WW17 - A Game of Thrones

[Tasunke]

teeeeeaaaaaase :P

[Azza]

There are currently 14 games where i played in and the majority of them I was village and in some of them I did make jokes so perhaps you stop parroting others and start to think for yourself. Else you find yourself led by the nose with traitors doing the leading.

It might be an unfair characterisation, but that's the general impression I've gotten from you. You don't seem like someone who would do something like that just for fun.

Dang it, Mattimeo, why'd you have to look so suspicious?

Sorry...

I'm beginning to feel uneasy on Mardoc and whether his double vote is truly a town ability. Scum wouldn't make sense from a meta perspective, but anti-town third party could especially if he had some sort of self-preservation ability.

I don't like this post at all. What is there about doublevoting that made you think 'oh, he has to be town?' I know that I'm a loyalist, but I don't see anything about my power that would prove that. Particularly in an Uberfish game.

And why is it 'beginning to feel uneasy' - about the power, and not about me? Why not a simple 'Mardoc's voted two villagers in two days, that's suspicious'? Because it's too direct? Because I'm by far not the only one with a bad record?

The rest of the post seems similar, trying to sprinkle some suspicion on a lot of people, indirectly and obliquely. Except of course for Lewwyn. He's literally the only one looking innocent to you, Azza?

My initial thought was that due to balance reasons double voting couldn't be a scum ability. But I was starting to think that an anti-town 3rd party was a possibility, since you'd need some significant assistance to win as an individual, and a double vote would be a significant help in achieving such a goal. I guess that I lean innocent on you though, since it's more likely to be a town ability.

Lewwyn is the only one I'd be at all confident in declaring as town. But even then, I'm open to arguments that prove otherwise.

But Coco. He was already my #1 candidate before last night, and with his biggest defender in Serdoa flipping scum he seems rather heavily implicated as being scum anyway.

[pindicator]

Varys the Spider, spymaster to two kings, was found dead in the courtyard of the castle. Apparently someone had taken exception to his sneaking about and thrown him out a window. His agenda was unknown.

Novice, Varys, Jack of All Trades Survivor was killed night 2

Wow, i just noticed that green did not mean loyal here. I'm guessing novice had some kind of flexible win agenda, hence the ambiguity at his death? That may explain his quiet nature this game.

[Lewwyn]

Varys the Spider, spymaster to two kings, was found dead in the courtyard of the castle. Apparently someone had taken exception to his sneaking about and thrown him out a window. His agenda was unknown.

Novice, Varys, Jack of All Trades Survivor was killed night 2

Wow, i just noticed that green did not mean loyal here. I'm guessing novice had some kind of flexible win agenda, hence the ambiguity at his death? That may explain his quiet nature this game.

That's why I said awesome. As a survivor he didn't care who got lynched as long as it wasn't him and he didn't get nightkilled.

[uberfish]

THE MANY-FACED GOD

And the god of death looked down from his palace of black and white and spoke

"WHO IS THIS FUCKING MINOR DEITY OF FUCKING FISH WHO DARES ASSUME THE IDENTITY OF MULTIPLE CHARACTERS AND DENY THE GOD OF DEATH HIS DUE AT THE APPOINTED TIME, ONLY DEATH MAY PAY FOR LIFE AND HE OWES ME THREE NAMES"

And the three names were spoken and they were:

Asha Greyjoy was found dead, apparently having been in King's Landing to buy a highly illegal rocket - I mean heavy crossbow that had been modified to shoot wildfire tipped bolts.

The mutilated head of Janos Slynt, commander of the city watch, was found mounted on a pike outside the Red Keep. A search of his office revealed that he had been deliberately interfering with the treason investigation.

Varys the Spider, spymaster to two kings, was found dead in the courtyard of the castle. Apparently someone had taken exception to his sneaking about and thrown him out a window. His agenda was unknown.


Pling, Asha Greyjoy, Lurker was killed night 2
Serdoa, Janos Slynt, Traitor Jailkeeper was killed night 2
Novice, Varys, Jack of All Trades Survivor was killed night 2

[BRickAstley]

*EDIT* Accidentally posted here instead of lurker thread.

[novice]

Good luck to all of you.

[Rowain]

I mean have you ever heard more waffling to not vote for Rowain and also vote for me?

Do you believe Serdoa do be dumb?

[zakalwe]

Poor Novice, pretty rough win condition for him. (I'm assuming it was to survive until the end.)

Neither Novice nor Serdoa felt entirely innocent to me, but it would have felt like a risky move to lynch them. So I think it's a real scoop to have them both killed in the night. We got all the information we could hope for, and more.

With Serdoa pushing both Lewwyn and Mattimeo, it doesn't look good for Coco.

I will reread to look for other clues too, but maybe not today.

[Jkaen]

Very interesting a wolf got night killed. If we assume the wolves (regicides/plotters/whatever) killed Novice (which makes sense) it does raise the question of who got Serdoa (and I guess Brick last night?)