[SPOILER] ww15 Lurker thread - No living players allowed!

[Gaspar]

Man, if Waterbat isn't NAP... hoo boy. That is some Roland in WW7-esque confusion sowing.

[Bigger]

Man, if Waterbat isn't NAP... hoo boy. That is some Roland in WW7-esque confusion sowing.

wasn't Roland a wolf in ww7?

I must admit I couldnt finish that one, it was hard enough getting through Roland's massive WOTs in ww2.

[Bigger]

Man, if Waterbat isn't NAP... hoo boy. That is some Roland in WW7-esque confusion sowing.

and, yes... there have been many people sowing confusion in this game (both intentionally and unintentionally). The setup was designed to introduce SOME confusion, but I severely underestimated how much confusion would be introduced by the players, so its gotten out of hand

[Serdoa]

Well if NAP, well played. If village it just goes to show that keeping all your information to yourself because of some belief that you can outsmart everyone with your knowledge is just bad play. And I think in this game we had many villagers who thought it is smarter to keep everything a secret. Together with all the out-of-thread talking roles that led to a very boring start of the game. I honestly believe that NAP would have won this easily if we hadn't gotten novice D2. Might be wrong, I still don't know the whole setup of course, but taking away from the discussions in the game-thread (via roles) is severely hindering the village.

(And it didn't help that some villagers thought it was best to scream "Kill me" in the game-thread...)

[Bigger]

Well if NAP, well played. If village it just goes to show that keeping all your information to yourself because of some belief that you can outsmart everyone with your knowledge is just bad play. And I think in this game we had many villagers who thought it is smarter to keep everything a secret. Together with all the out-of-thread talking roles that led to a very boring start of the game. I honestly believe that NAP would have won this easily if we hadn't gotten novice D2. Might be wrong, I still don't know the whole setup of course, but taking away from the discussions in the game-thread (via roles) is severely hindering the village.

(And it didn't help that some villagers thought it was best to scream "Kill me" in the game-thread...)

really? other than Lewwyn not mentioning his limited vig shot, who kept a secret they shouldnt have? I think the village was way to free with information, just about everybody confessed to about everything they had, except maybe Qgqqq (who never had any results with his tracking ability, unfortunately, so no reason to step forward).

[Gaspar]

wasn't Roland a wolf in ww7?

I must admit I couldnt finish that one, it was hard enough getting through Roland's massive WOTs in ww2.

You're missing out, wolves were absolutely brilliant. One in particular...

But yeah he was a wolf, that was my point. NAP or village he's only hurting the village here.

[Gaspar]

Well if NAP, well played. If village it just goes to show that keeping all your information to yourself because of some belief that you can outsmart everyone with your knowledge is just bad play. And I think in this game we had many villagers who thought it is smarter to keep everything a secret. Together with all the out-of-thread talking roles that led to a very boring start of the game. I honestly believe that NAP would have won this easily if we hadn't gotten novice D2. Might be wrong, I still don't know the whole setup of course, but taking away from the discussions in the game-thread (via roles) is severely hindering the village.

(And it didn't help that some villagers thought it was best to scream "Kill me" in the game-thread...)

Also disagree here. If I had gotten one of those dreams I'd have dismissed it as nonsense and never mentioned it, which would have saved reams of virtual paper and ink spilled on nothing that's remotely helping the village.

[Bigger]

Also disagree here. If I had gotten one of those dreams I'd have dismissed it as nonsense and never mentioned it, which would have saved reams of virtual paper and ink spilled on nothing that's remotely helping the village.

agreed.

[Serdoa]

But thats the point. Stuff which is not helpful at all was mentioned like no tomorrow (like the dreams - which imo are not wrong to be mentioned but if you get one you certainly can take some time to think about it first) while other (helpful) discussion was held in secret. Look at the neighbours or Molachs diary. Or Sareln not mentioning his theories on Selrahc. Though maybe I just feel that way and there was really not kept that much secret.

Btw: Lewwyn was right not mentioning his vig-shots, but I didn't mean abilities. Obviously those should be kept secret if possible.

[Sareln]

But thats the point. Stuff which is not helpful at all was mentioned like no tomorrow (like the dreams - which imo are not wrong to be mentioned but if you get one you certainly can take some time to think about it first) while other (helpful) discussion was held in secret. Look at the neighbours or Molachs diary. Or Sareln not mentioning his theories on Selrahc. Though maybe I just feel that way and there was really not kept that much secret.

Btw: Lewwyn was right not mentioning his vig-shots, but I didn't mean abilities. Obviously those should be kept secret if possible.

I didn't mention my Selrahc theory because it didn't hold together at all everytime I thought about it... that and I couldn't afford to split attention between more than one or two people if I wanted to make a successful defense I think.