Generally it's good to keep PR's hidden. Granted this one isn't hugely powerful, but there's also the aspect of 'don't claim vanilla town and narrow down the suspect pool'. I wasn't on the block, so didn't need to claim for self preservation. I could see a bit of value if I happen to vote a scum, and his buddies thought he was safe so didn't swap, then he finds a noose anyway. Honestly was hoping that would happen to Brick, only he turned out to be innocent Kept hoping the topic would be dropped and you'd move on to important stuff.
But then I woke up this morning and saw tons and tons of discussion on the extra vote, in lieu of scumhunting. Figured I'd better stop you guys from wasting more time. Especially because Lewwyn and Mattimeo have both denied it, and I wasn't voting with Sareln, so it was going to be obvious soon anyway. And...it's not like being a seer, revealing it isn't a suicide move.
I still wish you guys hadn't forced my hand, now the scum have more info on power roles. But revealing seemed the lesser evil at this point.
Mattimeo Wrote:gee, thanks for invalidating most of the actual thought I've put into this game :P
Y'know...I can see Serdoa's point on you, Mattimeo. Tons of thought on meta, especially the piece that scum didn't know the answer on, but none on actual suspects? You don't even have Coco's excuse, you've been around. At least with Coco, his project might complete and he'd find more time to contribute afterward.
(November 16th, 2012, 11:01)coco Wrote: I have a deadline nov 21, someone decided it is very important to build a road in the middle of nowhere in the middle of the winter.
Did they decide this after you signed up for this game? If swedish bureaucracy is anything like norwegian bureaucracy, I doubt it.
(November 16th, 2012, 11:01)coco Wrote: I hope to be done before wednesday, but I don't count on it
If you want to be rid of me now go ahead and lynch me, I probably wont be able to give any more time to this than I have so far until middle of next week anyway.
Yeah I want to lynch you, nothing personal. You've contributed nothing so far, acted suspiciously IMO, and you will continue this for another 2 game days. This is a fast paced game, in 2 days we might be at Lynch Or Lose.
(November 16th, 2012, 12:34)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: ever since Molach's wolf game where he kept making excuses for being absent, I don't think a free pass should be given.
But that's what you're giving him. He just said he'd keep up the lurking for another 2 days. Better to lynch him now, in that case.
(November 16th, 2012, 12:34)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: If I had the chance to kill as a bad guy, I would have gone for someone claiming Sansa Stark who would clearly be a loyalist.
You know, scum normally don't have to guess who's town.
(November 16th, 2012, 12:34)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: I feel like he has hung on the name claim issue of Rowain since its happened, yet in one post I have explained the concerns about it a lot better than he ever has.
@coco Little time is one thing but your actions so far has been a ) parroting vote against me without any reasoning on your own. and a selfdefense vote on Mattimeo.
Why not on Lewwyn who at the time of your post had the same number of votes as Mattimeo?
(November 16th, 2012, 12:34)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: I'm not a fan of Rowain's implicit character reveal. .... But I do wonder why he did it.
tell me what part of:
(November 16th, 2012, 05:23)Rowain Wrote: And why I did it? Because it looked like a fun thing to do for me with all those talk about wolves.
(November 16th, 2012, 12:34)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: If I had the chance to kill as a bad guy, I would have gone for someone claiming Sansa Stark who would clearly be a loyalist.
You know, scum normally don't have to guess who's town.
(November 16th, 2012, 12:34)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: I feel like he has hung on the name claim issue of Rowain since its happened, yet in one post I have explained the concerns about it a lot better than he ever has.
Which post is that?
If there wasn't the possibility of a third party being involved, then yes the scum wouldn't have to guess who is town.
And the post you talk about is the same post you have quoted three times. I hope you read it all and didn't just pull out the bits you wanted.
"You want to take my city of Troll%ng? Go ahead and try."
(November 16th, 2012, 12:34)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: I'm not a fan of Rowain's implicit character reveal. .... But I do wonder why he did it.
tell me what part of:
(November 16th, 2012, 05:23)Rowain Wrote: And why I did it? Because it looked like a fun thing to do for me with all those talk about wolves.
do you not understand?
You don't strike me as that kind of player Rowain. I can see that talk of wolves and linking it to direwolves isn't exactly a long stretch, it just seems odd to do it for 'just fun'.
You may be right but I just feel like someone like you wouldn't have done that for simply that reason. Why I am not voting for you is because I don't have a clue as to whether that reason is pro-village or not. Its a move which, in certain circumstances, could be used as a village or a wolf ploy.
"You want to take my city of Troll%ng? Go ahead and try."
Coco-
What are you observing in game? You've already made it clear you have limited time, so use what time you have to make observations. Ibviously you're paying close enough attention to see that mattineo had passed lewwyn to be your defensive vote. What else are you noticing?
Serdoa-
The post was around 24hrs ago. Dont have time to dig for it on the phone right now. Gonna be at work through deadline
(November 16th, 2012, 12:34)Twinkletoes89 Wrote: I'm not a fan of Rowain's implicit character reveal. .... But I do wonder why he did it.
tell me what part of:
(November 16th, 2012, 05:23)Rowain Wrote: And why I did it? Because it looked like a fun thing to do for me with all those talk about wolves.
do you not understand?
You don't strike me as that kind of player Rowain. I can see that talk of wolves and linking it to direwolves isn't exactly a long stretch, it just seems odd to do it for 'just fun'.
You may be right but I just feel like someone like you wouldn't have done that for simply that reason. Why I am not voting for you is because I don't have a clue as to whether that reason is pro-village or not. Its a move which, in certain circumstances, could be used as a village or a wolf ploy.
Just out of interest: what kind of player am I in you opinion? And why won't i make such an easy link and joke?
Kept hoping the topic would be dropped and you'd move on to important stuff.
