doesnt influence chance to be killed, clearly being Marr if you are telling the truth 'hurt you stay alive'.
Look if you are telling the truth, then sorry but bigger screwed you over here.
Oh and i think both you and Marr are NAP
Posts: 5,157
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2011
Lewwyn Wrote:Right so waterbat as NAP slips up and tells everyone that his NAP partner Molach is a drone? That just doesn't happen. Also if waterbat found out the role through novice, you don't think he would keep that information locked up tight? That he wouldn't be more careful about revealing himself? So how do you explain the fact that Waterbat actually did contact me and that we are able to send PMs back and forth to each other. How do you reconcile that with your current conspiracy theory here?
I can easily explain things by waterbat being village and 'mr day 3' being NAP
Posts: 491
Threads: 3
Joined: Jun 2012
Lewwyn Wrote:Right so waterbat as NAP slips up and tells everyone that his NAP partner Molach is a drone?
It's not because NAP waterbat tells everyone NAP Molach is a drone, that Molach is in fact a drone.
Quote:Also if waterbat found out the role through novice, you don't think he would keep that information locked up tight?
Revealing a villager Molach as drone, would strengthen waterbat's story that he was in contact with a nameseer.
Quote:So how do you explain the fact that Waterbat actually did contact me and that we are able to send PMs back and forth to each other.
Why do you assume I believe you?
Posts: 491
Threads: 3
Joined: Jun 2012
Oh yeah, let's not forget the villagers win if "all threats to humanity are destroyed". An argument to say both Marr and H'minee are NAP.
Bobchillingworth
Unregistered
Quote:Lewwyn, the rules dont state name indicated scumminess. it says it doesnt influence chance to be killed, clearly being Marr if you are telling the truth 'hurt you stay alive'.
Yes. Obviously being named "Marr" could be hazardous to one's survival, given what Lewwyn told us on day one. So, idk, maybe Marr has a fake name they could safely claim publicly? And maybe that's why we would have a name seer, to find out who Marr *really* is???
Posts: 12,335
Threads: 46
Joined: Jan 2011
Oh shit... I was given a fake name to claim. 
I was told in the role PM that I could safely claim to be a human librarian to sneak into the planetary conference. I misread that earlier. I guess bigger didn't screw me over in that regard. I'm betting Marr received something similar since we're both aliens.
Well fuck it. It doesn't change anything about who I am. But it does give credence to the idea that Marr was given a disguise.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Posts: 3,045
Threads: 2
Joined: Aug 2006
Bobchillingworth Wrote:Yes. Obviously being named "Marr" could be hazardous to one's survival, given what Lewwyn told us on day one. So, idk, maybe Marr has a fake name they could safely claim publicly? And maybe that's why we would have a name seer, to find out who Marr *really* is??? Yep...
|
