WW17 - A Game of Thrones

[Mattimeo]

GG Mattimeo

not particularly

[pindicator]

GG Mattimeo

not particularly

Well, I thought it was better than one person's, at least

[Rowain]

Bye Mattimeo

@uber: The thestick-vote on coco in the final tally should be Rowain but the numbers seem to be right

[Jkaen]

Caught up to post 150 here now, the pressure on Mattimeo seems a bit odd, couldnt really work out the source of all that.

Tansuke however I started to feel was acting just a bit too wierd and odd

[Azza]

4 dead, all loyal. Not feeling great about our chances right now, especially with another couple of night kills likely coming up. Hopefully there's some scum crossfire in there...


Some of the things that stand out to me, as I try to organise my thoughts during the night while nothings happening.


I still think (night results pending) Coco needs to be policy lynched unless he can really start contributing. I just hope like hell he's scum, coz he's done practically nothing for us.

I'm beginning to feel uneasy on Mardoc and whether his double vote is truly a town ability. Scum wouldn't make sense from a meta perspective, but anti-town third party could especially if he had some sort of self-preservation ability.

Twinkletoes and Tasunke both seem completely and utterly crazy. I have no reliable scum or town read on either of them, but neither seems to be particularly productive.

I don't like Rowain's nameclaim either. I have no idea what it means, as I haven't read or watched GoT (although I do intend on doing so at some point), but "just for fun" doesn't strike me as the sort of thing Rowain would do. He typically seems focused and aggressive, a jovial post like that is completely out of character compared to what I'd expect.

The only person I'm genuinely getting a village read on is Lewwyn. I find it so hard to believe he'd have made his Loki mistake if he were scum, and his attitude since that mishap has only solidified it in my mind. If he's scum, he's a damn good actor.

[Rowain]

About Lewwyn: Thats BS. He knows full well that he will be far easier lynched as Loki than as Lewwyn. Had an unknown player named Loki tried that stunt with its mass of 'misinterpretations' (to not say lies) vs me on day 2 he would be swinging from the gallow right now.

If there are 2 packs then those are naturally rather small (2/pack) and in this circumstances I'm absolutly sure Lewwyn will/would return to his real name.

Of course so far there is no proof that it was done on purpose but I would not take that as a sign of his villagerishness.

[Rowain]

There are currently 14 games where i played in and the majority of them I was village and in some of them I did make jokes so perhaps you stop parroting others and start to think for yourself. Else you find yourself led by the nose with traitors doing the leading.

[zakalwe]

What happened to the ability to search for psots by user?

On Mattimeo, I don't think that he'd be careless enough to launch such a faulty case on Tasunke if he was a wolf. Heh, people who are acting very weird are looking village to me
On Lewwyn, the whole 'I can't think of anything' thing sounded like myself from 15, but Lewwyn isn't supposed to remind me of myself.

Look, you only have one game to get a wolf baseline from me. There is no history. But let me tell you. I was in favor of killing off Bigger when I was a wolf. I was fine with the Zak kill but Bigger was my choice. Why? because I think he's more dangerous than Zak. If anything last game should tell you that I have a penchant for getting rid of Bigger. And the fact that I didn't take the opportunity to vote for Bigger yesterday should be a village tell. I respect Bigger's game a lot more than most people here. I think he's dangerous. But I also started to think he was innocent yesterday and I kept my vote on Brick who I believed to be scum.

Hang on, 'You should disregard my wolf play from last game, but my wolf play from last game indicates that I'm villager this game.' Wha?
Lewwyn

Lewwyn, what are your thoughts about this post, now that you've slept on it?

[Mardoc]

Dang it, Mattimeo, why'd you have to look so suspicious?

Sorry...

I'm beginning to feel uneasy on Mardoc and whether his double vote is truly a town ability. Scum wouldn't make sense from a meta perspective, but anti-town third party could especially if he had some sort of self-preservation ability.

I don't like this post at all. What is there about doublevoting that made you think 'oh, he has to be town?' I know that I'm a loyalist, but I don't see anything about my power that would prove that. Particularly in an Uberfish game.

And why is it 'beginning to feel uneasy' - about the power, and not about me? Why not a simple 'Mardoc's voted two villagers in two days, that's suspicious'? Because it's too direct? Because I'm by far not the only one with a bad record?

The rest of the post seems similar, trying to sprinkle some suspicion on a lot of people, indirectly and obliquely. Except of course for Lewwyn. He's literally the only one looking innocent to you, Azza?

[uberfish]

Confirming that night deadline is still 2200 and I'll be late with the resolutions.

please dont post between deadline -> resolutions