WW16: The Outlaws and The Olives

[Injera]

but why in the hell would I feel a need to justify my first vote of the day?

Well, you did. At least that's the way I read it. "My vote on X was a joke vote, but he was suspicious for reason Y. Also, reason Z which supports reason Y." If there's a different way to read it, or you meant something differently than what came out, feel free to clarify.

As for why you would justify your "joke" vote? Maybe you're a wolf and started feeling a little heat. Zak mentioned the hostile tone, but that whole post was overreacting to a pair of innocent early votes. So you throw in a parenthetical "well, it was a joke vote but it wasn't a bad vote" justification.

I do enjoy your stealthy "Day 1 asides can matter" trying to plant a seed for a later screed no doubt. Deciding if its worth taking the Pepsi Challenge to see if you can mislynch me in the quiktopic? :oldwink:

Uh, no. It was a reference to WW12, when Ichabod correctly called out on an innocuous line on Day 1. Really, though, this whole statement is delusional. I'm not a wolf but even if I was I wouldn't do any of that.

[BRickAstley]

Official Lynch Vote Count
Players needed to lynch: 14

tasunke - 3 - novice, Sareln, Merovech
Gaspar - 2 - Bigger, Injera
Molach - 2 - zakalwe, Gaspar
Waterbat - 2 - Catwalk, Azza
novice - 1 - uberfish
Qgqqqqq - 1 - Lewwyn
Pindicator - 1 - Waterbat
Bigger - 1 - Pindicator
Ichabod - 1 - Qgqqqqq
Sareln - 1 - tasunke
Selrahc - 1 - Molach
Lewwyn - 1 - Rowain

Players not voting: Arromir, Ichabod, Jkaen, Mattimeo, Meiz, Selrahc, Serdoa, thestick, Twinkletoes89


Official Mayor Vote Count
Players needed to vote in: 14

Rowain - 4 - Gaspar, Rowain, uberfish, Azza
Lewwyn - 2 - Sareln, tasunke
novice - 2 - novice, Injera
uberfish - 2 - zakalwe, thestick
zakalwe - 2 - Pindicator, Lewwyn
Twinkletoes89 - 1 - Bigger
Waterbat - 1 - Qgqqqqq

Players not voting: Arromir, Catwalk, Ichabod, Jkaen, Mattimeo, Meiz, Merovech, Molach, Selrahc, Serdoa, Twinkletoes89, Waterbat

[Catwalk]

Managed to have a very quick read through, I'm off in a minute. I stayed up late in order to make a post at game start, but of course it was pre-planned. I have a long list of opening moves to choose from depending on game settings and alignment, so of course I chose a villager opening for this one.

I'll be at a party convention this weekend, and I will be looking for wifi.

[Lewwyn]

I have a long list of opening moves to choose from depending on game settings and alignment, so of course I chose a villager opening for this one.

You have one that announces you are mafia instead?

[Mattimeo]

Wait, I'm a wine connoisseur? That doesn't seem right, at all...

Don't feel comfortable jumping on a lynch vote this early on Day 1.

However, I fully support high levels of paranoia in a mayoral candidate, in a game focused so much on double guessing EVERYTHING. Rowain.

[Serdoa]

So you hint that there are lots of metagame possibilities, but don't want to bring them up yourself, and also insinuate that a wolf would have tons to work with here. Subtly bringing it up so you can pounce on someone who runs with it? Or just way into the start?

Seriously, I was so sick of all the meta nonsense last game (which you were a big proponent of, being scum, but that was last game). It pissed me off how much that got carried and perpetuated. So if you continue down the meta road I will vote and shout and cry on you until you start acting sensible.

I'm too sick of it. Nearly as much as I am sick of badly made-up votes... speaking of that:

Fortunately you aren't the biggest offender so far, waterbat. But you're on my watch list.

I wonder how many day 1 votes it would take to get Gaspar to blow up this time?

I also think Twinkletoes is a safe vote for mayor. He gave me a great haircut last week and seems like a swell guy.

+1 - I'm the milkman, but I'm actually lactose intolerant

I'm no fan of bureaucrats, but Catwalk seems harmless enough so far, and I want to see how far he can role-play a bureaucrat

Serdoa is the chef. If you take his job, he'll have to be the town drunk - and clearly you are made for that job!

Garbage collector = sanitation worker = the "legit" job of mafioso (at least American mafioso). Probably a bad joke playing on lewwyn's eagerness to be scum, and makes me think he rolled village once again. Or could just be an oversight by Brick

Bigger

You know pindicator, I REALLY am sick of meta-discussions and I'd vote in a heartbeat for anyone trying to start a discussion on if the "role" of a player does mean something. But out of your 4 Bigger-quotes there is only 1 which could be attributed to that, the last one about Lewwyn. All the others? Obviously joking around. That leads me to what I wrote first: I hate made-up votes, and your vote on Bigger is just made-up in order to vote for him. You can't tell me that you didn't see yourself that his quotes and your "reason" for voting for him don't really match. Therefore

pindicator[/quote]

And for mayor: [color=Cyan]uberfish

[Serdoa]

pindicator

One should close the same tags he opens...

[Molach]

Not going to be 100% available during daytime, but when my youngling goes to bed I'll have the house to myself.

So Sareln votes Tasunke for acting weird? Curious. Merovech, read the first day of last game. I figure that when Tasunke starts acting completely rational and calculating is when he should be lynched.

And Gaspar, when I'm scum I would exaggerate the ligitime reasons I had for absense, to avoid posting and outing myself & fellow wolves. But that first game I really was cut off for 3 days. Recent game I could probably have posted more by phone (once I figured out how to use it abroad), but I told myself "too expensive" to use phone and "wife won't be happy" and "hey this is a great excuse to shut up" so I upgraded my extremely limited avaliability to total disconnection.

And I like uberfish for mayor.

[Jkaen]

Going to open with Merovech as my lynch for putting on the last vote to try and get Tansuke to role claim (which on day 1 needs about 2 votes!)

As for Mayor I think Villager Novice has good snap judgements

[Rowain]

Official Lynch Vote Count
Players needed to lynch: 14

Official Mayor Vote Count
Players needed to vote in: 14

What do you mean with playeers needed to lynch??? I thought the one with the most votes at the end of day gets lynched not an instadeath once someone reaches majority. Same for mayor or?

On that topic, can we ban the mayor self-votes?

If you want then I vote for my friend the bartender: Merovech. Thats a few free drinks for me right?

Going to open with Merovech as my lynch for putting on the last vote to try and get Tansuke to role claim (which on day 1 needs about 2 votes!)

Jkaen